*** The Dean51 30-day ***
-
Spectacular list of participants already :o :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh

-
Since it has never been brought up and we have several members with these now... The Christy knife is one I have been carrying lately and has been in production since 1936 (relatively unchanged I might add ;) ) will it be allowed in this challenge


I would say yes
but will leave final call up to Nix and some of you other trad aficionados :D -
I have to recuse myself and defer to those who are the standard bearers for the Traditional category. I'm not expert enough to make that call. :D
I'd agree that given its longevity and unchanging nature the Christy could be a traditional. It is not what I picture when I think of a "traditional", but in thinking about it, I'd say "heck, yeah."
So I'll second the motion to permit the Christy, but, again, I defer to wiser heads.

-
I will be using this GEC. I carried this with me in Iraq 2008-2009




-
That dog will hunt!

-
I'll second that!!
-
:o 
@Nix said:
I have to recuse myself and defer to those who are the standard bearers for the Traditional category. I'm not expert enough to make that call. :DI'd agree that given its longevity and unchanging nature the Christy could be a traditional. It is not what I picture when I think of a "traditional", but in thinking about it, I'd say "heck, yeah."
So I'll second the motion to permit the Christy, but, again, I defer to wiser heads.

Well, I have one vote in my favor
;) :DI have plenty of trads to pick from if this doesn't get voted in and will likely do as I always do and carry many different ones

-
-
Having been carrying, using and researching the Christy knife the last couple of months. This is a question I've pondered many times as to whether the Christy qualifies as a traditional knife or not. Most traditional knives are considered as slip joint or as the English called them spring knives which I think is a better term. There were other type knives in use during this time frame also. Since I seldom like to take the long way around the barn when you can walk straight thru it. So when all things are considered I think the Christy does qualify as a traditional knife. The purist among us will surely squall but so be it. Let'um squall. Since this Challenge is to honor Dean I might suggest along with Steve to carry regular traditional knives as much as possible when you can along with your Christy if you choose to use the Christy.
:D -
@Deathtakeslast said:
I will be using this GEC. I carried this with me in Iraq 2008-2009Good choice!

-
@David said:
Having been carrying, using and researching the Christy knife the last couple of months. This is a question I've pondered many times as to whether the Christy qualifies as a traditional knife or not. Most traditional knives are considered as slip joint or as the English called them spring knives which I think is a better term. There were other type knives in use during this time frame also. Since I seldom like to take the long way around the barn when you can walk straight thru it. So when all things are considered I think the Christy does qualify as a traditional knife. The purist among us will surely squall but so be it. Let'um squall. Since this Challenge is to honor Dean I might suggest along with Steve to carry regular traditional knives as much as possible when you can along with your Christy if you choose to use the Christy.
:D
-
Ok, cool
I will carry as many different ones as I can
but if I happen to forget another trad then the Christy will still be there 
Dean would like that it is stainless steel but might not like that we don't know what kind :D
-
Now, whilst starting to gear up for this I collected what I think I might carry. In order not to break them Rules I’d like to request for prior ruling.
These might be carried:

Now, the ones opened are the ones I’m wondering about.
Does CRKT Eros qualify? A Deejo? CRKT Art Deco? The Colt Freedom or the no name blue plastic scaled one?


Was it so, that anything by Vic/Wenger was outruled?
-
I'd say the Colt is ok and it looks really nice too, the others not that traditional as far as I am concerned. Let's see what the others think.
Yes, Vic/Wenger are traditional, but we already have a ton of challenges for SAKs, so they can sit this one out. -
I think you will be fine with 5 of those Lefty, there was also a no pocket clip, no thumb stud / thumb hole rule and yep no Vics or Wengers

-
^ and ^^
Thank you gents! The no pocket clip or thumb studs rules will disqualify the Eros, the Walker and the Winchester it seems.Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
The Canoe and one next to it, the brass and wood folding hunter and the Barlow and Colt are the ones i would say would be fine but yep we will wait and see what others think

-
Nice collection there Lefty

I think Buck 110 and alikes were ruled out too

-
Even if we have a challenge or 2 for the Bucks I think they would be able to be in this challenge

I would think the top 5, the Colt and the Barlow should be fine but then again I am not the one making the rules here
:DThe line does get blurred a bit when determining a trad these days because so many of the traditional designs were so good that they have made it into new modern designs as well

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

