Combo Edge Cooperative - partial to partially serrated blades
-
With discussions of 2022 challenges underway I wanted to start drumming up some interest in a Combo Edge Challenge for February/Mar 2022 (what timeframe can be more appropriate?)
There are lots of tools that qualify, and lots of tools that people carry daily without any issue (though often with a secondary plain edge blade)
At this point, I'm thinking of doing the challenge with the Skeletool.
Anyone else interested? It's a long way away, but... might as well start planning early.

-
I’d be in EB

-
I would be interested too.

-
I guess I could use the Signal and get its badge, unless this gets its own dedicated one.

-

@Alan K. said:
I would be interested too.

@ReamerPunch said:
I guess I could use the Signal and get its badge, unless this gets its own dedicated one.
That's an idea - if we don't get enough people to get a Combo Edge badge, it makes good sense to use a tool that already has one, like a...
Signal,
Swisstool Spirit (with butter blade),
Leatherman MUT,
Spyderco,
SOG Powerlock
Victorinox Soldier or 111mm
Skeletool
Gerber MP 400
or even the Discontinued MT or Off Brand MT badgesLots of great options

-
Do the serrated blades of the Wave/Surge/Rebar/ST300 count? :D
Seriously. That tiny plain edge tip of the ST300 serrated blade is just brilliant.
I usually use those for short draw cuts. Nothing too ambitious. But I had to wrap a birthday present, so I did a draw cut of about 50cm, about 1.5 ft. Man, did it knock it out of the park! I kept a steady hand, and dragged the blade tip along a straight line, and the wrapping was easy as pie.

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Do the serrated blades of the Wave/Surge/Rebar/ST300 count? :D
Seriously. That tiny plain edge tip of the ST300 serrated blade is just brilliant.
I usually use those for short draw cuts. Nothing too ambitious. But I had to wrap a birthday present, so I did a draw cut of about 50cm, about 1.5 ft. Man, did it knock it out of the park! I kept a steady hand, and dragged the blade tip along a straight line, and the wrapping was easy as pie.

I'm thinking that they don't
If it's like the Wave-OG or ST-OG, it's really a dedicated serrated blade. That tiny plain edge benefits from the chisel grind that many of these combo edge blades have. Especially when you use it along a straight edge like a ruler or a square... you know exactly where your edge is. For regulation purposes, I'd say it has to be one of the blades that was intended for use as a combo edge, like the Skeletool. ;)I friend of mine has been carrying a part serrated knife for most if his life... for the last few years it's been a SOG.... SOG Flash, or something similar. The other day he asked me to run it through the carbide "sharpener" I happened to have - the blade was chisel ground, but really nicely done. That knife of his was well worn, and had many stories to tell. It wasn't well kept, but it was used over and over and over again - and that's the important thing... isn't it?

-

No use going with a tool I've carried previously anyway. I'll go with the Signal maybe. I also have a Wingman. Weird. I can't think of any more, though I am sure I have more with combo edges. I must.
-
@ReamerPunch said:

No use going with a tool I've carried previously anyway. I'll go with the Signal maybe. I also have a Wingman. Weird. I can't think of any more, though I am sure I have more with combo edges. I must.
Yep, and there's plenty of time before next February to acquire some more
So far, I'm thinking of splitting the 30 days between a Skeletool KBX and a Victorinox Nomad. My Skeletool is the Topo edition, and I can't bring myself to scuff up the blade. 
-

That's an idea - if we don't get enough people to get a Combo Edge badge, it makes good sense to use a tool that already has one, like a...
Signal,
Swisstool Spirit (with butter blade),
Leatherman MUT,
Spyderco,
SOG Powerlock
Victorinox Soldier or 111mm
Skeletool
Gerber MP 400
or even the Discontinued MT or Off Brand MT badgesLots of great options

I could be up for this as well. I quite like the combo edge as it comes in handy for SAR stuff and, if I use my Gerber (work issue before the Surge trial) then it's handy for that as well

So, here are my current options (can't use my Skele as the CX is P/E :'( ::) )

-
@SurgeUk said:
I could be up for this as well. I quite like the combo edge as it comes in handy for SAR stuff and, if I use my Gerber (work issue before the Surge trial) then it's handy for that as well
So, here are my current options (can't use my Skele as the CX is P/E :'( ::) )
Those are some good options SurgeUk

They do come in very handy for rescue, as long as you're careful in the event you're cutting clothing. The Vic Rescue has a blunted tip which makes it safer. For the Wingman and Gerber MP 400, it's helpful to run the edge across the material you're cutting such as a strap or seatbelt, and get the feedback in your hand as to which edge works better... often it's the serrated edge to start the cut and plain edge to finish it off.

-
@ElevenBlade said:
Those are some good options SurgeUk
They do come in very handy for rescue, as long as you're careful in the event you're cutting clothing. The Vic Rescue has a blunted tip which makes it safer. For the Wingman and Gerber MP 400, it's helpful to run the edge across the material you're cutting such as a strap or seatbelt, and get the feedback in your hand as to which edge works better... often it's the serrated edge to start the cut and plain edge to finish it off.

Absolutely EB and my first choice is the RT on my load vest and I carry the Wingman as back-up (on my duty belt)
TBH most of the rescue type scenarios we are involved in are urban/semi-rural and tend to be suicidal types (hanging) where seconds can make a difference.
Moreover, given their circumstances (strangulation etc) I need to be able to cut them down from a rope, or other type of ligature, very quickly and in that case, if possible, I need to preserve the knot for evidential purposes (without losing sight of the primary purpose of course)
I don't recall ever needing to cut a seatbelt, as we don't get called for road traffic collisions (RTCs) and equally, I've never needed to cut clothing off.
Obviously, things change and I tend to choose the type of kit specific to the call out; day/night etc. and of course terrain (not many mountains here though) ;)
It's not a bad selection but I think I might need the Skele RX

-
@SurgeUk said:
Absolutely EB and my first choice is the RT on my load vest and I carry the Wingman as back-up (on my duty belt)TBH most of the rescue type scenarios we are involved in are urban/semi-rural and tend to be suicidal types (hanging) where seconds can make a difference.
Moreover, given their circumstances (strangulation etc) I need to be able to cut them down from a rope, or other type of ligature, very quickly and in that case, if possible, I need to preserve the knot for evidential purposes (without losing sight of the primary purpose of course)
I don't recall ever needing to cut a seatbelt, as we don't get called for road traffic collisions (RTCs) and equally, I've never needed to cut clothing off.
Obviously, things change and I tend to choose the type of kit specific to the call out; day/night etc. and of course terrain (not many mountains here though) ;)
It's not a bad selection but I think I might need the Skele RX

I was thinking of getting the glass breaker that comes with the Skeletool Rx and attaching it to my Skeletool Topo... just because. The Skeletool RX has a fullly serrated blade with deep serrations - more designed for ropes, clothes, and seatbelts. For that reason, I didn't got the the RX itself. The glass breaker fits into the bit driver.
Though my rescue days are in the past, I can't (don't want to) shake the mindset. My backup MT is a Gerber MP-600 with a fully serrated sheepfoot blade for .... just in case.
A combo edge blade does give you some of that extra utility, to be able to get through various types of material.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
When I was in my teenage years, I first got interested in edged tools by way of lockbacks that had serrations on the inner half of the blade. One of my friends would get these sorts of knives from a hardware store and would use them to within a millimeter of their limit. He would keep the plain edge razor sharp, and when he had sharpened the curved belly of the blade to a straight edge with the angles of a box cutter, he'd shelf the knife and get a new one. I envied how he could do precision work but also tear through rope and even metal tins with that knife.This began a series of both budget and brand name locking folders that I used for EDC.. Buck and Cold Steel being my favorites. When I switched to multiools, I rather liked having separate plain and serrated edges, starting with the Leatherman SuperTool. Meanwhile, another friend of mine started carrying the LM PST II for basic thinks when he went away to school. I have to admit that I was a bit jealous of his PST II, if only for the fact that it didn't have that finicky locking mechanism.
... ... ...
The Victorinox One Handed Trekker, and the Soldier have a combo edge. But in a twist, the serrations are on the outer two thirds - allowing for precision and leverage on the plain edge but allowing for momentum and slashing with the serrations.
... ... ...
All told, I think combo edges have their place. Victorinox has done a great job with them on certain tools, especially given the reverse configuration. The butter blade on the Vic Sprit hasn't let anyone down yet. Leatherman seems to continue to use them on the multiools that serve in a complimentary system for outdoor recreation with the Signal, Skeletool, and several of their knife based tools. Then going back to basics... For people that need a tool just to make life easier, there's the Wingman.
When you're not filleting a fish or carving a wooden spoon... When you have a plain edge blade on one tool and you have a complimentary tool with a combo edge... Or when you just want to pack as many options into an efficient multitool or even a folding knife... What are you carrying?
Big fan of combo blades. Left alone with only one blade, I might choose a combo, like a Spyderco Native combo.
To the discussion as to why most combo blades are serrated near the choil a d plain edge from midway to the tip, there are two very compelling reasons:
-
Skinning animals is done with the tip-end, and not accomplished well with a serrated blade.
-
If you think about the way rope is most often cut, it is doubled over, the blade placed inside the loop all the way to the hilt of the knife, and - from the choil/ hilt end - pulled from the center of your chest to one side, blade facing away.
For these reasons, serious combo edges have the serrations closer to the hand through center and plain edge from the center to the tip.
That doesnt mean the Victorinox combo edge is bad. It's already been outlined here just how that can be of help, but that's not the way combo edges are generally designed because that's not who they were initially designed for.
And no, I do not baton with any of my knives. I have a hatchet for that, and if I dont have that, I look for smaller wood to start.
One of my favorite combo edges, which got me into combo edges and serrated edges, was the LM PST II. When I find a multi tool with individual PE and SE, I go for that, as each has its place. But if I can only have one blade, I like it to be a combo, with serrations at the hand-end.
-
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
Big fan of combo blades. Left alone with only one blade, I might choose a combo, like a Spyderco Native combo.To the discussion as to why most combo blades are serrated near the choil a d plain edge from midway to the tip, there are two very compelling reasons:
-
Skinning animals is done with the tip-end, and not accomplished well with a serrated blade.
-
If you think about the way rope is most often cut, it is doubled over, the blade placed inside the loop all the way to the hilt of the knife, and - from the choil/ hilt end - pulled from the center of your chest to one side, blade facing away.
For these reasons, serious combo edges have the serrations closer to the hand through center and plain edge from the center to the tip.
That doesnt mean the Victorinox combo edge is bad. It's already been outlined here just how that can be of help, but that's not the way combo edges are generally designed because that's not who they were initially designed for.
And no, I do not baton with any of my knives. I have a hatchet for that, and if I dont have that, I look for smaller wood to start.
One of my favorite combo edges, which got me into combo edges and serrated edges, was the LM PST II. When I find a multi tool with individual PE and SE, I go for that, as each has its place. But if I can only have one blade, I like it to be a combo, with serrations at the hand-end.

to your point... some hunting/bushcraft type knives like the Esee come with combo edge options.
-
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
To the discussion as to why most combo blades are serrated near the choil a d plain edge from midway to the tip, there are two very compelling reasons:-
Skinning animals is done with the tip-end, and not accomplished well with a serrated blade.
-
If you think about the way rope is most often cut, it is doubled over, the blade placed inside the loop all the way to the hilt of the knife, and - from the choil/ hilt end - pulled from the center of your chest to one side, blade facing away.
For these reasons, serious combo edges have the serrations closer to the hand through center and plain edge from the center to the tip.

-
-
The serrations were not required in the making of "Chicken Ding" for Mrs Surge ;)

-
/topic/87756
I started a thread for the Combo Edge Challenge for next February

-
@ElevenBlade said:
/topic/87756I started a thread for the Combo Edge Challenge for next February

Joined

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
