Vintage SAK Owners Club
-
Judging by the rough execution of the scales and differing condition of the tools, it appears to be a hand-made combination of donor parts.
How well finished are the back springs, as this will also be a clue to whether or not it's a mod of an existing knife, or a one-off creation?

EDIT: I think it is not a Victorinox blade, as the marking appears carved and not stamped.

-
Some details




-
Some details,I believe this knife is made by hand. Will Vic in the 1930s make this kind of knife by hand?


-
Thanks for the additonal pictures.
I do not think this is a Victorinox knife. But it does look like it came from a factory, as the back springs and corkscrew are properly fabricated to work together.
I suspect that this is from a different factory (not Victorinox), and at some point, the main blade was replaced and someone engraved the Victorinox logo into the blade tang.
But this is only my opinion. There are experts on this forum that will probably be in a better position to comment...

-
@Max Stone said:
Thanks for the additonal pictures.I do not think this is a Victorinox knife. But it does look like it came from a factory, as the back springs and corkscrew are properly fabricated to work together.
I suspect that this is from a different factory (not Victorinox), and at some point, the main blade was replaced and someone engraved the Victorinox logo into the blade tang.
But this is only my opinion. There are experts on this forum that will probably be in a better position to comment...

Thank's for your opinion, Max stone! I've seen some early pocket knives (most of them were before the 1930s). They all have Vic stamps, but they're not in Vic product catalog. So I'm very confused. First , did Vic make some special products in the early stage? Second, it may be that other knife makers or shops use Vic parts for assembly, but have they been authorized by Vic?
-
Yes, I agree it is confusing and still a mystery.
The question I have is that it appears the blade marking is carved (engraved by hand), and not stamped as you would expect with a Victorinox mark - even the very early Victorinox marks would be stamped and not engraved.
I may be wrong about this, but if I am correct, then no part of this knife is from Victorinox. Maybe you can have a closer look at the Victorinox mark again, to see if it is stamped or engraved?


-
@Max Stone said:
Yes, I agree it is confusing and still a mystery.The question I have is that it appears the blade marking is carved (engraved by hand), and not stamped as you would expect with a Victorinox mark - even the very early Victorinox marks would be stamped and not engraved.
I may be wrong about this, but if I am correct, then no part of this knife is from Victorinox. Maybe you can have a closer look at the Victorinox mark again, to see if it is stamped or engraved?

I don't think it's a problem with this stamp. This is another stamp from Vic in the 1920s. They all used this technology in their early days


-
OK, you are correct. Then I think we need the experts to comment as the rest of the knife does not look Victorinox. Let's see what other comments you get for this interesting knife.

-
Ulli / Elsinox / JNOXYD ....... we need you!!! :D
-
Most things are already mentioned.
I would say: the mainblade is original from Victorinox, the rest not. The mainblade seems to be the only part that is inox steel. Victorinox did not produce such knives, at least I dont know of any. The knife seems to be much older that the mainblade.
It could have happened that way: mainblade got broken on the 1930s, the owner brought it to a knifemaker, who repaired the knife as good as he could and used spareparts that were available. That was very normal those days. The owner of the knife was happy, he had his loved knife back with an upgraded inox steel mainblade.
-
I agree with Ulli , knife body and other tools looks not Victorinox made (small blade nail nick, scissors, corkscrew). BTW I have
Victoria blade on non-Victorinox body also, blades swap was usual that times as Ulli said.
Probably Victorinox (Elsener Messer-Fabrik that days) made very close knife pattern. It’s not shown in known catalogs but looks well factory made. Victoria blade stamp, 1909-1930 according Ulli. It’s not mine to my regret.
Same knife was sold recently:
Sackmesser Victoria https://ricardo.ch/en/a/1177353610





-
@jnoxyd said:
I agree with Ulli , knife body and other tools looks not Victorinox made (small blade nail nick, scissors, corkscrew). BTW I have
Victoria blade on non-Victorinox body also, blades swap was usual that times as Ulli said.
Probably Victorinox (Elsener Messer-Fabrik that days) made very close knife pattern. It’s not shown in known catalogs but looks well factory made. Victoria blade stamp, 1909-1930 according Ulli. It’s not mine to my regret.
Same knife was sold recently:
Sackmesser Victoria https://ricardo.ch/en/a/1177353610





This knife is too beautiful! Is this also a blade exchange product? What is the reason for the blade swap? At that time, Vic also made knives by hand. Could it be customized according to customers' requirements?
-
@ulli said:
Most things are already mentioned.I would say: the mainblade is original from Victorinox, the rest not. The mainblade seems to be the only part that is inox steel. Victorinox did not produce such knives, at least I dont know of any. The knife seems to be much older that the mainblade.
It could have happened that way: mainblade got broken on the 1930s, the owner brought it to a knifemaker, who repaired the knife as good as he could and used spareparts that were available. That was very normal those days. The owner of the knife was happy, he had his loved knife back with an upgraded inox steel mainblade.
Your analysis is very reasonable.However, I feel that this main blade is not quite the same as the other 91mm main blades, especially the shape of the root. I do not seem to have a sample of the 91mm main blade from the 1930s, so I cannot make an accurate comparison.

-
I found another picture of a SAK that is not in the Vic catalog. It seems that several tools are made by Vick. What kind of situation does this knife belong to?

-
@xfile said:
This knife is too beautiful! Is this also a blade exchange product? What is the reason for the blade swap? At that time, Vic also made knives by hand. Could it be customized according to customers' requirements?I think these two knives are not "blade swap product". We have no Elsener catalogs from 1910s-1930s period and they can made this model that time. Of course we need more these knives to be sure.

-
The shape of your knife is different. Victorinox produced 2 lines of s-shaped knives, the Nr 1230 serie and the Nr 1240 series, 79 mm and 84 mm. The one shown from an auction is a nr 1239 or nr 1249.


-
@ulli said:
The shape of your knife is different. Victorinox produced 2 lines of s-shaped knives, the Nr 1230 serie and the Nr 1240 series, 79 mm and 84 mm. The one shown from an auction is a nr 1239 or nr 1249.Wow, what catalog is this? I've never seen such a picture about SAK. It's so sexy! I would appreciate it if you could share it with me.
BTW,the length of my knife is 88 mm 
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
