Small Blade vs Large Blade
-
...and with that elegant summary, this debate is now over

-
For decades I’ve been mostly using the small blade. And like many above I now primarily reserve the big blade for food. Just the other week at a picnic nobody brought any real knives for the baked chicken. Glad I had my Troublemaker with me. Especially since I’ve been carrying a Work Champ most days lately and a 111mm might have looked a bit out of place there.
And that leads me to this suggestion: If you want to see what life is like without the small blade, try a 111.
I do miss the familiarity of the small blade for most tasks when I have the Work Champ on me. Enough so that I’m rethinking some of my planned 111mm mods.
-
Large blade for food and feathersticks. Small blade for everything else.
I've been without a small blade for quite a while now. We just got off a 30DC of small SAKs. Honestly, I was hoping that the blade would be comparable to the small blade on the medium sized SAKs; and it really wasn't - the depth of the blade, I suppose.
Then there's the 111mm, and the 93mm that I use almost exclusively. It would be nice to have a small blade, but it's not a deal breaker.
I still use a SwissChamp or Champion often enough. But for EDC a Climber doesn't offer me an advantage over my usual... For now. So I'll still be without the small blade. Maybe someday...
-
@Steelej1976 said:
I really do find the small blade is safer for most jobs.
I'd have fewer scars if I thought like that.

-
The small blade is definitely one of my most used tools. Keeping the large blade clean for food is also a habit of mine. The Large blade also does work well for precision cuts on cigars, cutting plugs and other pipe tobacco. Another reason I like to keep the big blade clean is because of those purdy Tang stamps!

-
Small blade for everything, large blade when i need the extra length or the job at hand justifies it.
I never use my SAK's on food, generically...
-
I've carried my Pioneer X for long enough that I use the large blade on any given SAK by default. I can appreciate the mentality behind using the small blade more, though.
-
@Mad Scientist said:
I've carried my Pioneer X for long enough that I use the large blade on any given SAK by default. I can appreciate the mentality behind using the small blade more, though.On the 93mm knives, I tend to use the awl for a lot of tasks (e.g. cutting tape on packages), and reserve the blade for tasks that need truly require it.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
Me too - I'll also cut cardboard with the awl quite often+2 :D
The 93mm awl is a heavy duty "small blade"
-
I use the main blade on my Tinker mostly. Keep small blade (reshaped to clip) for delicate tasks needing a really sharp blade.
Rich -

This is what I do as well. Large blade as primary and small blade kept sharp for precision.
-
This is why I really like the electrician. The small blade is perfect for most of my needs. Now if Vic would make an Electrician-X I'd be ecstatic!
-
Another potential consideration is that, if you ever loan your knife to anyone (whether you should or shouldn’t do this, and if so under what circumstances/conditions, could be and I believe has been the topic of entire threads on its own), they are likely to go for the big blade first.
-
@pa_strunk said:
How about this?If I could make my own I'd swap out the large blade and pruner blade for an inline phillips and it would then be perfect.
-
Like your idea, you should do it. This I made off a Texas tool crib mod idea. It’s designed to carry with leatherman surge or MT without all the cutting options.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
.

