*** The Dean51 30-day ***
-
GEC Stockyard Whittler and the Mustang
David, I think it was about a year or two ago I asked you and Steve(possibly Dean too) which one of GECs would you consider is quintessential, and I remember one of them being 74 Mustang. Do you all still feel the same or would you think differently now?
I read on BF most folks seem to consider 15 and 23 as quintessential, but I love my 74 just as much, and can totally see that as being one of the tops.
@GA1dad said:
This evening I had to enlist the help of a non-traditional( per the rules ). The Schrade might have been able to whittle the cork out,,, but it was not the tool for the job.Quite like that Schrade, though it may have faded out a little. The scrimshaw on those are quite nice and eye pleasing.
@nate j said:
However, once you get to users in the $50 - $60 range, I think it will be difficult for “premium” RRs to compete with other manufacturers’ offerings IN THE SAME PRICE RANGE (not “more expensive”). These include (but aren’t limited to) US-made Bucks like the 301, 303, 501, 110, and 112; numerous offerings from Case; many Victorinox SAKs; etc.@GearedForwards said:
I'm not entirely sure what your point is then, if it isn't about it being US-made, then... it's about name recognition? Which I can get, but isn't really about the quality of the knife for the price (which should matter). Though if it was name recognition I'm not sure why mention US made at all.If it's about Rough Rider breaking into a higher price/production point then I totally see that, that's a hard transition for any company to make.
On price points, outside the US (Or the UK at least) by and large I don't think they're really competing all that much, Case etc. tend to be incredibly expensive for what you get here. If this works as a touchstone at all, a standard, no grooves Buck 110 is $100 from probably one of (if not the) most popular UK knife retailers. Small Case knives typically run $80+ for whatever mystery steel they use. When it comes down to value, named steel and reviews carry more weight (at least to me personally) than the name on it being x or y
Didn't mean to offend with any of this for the record, just like the discussion

All interesting reads here, and since I do collect a handful of Case/Buck/Vic in the 50-100 price points and a few RRRs, maybe I could offer a few cents here.
I think GearedForwards bring a really valid point here, for rest of the world, when sentimental value, brand loyalty and warranty program to traditional US brands are not the same as domestic US, these RRRs do offer decent value as an alternative, if not better.
Of 2 dozen Buck and Case I owned, 70-80% do come with slight imperfection one way or another(uneven grind, heavy rub, poor centering, play and grinding action), though I can't speak for all the RRRs, but of the 2 I have, they have been perfect in execution(no gaps, play, grind issue, great crisp walk and talk, pull of 6.5, perfect centering and flush of materials). The only complain I have is the heavy liner and bushing, if they could slim down the package a little bit, they will be perfect in every way and be in direct competition with GEC(at least from my humble prospective).
-
No4 carbone with forced patina and tea stained handle for day 8, with a Squirt PS4 riding shotgun

-
Day 8
An instant favourite of mine; Case small Texas Jack.

-
Day 8: No. 8 with sassafras root, cut up for tea.

-
Day 8
At the office with good 'ol 66.

-
<u>Day 8</u>








A double feature today, a Rough Ryder Reserve 001 Easy open(blue background) and 008 Stockman(red background). Overall I am quite happy with the fit and finish, but I am hoping they could minimize the width of the bushings and brass liners. RR has been known to be offering good value traditionals at an inexpensive price, and this new line of Rough Ryder Reserve is probably their attempt to open mid-high end market with supposedly better workmanship and material.
-
Very nice!!
-
-
Wow :ahhh such nice knives

Love seeing the variety :o

-
Day 8 of 30
I have today a 1 bladed Hen and Rooster coffin knife with stag handles
It is a very substantial blade and nice knife in hand 





-
@comis said:
A double feature today, a Rough Ryder Reserve 001 Easy open(blue background) and 008 Stockman(red background). Overall I am quite happy with the fit and finish, but I am hoping they could minimize the width of the bushings and brass liners. RR has been known to be offering good value traditionals at an inexpensive price, and this new line of Rough Ryder Reserve is probably their attempt to open mid-high end market with supposedly better workmanship and material.Those look good! I question the use of bushings to space the stockman tools/blades away from each other rather than grinding/crinking them to fit, but they look well-finished otherwise. It's a time saver in the process, but it sure adds some girth.
-
I have today a 1 bladed Hen and Rooster coffin knife with stag handles
It is a very substantial blade and nice knife in hand 





Poncho, when you say substantial, how big is this knife?
@NutSAK said:
Those look good! I question the use of bushings to space the stockman tools/blades away from each other rather than grinding/crinking them to fit, but they look well-finished otherwise. It's a time saver in the process, but it sure adds some girth.I think so too...on one hand, you could pitch it as a way to give smoother opening(but why? It is not like we are flipping it open), but on the other, it just increase girth and beg the question whether it is just another way to skip on the workmanship to make it tight and compact.
-
Day 08:
We see a lot of Opinels and Douk-Douks, but I haven't seen many K55K's here. Why not? The K55 is as traditional as they come. I think the K55 would be a brilliant hiking, picnicking, or camping knife. It is light, slim, and has a great all-purpose blade shape. Obviously it has stood the test of time and is still in production today (I think...).
I confess, I haven't used mine much, but I really like it. It should get a bit more trail time.

Douk-Douk, Mercator K55K, GEC Trapper -
Day 8:
Colt ’friend of Jack’ entering stage:

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@comis said:
I think so too...on one hand, you could pitch it as a way to give smoother opening(but why? It is not like we are flipping it open), but on the other, it just increase girth and beg the question whether it is just another way to skip on the workmanship to make it tight and compact.
, skimp on workmanship but at the same time reduce the chance of blade rub that many are bothered by. And, that's not to say that the likes of Case have not also cut corners in recent years. One unfortunate example of that was the decision years ago (when?) to change the canoe pattern #131 from one thick backspring to a two-backspring design, dramatically reducing the heft of the blade stock. -
@comis said:
Oh, that's right! I do remember seeing them here and there, and am wondering how good are they. I remember seeing a good number of Tony Bose Tribal lock jack knife available in different website, kinda wonder there is any merit getting that? What's special about this lock vs regular lockback?I do have two Rough Ryder Reserve knives, and I gonna share some pix about them.
I think their degree of fit and finish is pretty high(almost on par with GEC, everything perfectly flush and polished), with really smooth walk and talk(brass bushing) but design is kinda bulky and not very space conscious.
If they could have better and classier designs, they can be real competitor to GEC. But for now, I would prefer the RRR offerings over Lionsteel or Boker "modern" traditionals, since it has much better value and finishing.
AFAIK, the lock on the Tribal Lock is a pretty standard mid back lock. Tribal Lock is simply the name of the pattern, which of course was designed for Case by the late great Tony Bose.
That’s pretty high praise for the RRR series. Sounds like I’m going to have to pick up one or two, for scientific comparison purposes of course.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
