Lightweight SAK for backpacking
-
@GearedForwards said:
If you're looking for a 3 layer SAK anyway, then why not an Alox farmer like Kirkie suggested?The Farmer would seem to be a great choice, Parsa.
I like your tool priorities! 
The awl is one of my favorites. And a saw can be darned useful; however, I think the saw length of 91mm, 111mm, or 130mm is more functional. The 84/85mm saws start to seem too small to me (sometimes the 91 seems too small). When camping/hiking, I really like having scissors. So a Climber or Huntsman or Farmer X gets my vote. Or...I add a 58/65mm SAK to my load. A Farmer/Camper + a Classic has worked for me in the past (and will again, I'm sure!).
I totally get the "lighter is better" concept; however, I'm willing to make an exception for my knife(s). I feel I can carry a few extra grams to have the knife(s) I like. No one ever failed to complete the AT because the carried a Huntsman.
-
The Farmer is a great knife. I may look for one, especially if I can find a reasonably priced golden orange one. ;) The thing is, I already own a Hiker, which is pretty comparable, and lighter. I took a look at the specs on the 3 layer 84mm models (like the Salesman) and they come in at about 70 grams. My Hiker is only 77 grams, so I doubt if I'd be saving enough weight to make it worth my time to even modify one. The Farmer is about 9 grams heavier than my Hiker.
Here's my Hiker:

-
A couple of thoughts…
You’ve mentioned a lot of uses of the awl and can opener, but no actual uses of the saw. If you would be willing to consider doing without the saw, that gets you down to a Tourist or Sportsman.
Take a Farmer and remove the opener layer, leaving you with a slim 2-layer 93mm containing just the main blade, awl, and saw. Toss a P-38 in your kit or attach it to your key chain to cover can opening duties, and you’re good to go.
As you may be aware, the corkscrew actually makes a pretty handy little marlin spike for things like bootlaces and paracord, or any other cordage that is smaller in diameter than the space between adjacent corkscrew turns.
-
@Parsa said:
The Farmer is a great knife. I may look for one, especially if I can find a reasonably priced golden orange one. ;) The thing is, I already own a Hiker, which is pretty comparable, and lighter. I took a look at the specs on the 3 layer 84mm models (like the Salesman) and they come in at about 70 grams. My Hiker is only 77 grams, so I doubt if I'd be saving enough weight to make it worth my time to even modify one. The Farmer is about 9 grams heavier than my Hiker.Here's my Hiker:

So... how many grams matter to you then?
-
@nate j said:
A couple of thoughts…You’ve mentioned a lot of uses of the awl and can opener, but no actual uses of the saw. If you would be willing to consider doing without the saw, that gets you down to a Tourist or Sportsman.
Take a Farmer and remove the opener layer, leaving you with a slim 2-layer 93mm containing just the main blade, awl, and saw. Toss a P-38 in your kit or attach it to your key chain to cover can opening duties, and you’re good to go.
As you may be aware, the corkscrew actually makes a pretty handy little marlin spike for things like bootlaces and paracord, or any other cordage that is smaller in diameter than the space between adjacent corkscrew turns.
The P38 is a good point. It's not like I'll be using a can opener all that often. A Lumberjack with an awl would probably weight about an ounce. That would be cool. Or an 84mm Tourist with the two openers replaced with a saw....
I've been thinking that the corkscrew may be better than the screwdriver. It would be more useful as a cord tool. I could even put one of those FireAnt Firestarters in there.
-
@GearedForwards said:
So... how many grams matter to you then?I was just looking for trying to go lighter than my Hiker if possible, and wanted to know if there were options. ;)
-
Does anyone know what this knife is?

-
@Parsa said:
Does anyone know what this knife is?
Bushcrafter I think
SAKWiki | Bushcrafter_SwissBianco
SAKWiki - The online Swiss Army Knife Encyclopedia. Information and Identification on Swiss Army Knives by Victorinox and Wenger.
SAKWiki (www.sakwiki.com)
-
@GearedForwards said:
Bushcrafter I thinkSAKWiki | Bushcrafter_SwissBianco
SAKWiki - The online Swiss Army Knife Encyclopedia. Information and Identification on Swiss Army Knives by Victorinox and Wenger.
SAKWiki (www.sakwiki.com)
Oh, so a Swiss Bianco... dang. Thanks.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



