Crapsman
-
@Vidar said:
I guess another factor is the survivor bias. Whatever old tools are still in circulation are probably the best of the best, and likely not really representative of old tools in general. I think it is fair to assume that most bad or okish old tools have been scrapped long time ago as people didn't consider it worth it to keep around - as opposed to the good ones.That is an excellent point that I hadn't thought of
Over the years I have thrown out a few tools that broke or otherwise didn't meet my expectations. -
@gregozedobe said:
Over the years I have thrown out a few tools that broke or otherwise didn't meet my expectations.I've certainly done that way too many times too. Thus years ago I tried to change policy and aim to take the expense to buy quality for tools I expect to have around a long time. The price is typically much higher initially, but quite often one ends up paying in various ways for lesser quality too. (And sometimes only to then get the proper stuff afterwards - for added insult and cost).
Sadly price and quality doesn't always match up. It is nice when quality comes inexpensive, but all the more frustrating when bad quality comes at high cost. I blame the business pricing policy of basically charging irrespectively of production cost and rather just aim for whatever price the customer might be willing to pay - and increase that with inflated marketing. That policy goes a long way in undermining price as a signal of quality - and given time takes the brand value with it. (By then the MBAs probably got their bonuses already, and have moved on to the next job).
And all kind of more or less trustworthy reviews floating around the internet doesn't really help. These days I'm generally sceptical to most reviews that show glossy pictures of a shiny new tool, and that seems to be most of them. I'd rather want to see pictures of tools that has been put through its paces so the reviewer have at least experienced using them.
Seems I've gone off on some rant. Better stop here! :D
-
@Vidar said:
I've certainly done that way too many times too. Thus years ago I tried to change policy and aim to take the expense to buy quality for tools I expect to have around a long time. The price is typically much higher initially, but quite often one ends up paying in various ways for lesser quality too. (And sometimes only to then get the proper stuff afterwards - for added insult and cost).Sadly price and quality doesn't always match up. It is nice when quality comes inexpensive, but all the more frustrating when bad quality comes at high cost. I blame the business pricing policy of basically charging irrespectively of production cost and rather just aim for whatever price the customer might be willing to pay - and increase that with inflated marketing. That policy goes a long way in undermining price as a signal of quality - and given time takes the brand value with it. (By then the MBAs probably got their bonuses already, and have moved on to the next job).
And all kind of more or less trustworthy reviews floating around the internet doesn't really help. These days I'm generally sceptical to most reviews that show glossy pictures of a shiny new tool, and that seems to be most of them. I'd rather want to see pictures of tools that has been put through its paces so the reviewer have at least experienced using them.
Seems I've gone off on some rant. Better stop here! :D
Not a rant in my book, just some true but harsh facts ... Lots of "reviews" I see are simply an unrealistically positive unpackaging of a freebie, rather than discussion of real world use. So I just skip to the next review in the hope it will contain some useful info (and thankfully some do).
When I'm buying tools I like to have a look at several examples of a supposedly identical tool. If I can see variations in finish that tends to turn me off - if they are taking short cuts at the end it is more likely they have taken shortcuts in the intermediate steps as well, and at least their QA is deficient.
Like you, I try to buy on quality rather than brand or price, and as a result I have a wide variety of brands, particularly in sockets & spanners (wrenches).
-
@ Sea Monster
This...
" Not much point in recycling or driving a smaller car or using solar power if big companies are still going to insist on digging ore out of the ground, shipping it around the world, mashing it into the shape of something that doesn't even work, and then throwing the broken thing back into the ground"
Wiser words were never spoken.
My late Grandmother worked at Chestermans in Sheffield making Rules / Tapes. Upon being bought out by another, their top guy approached my Grandmother and having inspected the quality said they would never be repeated, "...people who buy these will only ever buy one in their lifetime, we will make sure they need to buy at least three"
You need only go to the recycling centres to see the stuff chucked in.
Yep, the planet will die (almost certain children born today will witness this) ...and only then will Billionaires consider their own fatal choices. -
@mikekoz said:
I used to go to Sears and buy Craftsman drivers and other tools because they were reasonably priced and made in the USA. I bought one of the last USA made tool sets at an Ace Hardware years back and still have it. I am not sure who used to make them for Sears, but maybe they just went out of business. I did not realize Stanley bought the name.At one time Western Forge made a short run of screwdrivers for Craftsman. The are stamped with a WF and are by far the best that Craftsman ever sold.
-
Western Forge did indeed make screw drivers for Craftsman. And Moore Drop Forge of Springfield Mass made the V series ratchets and wrenches. In '67, Moore got bought out by Easco. This can be noted on the tools, as the time when the pointed letter A becomes a flat topped, "barn roof" style letter A. Around this time is also when they first started offering the quick release button on the back of the ratchets (invented by a teen-age Sears store clerk in Gardner Mass in 1964). So if in your travels you find wrenches or sockets with pointed A's in the Craftsman name, or without the quick release button, by all means pick those up. Even beyond 1967, the tools are still great. Right up through the year 2011.
Anyway, Easco in turn got bought out by Danaher, then Apex. Today, the location those tools were made is one of those brick mill style buildings converted to office use as a medical center and row of doctors offices.
I have a 94 piece Craftsman set probably 25 or 30 years old, and replaced a kit that I "lost" when someone borrowed it. I love it. I bought whatever I needed at Sears back in the day and greatly lament the "Evolve" line of tools they made, because that was the precursor, test balloon for moving all production to China. Every time I see Made In China, I know that a couple hundred people or more list thier jobs here in the US and I'm sad for it. But mainly the quality is not there
So in my recent quest to buy a 3/8inch ratchet that I lost, I was forced to craigslist and ebay. I found a 1967 3/8 inch ratchet, AND three half-inch ratchets dating 1957 to 1986. They ALL worked. I did take them apart to clean them up, but they all worked.
With that bulk purchase I also obtained an S-K round headed, 50-tooth ratchet and bunch of S-K sockets. I have to say, comparing Craftsman sockets of the 1960's and 79's to S-K sockets of the same era, Craftsman had a much better finish especially at the bottom of the socket where the ratchet plugged in. But the SK stuff is still also great
-
I found this 25 foot tape measure 6 feet from the end of my driveway.

-
@Syncop8r said:
I started thinking this was a maths problem....
It is! The answer is 42.

@pfrsantos said:
Oh, so there's where I dropped it. Thanks. I just PM you my address, mail it when you can.

I was trying to post to my Lost Tools Found string.

Close your eyes. What color is your tape measure?

-



Soooooooooooooooo close. :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
