*** The Dean51 30-day ***
-
@comis said:
I never quite warm up to the Swayback design, but I know those whom just love them. Am I missing out?Is it the aesthetics you aren't sure about? Have you used one? Using one might convince you. They fit the hand so well for duties that require an "underhand" grip like carving, paring, pruning, etc., but not quite as well for "overhand" activities such as slicing on a cutting board.
-
@Nix said:
Well....I clearly don't pay attention as well as you do!
My USA-made 301 and 303. You can see that the tip of the spey blade on mine is exposed too!

I guess this hasn't been an issue for me. The other blades seem to shield the tip, so when the sheepsfoot blade is being used, the clip protects the hand from the tip of the spey.The springs on these are slightly better than my other Buck Stockman, but they are still a bit soft. Like Nate, I don't really mind the soft springs. I'm not fond of 'nailbreakers' and would rather have my springs a bit softer than overly strong.
The 301 took a good bit of work to get the blades sharpened up the way I wanted. And, yes, the clip is only swedged on one side. Why.....?

Compared to GEC or Case, these Bucks are not great knives, but I still love 'em. They make for great little work knives.

Thanks for the feedback, I think if I were to choose between nail breaking or soft spring, I too probably would choose the soft spring too. At least I could use it anytime I want to, and I don't have to caution myself about the gator trap everytime.


Finally got a chance to make the mod on a grinder, and I think I over did it just a bit(turn it into a semi spear-spey crossover....). But the tip is well within the chassis, and the other nail nick is slightly more exposed. Used it to open my afternoon coffee packet and love it. The crude mod job once again reminded me of what Dean once said, it's easy to take metal off, but impossible to put it back on. -
@NutSAK said:
Is it the aesthetics you aren't sure about? Have you used one? Using one might convince you. They fit the hand so well for duties that require an "underhand" grip like carving, paring, pruning, etc., but not quite as well for "overhand" activities such as slicing on a cutting board.Hmmm...come to think about it, it is probably time to put one in hand and give it a spin--I did get a micarta GEC swayback a while ago, and if it does have any etching on blade(which I don't want to ruin from patina or sharpening), I totally could turn that into a light user and see how it feels.

-
@nate j said:
As several others have already noted, all appear to have this one-sided swedge, so it seems to be a design feature rather than a manufacturing or QC error. As to why they are like this, I can only speculate, but my best guess is that it serves to sort of round out that corner of the blade, which makes the knife more comfortable in hand when using the spey or sheepsfoot blades.That's a good theory, and I think very likely that's probably why they are made that way.
@nate j said:
Day 20Based on some earlier discussion in this thread, I decided to acquire and carry a RRR knife, the Common Stockman. Overall, the F&F of this knife is impressive.
The pull is quite stout though, and varies considerably between blades. I would rate the sheepsfoot as a 7, the clip as probably an 8, and the screwdriver/caplifter as a 9.5 or 10, as it is literally a nail breaker. This is a real shame, as I want to like and carry this knife more, but probably won't because it is a pain to open, especially the screwdriver/caplifter. Really stiff springs are not a safety feature; they just make people not want to carry the knife, as instead of being an easy and convenient pocket tool, it's a PITA.

In the interest of science, of course, I did manage to get the screwdriver/caplifter open, and confirmed the efficacy of the caplifter function.

I pulled out my copy and I think I would rate them about 6-7(I don't have that strong a nail, and too prefer adequate spring), and sorry to hear about the 9.5. Since you are based in US, I did hear their warranty program is pretty responsive and well regarded. Would you want to give them a try to see whether they could ligthen that for you?
-
<u>Day 21</u>


Remington Daddy Barlow, IIRC, it is made by Camillus. Love the shield and the lettering on bolster.
-
Day 21.
First time carrying this for the challenge; the big old Lockwood Brothers Spearpoint. I've never been certain how old this is but I've read a piece that suggests the C+X mark (and lack of Pampa etch on the blade) might make it 1920s! Remarkably good condition if that's true. My gut says it's younger than that.

-
Outstanding Gareth!

I have my Schrade Barlow for Day 21.

-
First time carrying this for the challenge; the big old Lockwood Brothers Spearpoint. I've never been certain how old this is but I've read a piece that suggests the C+X mark might make it 1920s! Remarkably good condition if that's true. My gut says it's younger than that.
Sure is a good looking Jack Knife!

-
First time carrying this for the challenge; the big old Lockwood Brothers Spearpoint. I've never been certain how old this is but I've read a piece that suggests the C+X mark (and lack of Pampa etch on the blade) might make it 1920s! Remarkably good condition if that's true. My gut says it's younger than that.
That's a beauty !

-
@comis said:
Finally got a chance to make the mod on a grinder, and I think I over did it just a bit(turn it into a semi spear-spey crossover....). But the tip is well within the chassis, and the other nail nick is slightly more exposed. Used it to open my afternoon coffee packet and love it. The crude mod job once again reminded me of what Dean once said, it's easy to take metal off, but impossible to put it back on.Nice!

-
First time carrying this for the challenge; the big old Lockwood Brothers Spearpoint. I've never been certain how old this is but I've read a piece that suggests the C+X mark (and lack of Pampa etch on the blade) might make it 1920s! Remarkably good condition if that's true. My gut says it's younger than that.
That is just wonderful.

-
First time carrying this for the challenge; the big old Lockwood Brothers Spearpoint. I've never been certain how old this is but I've read a piece that suggests the C+X mark (and lack of Pampa etch on the blade) might make it 1920s! Remarkably good condition if that's true. My gut says it's younger than that.
That is one sexy piece!!!
-
AND............. We're off the an amazing start.

-
-
Another awesome day of pics

3 weeks in already :o :ahhh

-
Day 21 of 30
I forgot to swap out my knife last night so instead of more pocs of the Case from yesterday
I will showcase the Christy knife today
Love this little knife 8) so lightweight and the company has been making this knife for many many years (enough to consider it a traditional knife in fact ;) :D )

-
Day 21
I feel like the posts today should have started with John Cleese saying, "and now for something completely different." because it looks like today is the day that everyone is changing up. I figured I would too, so here is my Svord Peasant. It's the 4 inch (10 cm) model that I won on MTO several years ago and it usually lives on my dining room table where I mostly use it for opening new pill bottles.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



