*** The Dean51 30-day ***
-
Good job everyone

Day 30, first run out since Nessmuk for the Ka-bar

-
Day 30, this one’s gone quickly, been a great challenge, thanks for awl the great posts everyone

Saved what is for me the best until last.
Given to me by my granddad about 50 years ago and my very first knife. It looked pretty well like this then, I’ve never sharpened it, (it’s as blunt as anything!), just scraped my name into it years ago and had ever since
... And this, that's a lovely knife.

-
Day 30:

This has been a fantastic challenge for me. Not just because I am now the custodian of a really lovely Camillus Stockman, but because I really came to appreciate the GEC #23, known as the Trapper.
I had hoped to get out to do some fishing and camping with the Trapper, but between the heat and the wildfires, I haven't done much. Nevertheless, the Trapper has been an excellent EDC companion knife. It got used for awl sorts of corse and tasks and performed brilliantly.
What I liked:
• Big blades. Not one, but two. Each has their place for me. Over-awl, the straight blade was the most useful, but the spey blade was used a good bit and is very handy. The two together made for a very functional cutting tool.
• Both blades took an exceptionally nice edge. The broad blades also helped create a nice slicey geometry.
• The ergonomics are really nice. The big handle is great to use, a bit like a Buck 110. It is comfortable in upside-down saber grip as well and right-side-up saber grip. The handle provided nice control when doing fiddly tasks like cutting up a chicken.
• Solid construction. Obviously I didn't give the Trapper a destruction test or een put it to really hard use, but it is well made and feels solid. After a month of use it show no sign of significant wear.
• Traditional styling. I'm a big fan of the old-school pocket knife. I like the new stuff, but there isn't much charm in a Spyderco Endura.
The negatives...
• The carbon steel blades were quick to tarnish and take on 'patina'. I don't mind this, but it is a reminder that these knives need to be kept dry and protected from corrosion. I've a Case Trapper with some 'patina' spots from a long hot day of hiking. The cool knife condensed sweat and rusted before supper time. I love the edge of carbon steel, but it does require some maintenance and care.
• Big and heavy. So....I like the size and weight of this knife. Smaller knives can sometimes feel like toys or novelties to me. This Trapper feels like a genuine working knife. I've no doubt that it would be good for skining beaver or dressing out a deer. But...for EDC it's a bit big. For the last week I carried the #23 in the Buck 110 sheath pictured above. This was really handy, especially in the garden where I could just reach the knife with a dirty paw and not have to dig into my pocket. And the weigh twas a non-issue in the sheath. My reality was that the wright was a non-issue with in the pocket carry as well; I just got used to it quickly.
• Stiff springs. As I've usesd the #23, the springs have "broken in" a bit. But hey are still stiff. It is best to pause and take a very deliberate approach to opening the blades. Using the big leverage available from the long blade and handles, the blades open nicely, but it pays to do it carefully every time. I can get a a Buck 110 open with just my left hand, even when cold. I'd have to get really creative to open this one with one-hand (say, if my dominant hand were injured.). I'm able to open the spey blade using my left hand and right foot. In a crisis, it could be done. But.....
Some of the drawbacks notwithstanding, I really like this knife. I don't think it will replace the Buck 110 for me, but it may just be a close second. I hope GEC doesn't do a run of #23's anytime soon, I'll be too tempted to get a back-up. ;)
-
Final post completed.
I'd like to offer a big congratulations to awl who participated and completed the challenge. It was a lot of fun to do this challenge and see awl the great knives in various styles. The traditional knife world is so deep and rich, it seems pretty easy to get lost in the various rabbit holes. I can see why Dean was such a fan, and am pleased to follow in his footsteps to some small degree.
Thank you to Dean, now gone, for helping to keep the Traditional Knife passion alive here on MTo.

Thanks to awl for the great participation and fun atmosphere that youz guys created.

Thanks to Steve and David for riding herd on this challenge. Awesome work guys!

A huge Thanks to Steve, NutSAK, and Sos24 for their generous give-aways during the challenge. Those were unexpected and delightful! I'm only sorry I didn't win them awl......

I hope that we will run this challenge again next July. I know that I'll be up for it! :D
-
Day 30 and it's that Douk Douk again

-
Oh.....the rib challenge.....
uh....
Looks like I take the bronze medal:

I smoked these for about 3 hours, and then cooked 'em wrapped in foil for about 3 more. Once again I had a hard time keeping the smoker down below 250ºF. At times it hit 300ºF.
They were simply seasoned with salt and pepper and smoke. Here's how I scored them:
Appearance: 3/5 -- they look OK, I think. I had planned to do ahoney & apple cider glaze, but didn't pull that off.
Taste: 3/5 -- good pork flavor, nice smoke, but maybe a bit dull. These ribs were a bit lean; fat is flavor! ( The next day the leftover rib meat was cooked up with some BBQ sauce, that was pretty dynamite. )
Texture: 3/5 -- overdone. Bones all but fell out. Meat just pulled apart and was a touch on the dry side. Again, a bit of extra fat would have helped.**** sigh **** Only 9/15.
Guess I'll have to practice more! :D
Congratulations to GA Dad and Alan for the gold and silver entries. I'll let you guys duke it out for bragging rights!

-

This has been a fantastic challenge for me. Not just because I am now the custodian of a really lovely Camillus Stockman, but because I really came to appreciate the GEC #23, known as the Trapper.
I had hoped to get out to do some fishing and camping with the Trapper, but between the heat and the wildfires, I haven't done much. Nevertheless, the Trapper has been an excellent EDC companion knife. It got used for awl sorts of corse and tasks and performed brilliantly.
What I liked:
• Big blades. Not one, but two. Each has their place for me. Over-awl, the straight blade was the most useful, but the spey blade was used a good bit and is very handy. The two together made for a very functional cutting tool.
• Both blades took an exceptionally nice edge. The broad blades also helped create a nice slicey geometry.
• The ergonomics are really nice. The big handle is great to use, a bit like a Buck 110. It is comfortable in upside-down saber grip as well and right-side-up saber grip. The handle provided nice control when doing fiddly tasks like cutting up a chicken.
• Solid construction. Obviously I didn't give the Trapper a destruction test or een put it to really hard use, but it is well made and feels solid. After a month of use it show no sign of significant wear.
• Traditional styling. I'm a big fan of the old-school pocket knife. I like the new stuff, but there isn't much charm in a Spyderco Endura.
The negatives...
• The carbon steel blades were quick to tarnish and take on 'patina'. I don't mind this, but it is a reminder that these knives need to be kept dry and protected from corrosion. I've a Case Trapper with some 'patina' spots from a long hot day of hiking. The cool knife condensed sweat and rusted before supper time. I love the edge of carbon steel, but it does require some maintenance and care.
• Big and heavy. So....I like the size and weight of this knife. Smaller knives can sometimes feel like toys or novelties to me. This Trapper feels like a genuine working knife. I've no doubt that it would be good for skining beaver or dressing out a deer. But...for EDC it's a bit big. For the last week I carried the #23 in the Buck 110 sheath pictured above. This was really handy, especially in the garden where I could just reach the knife with a dirty paw and not have to dig into my pocket. And the weigh twas a non-issue in the sheath. My reality was that the wright was a non-issue with in the pocket carry as well; I just got used to it quickly.
• Stiff springs. As I've usesd the #23, the springs have "broken in" a bit. But hey are still stiff. It is best to pause and take a very deliberate approach to opening the blades. Using the big leverage available from the long blade and handles, the blades open nicely, but it pays to do it carefully every time. I can get a a Buck 110 open with just my left hand, even when cold. I'd have to get really creative to open this one with one-hand (say, if my dominant hand were injured.). I'm able to open the spey blade using my left hand and right foot. In a crisis, it could be done. But.....
Some of the drawbacks notwithstanding, I really like this knife. I don't think it will replace the Buck 110 for me, but it may just be a close second. I hope GEC doesn't do a run of #23's anytime soon, I'll be too tempted to get a back-up. ;)
Great review! I think moving forward I too will try to use only one knife in a challenge. It has been rather cool watching the patina show up on your trapper.
Thanks for a cool challenge!
-
-
@Nix said:
Oh.....the rib challenge.....uh....
Looks like I take the bronze medal:

I smoked these for about 3 hours, and then cooked 'em wrapped in foil for about 3 more. Once again I had a hard time keeping the smoker down below 250ºF. At times it hit 300ºF.
They were simply seasoned with salt and pepper and smoke. Here's how I scored them:
Appearance: 3/5 -- they look OK, I think. I had planned to do ahoney & apple cider glaze, but didn't pull that off.
Taste: 3/5 -- good pork flavor, nice smoke, but maybe a bit dull. These ribs were a bit lean; fat is flavor! ( The next day the leftover rib meat was cooked up with some BBQ sauce, that was pretty dynamite. )
Texture: 3/5 -- overdone. Bones all but fell out. Meat just pulled apart and was a touch on the dry side. Again, a bit of extra fat would have helped.**** sigh **** Only 9/15.
Guess I'll have to practice more! :D
Congratulations to GA Dad and Alan for the gold and silver entries. I'll let you guys duke it out for bragging rights!

That's a pretty unique way of cooking ribs. Since we all didn't do them that way,,, I'd have a hard time saying anything bad about them. If I had tried that way,, they could have absolutley sucked,,, who knows. One thing is for sure,,,,, yours look mighty tasty! I'm betting the meat would have been outstanding on a biscuit!
-

Is there anything that isn't good on a biscuit?

-
Oooh...just requested my 30-GEC badge.
Remember to apply for your 30-GEC or 30-Trad badge, which ever is appropriate, after completing this challenge!

-
@McStitchy said:
Congrats on your new Queen #26 Fuzzy
That's a really nice one
Cheers Stitchy!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


Finishing put the challenge with a Rough Rider 

