The Go BIG Challenge
-
@Jackpine54 said:
Why does that n frame look small in that photo
With a full season in the bag, what's your opinion on the Smith vs Ruger? Inquiring minds want to know!
In order to keep this fair I'll skip 4" vs 6,5" barrels effect on aiming/hitting metal at distance, 9 mm vs. .357 felt recoil, emptying + reloading and capacity issues (obviously Smith cleans the table on these, with say Super GP100 things might be different)
With that in mind, here's my take:
Advantage SW 929 PC:- trigger, mine hasn't been touched but it is better than GP100's that has been touched by someone who knows his business and yet Smith has better pull
- weight, fully loaded SW feels lighter in hand than empty Ruger
- cylinder release, Smith's push forward mechanism is simply better, especially while moving
- support, Smith dominates IPSC revo circuit, support, advice etc. available
Advantage Ruger GP100:
- reliability. Ruger just runs, with Smith there are what I guess can be called SW quirks, screws getting loose and requiring attention is not a big thing but that does not exist on Ruger
- speed. This might be a bit unfair to Smith, but I was expecting faster splits in, say classic Bill Drill. As it stands, Ruger mechanism is good enough to keep up and frame weight means that I'm not really getting faster times. Keeping in mind that this is 9 vs. .357 mag I'm marking this as point for the Ruger
Sums up as 4-2 for the Smith, I'll give GP100 0,5 bonus point on looks (PC guns look a bit too fancy for my taste) and that brings the situation up to 4-2,5
Of course, if/when the factors ruled out in the beginning are taken into consideration it is even clearer.
Game, set and match for SmithAll in all I'm happy that I switched over to the dark side (9mm and 8 holes in a revo, by Harry!) and also satisfied with my choice. Super GP100s are rare, wait lists long and currently I don't thing it would've served me better than the 929
-
Day 47 of 60 (late post!):
I meant to include a scissors shot in my post yesterday. Apparently I missed that.

Still carrying the S'champ and loving it as much as ever, if not more!


-
Day 48
XLT helped out with assembly of a new Weber


-
Lefty, thanks for the review. Good comparison. Glad the Smith is working well for you.

-
@pfrsantos said:
At the same time?! How?!??? ??? ??? ???
Not at same time [emoji2957] first used mag to identify splinter and then pliers to remove those
Only Tools Matters
-
Day 48 of 60
Today SwissChamp was my backup at work, didnt see any action but it was there if i needed it.

Only Tools Matters
-
Day 48/60
SC helped with an afternoon snack...


-
@pfrsantos said:
Oh, ok. Didn't the tweezers handled it? Those you could use together with the magnifying glass at the same time.Not these splinters, didnt get enough pressure on tweezers to pull splinters out
Only Tools Matters
-
Day 47/60
Opened a really strong beer.

-
Day 48: More parcel duty

-
Day 48
Used the large screwdriver to pry the lid off a can of wax. Also used the universal scaler to check the lube level in a transfer case. The fill hole diameter is smaller than my finger diameter. No pictures of that, not enough hands.
-
**Day 48 of 60:
**No uses today. Too much wildfire smoke to do anything useful or fun outside.

-
**Day 17 of 30 (Stack Challenge)
**
Just drifting along...
-
@McStitchy said:
Day 48/60SC helped with an afternoon snack...
Excellent snack McS. You're not a Minion by any chance?


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



