Electronic Compass
-
-
@gregozedobe said:
Now you'll have to get a Schrade I-Quip (electronic compass, altimeter etc) AND an MT as well
</post/717406>
just order one 
-


-
-
@Cupboard said:
Woah now that's a serious bit of thread revival!And how about now?

TBH, I'd still find a compass like this to be useful. I have a properly calibrated prismatic one and another on my ABC watch, but most people seem reliant on their phones, which are generally only accurate to within about 15º... and if you're navigating several miles by that, it's a lot of error.
-
@Neil said:
I acquired this at a local car boot sale last weekend.
Accurate to a degree and I like the fact you can preset declination. Here's some more info.
A quick look at the Silva website doesn't show any electronic compasses in their current range. I wonder if the market was too limited?
I think they vanished because not only because of GPS and phones but because they are a electronic gadget with lots of limits.
If you have worked with a real compass you know its not only for knowing where north is, with a good one you can do a lot of map work (I got a few, for real work a Recta DS50G, a more basic Recta DP2 and a Silva Field as pure basic ).
All of them, even the most basic is more usefull than your electronic device, not talking about batteries.
This thing doesnt even have a straight edge to do basic map work or any scales, rotatable housing, glowing marks or some sort of illumination for bad light....list goes on.if you really need a compass, its more than a gimmic, its a tool that can save your life.
See here: /post/2211211
-
@Shuya said:
All of them, even the most basic is more usefull than your electronic device, not talking about batteries.
This thing doesnt even have a straight edge to do basic map work or any scales, rotatable housing, glowing marks or some sort of illumination for bad light....list goes on.According to Silva, this Nomad electronic compass has: "Forward & back bearing memory, off-course indicator, <u>backlit digital display</u>, adjustment for magnetic declination, 5º accuracy with 1º resolution".
More here: https://www.manualslib.com/manual/318819/Silva-Nomad.htmlWhat you say above, I would say the same about most of the military compasses we used... and yet, strangley enough, we never got lost and were always able to place artillery fire directly on target from several miles away.
I would also say the same about the various globular compasses on the majority of aircraft and ships, which also seem to make it to their destinations without any trouble.As for map work itself - We have protractors and romers that work just fine. Sometimes even better.
-
@Tasky said:
According to Silva, this Nomad electronic compass has: "Forward & back bearing memory, off-course indicator, <u>backlit digital display</u>, adjustment for magnetic declination, 5º accuracy with 1º resolution".
More here: https://www.manualslib.com/manual/318819/Silva-Nomad.htmlWhat you say above, I would say the same about most of the military compasses we used... and yet, strangley enough, we never got lost and were always able to place artillery fire directly on target from several miles away.
I would also say the same about the various globular compasses on the majority of aircraft and ships, which also seem to make it to their destinations without any trouble.As for map work itself - We have protractors and romers that work just fine. Sometimes even better.
5° is a lot when mapworking or navigation. Thats 87m error at 1000m distance.
And according to military compass: all of the ones I have seen have a straight long side when fully opened to be used as a ruler when doing map work, and this ruler has a scale on it.
When not having a transparend baseplate a protractor indeed is a very usefull tool .
I used my Recata DS50G a lot on maps or open landscapes, and never missed a protractor to be honest.I guess when they gave you this compass with 5° accuracy and no protractor lots of your shells would not have hit anything

-
-
@Shuya said:
5° is a lot when mapworking or navigation. Thats 87m error at 1000m distance.And according to military compass: all of the ones I have seen have a straight long side when fully opened to be used as a ruler when doing map work, and this ruler has a scale on it.
When not having a transparend baseplate a protractor indeed is a very usefull tool .
I used my Recata DS50G a lot on maps or open landscapes, and never missed a protractor to be honest.I guess when they gave you this compass with 5° accuracy and no protractor lots of your shells would not have hit anything

5º is far less than the 15º average of even modern digital compasses... Incidentally, your Recta is only accurate to 2.5º, according to the manufacturer and if it's anything like my DP6 from them, the markings are visibly out of alignment.
Current issue military compass: https://pyseroptics.com/product/m-88-green-liquid-prismatic-compass-degrees-model/
A design roughly unchanged since the late 1800s. Not that you asked, but it's accurate to 5 mils (or 0.28º), incidentally, but only because it's limited to the resolution of your own eyeball. If your eyesight is that good, you can be even more accurate with it.
The protractor is larger than most baseplates and has a thread that allows for far longer measures than a baseplate can manage.
Even WW2 US military compasses lacked any baseplate elements, yet people managed fine with these: http://www.44thcollectorsavenue.com/Militaria/WWII/US/Field-gear-and-equipment/US2-F-000081.htmlSo for the purposes for which this compass was likely designed, it's perfectly fine... and if you want to get all snobish about doing 'real' map work, any 'real' navigator will have other methods that partner with this.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login