Chuck Yeager (memorial) Challenge 2021
-
@Simon_Templar said:
Day 5Working some more on the right technique to open bottles with the orange peeler, I found that it's sufficient to bend the rim outwards in just one place. Once it's bent enough for you to slip the tip in all the way to the top of the bottle, you can simply flip the cap off. The cap then looks like in the picture.
It's pretty quick to do it this way, but you have to concentrate. I failed to do so once, and as soon as I had become careless the Executive's orange peeler immediately drew blood.
When tending to the cut, I thunk about why I edc SAKs. It's to have the proper tool ready for all those small chores you are presented with in daily life. Instead of ripping apart or gnawing through things, or using your key as a makeshift saw to cut something, the right SAK gives me a proper tool for all those little jobs. A civilized way of doing things. For me, carrying a SAK is about not having to resort to workarounds. That's why I like and carry them.
And it's in that respect that the Executive falls short as far as I am concerned. Comforting as it is to know that it can be used to open a bottle in a pinch, I know of other ways to get the cap off a bottle. So that's not the point. The point is that I carry a SAK so that I don't have to think of creative ways anymore to solve a problem for which a dedicated SAK implement exists. For me, the fun in chosing an EDC is to find a SAK that's as small as possible while giving me all the implements I might require in the course of my average day. This is why SAKs without scissors just don't work for me (unless I carry the missing tool elsewhere), and it rings equally true for SAKs without a blade or without a bottle opener: I might be able to work around their shortcomings, but if I have to do that, what's the point in carrying them in the first place?
Simon, I agree with soooo much of what you say! Theres so many ways of opening a bottle, that I don't feel the need to have a dedicated bottle opener with me though. To me, there is no perfect SAK, and they are all a compromise unless you get a maximum layer one. The beauty of a SAk is, the odd shaped bits of metal that make up SAK tools, are so handy for that odd job that needs a bit of poking, prying, nudging, or picking. Like the little SWD tip of the can opener being a good Phillips driver. Or the SD tip of the classic nail file making a decent bottle opener when used like you use the orange peeler tip. Tangled twine/string de-tangler for the SD tipped 58mm nail file is good use for the odd shaped bit of metal. I used the classic nail file so many times to untangle the knotted sneaker laces of my kids like magic. Not a job it was designed for, but it worked great at it.
I guess thats why I love the small SAK's sooooo much; they all work great at jobs they were not designed for, just by virtue of those odd shaped bits of metal being far handier and more effective than human finger tips. Theres no perfect SAK for me, although I've looked, tried out, and experimented for 50 years to find one. The best I've managed is to figure out what SAK works for me in the everyday life I live at that time. Now, as a retired old fart living off the government dole, I find the little 58's and 74's to be it. If I need a can opener or bigger screw driver/pry tool, then I have the old army P-38 and Sear's 4-way keychain screw driver in my wallet. I find at this stage of my life, I need knife blade, (Small) scissors, SD tip nail file because the odd shape lets me do sooooo many weird things that it was never designed to do. Tweezers are nice to have.
The most perfect SAK is the one we have on us at the stage of life we need it's particular tool set for. That changes from our 20's, to the 30's, and then again by our 40's and 50's. As humans, we continue to evolve through our life as we age and gain life's experiences.
-
Day 5
My EDC for the challenge alongside the mammoth tusk ivory Executive.
-
@FolderBeholder said:
Day 5
My EDC for the challenge alongside the mammoth tusk ivory Executive.That is very cool!FB

-
@cbl51 said:
The most perfect SAK is the one we have on us at the stage of life we need it's particular tool set for. That changes from our 20's, to the 30's, and then again by our 40's and 50's. As humans, we continue to evolve through our life as we age and gain life's experiences.Nicely said cbl!

-
Simon and cbl, I agree with you both, which is why the Executive will never be my favorite SAK. Its tool set is just too limited for the way I like to use a SAK. I like to have Classics and other small SAKs around and I find them handy, but I usually have other tools close at hand so I'm not so limited. Trying to use the Executive exclusively has been difficult.
-
Day 05
I don't like knives or tools that lie in the bottom of my pocket. They always end up pressing against my leg which I find uncomfortable. The small and medium SAKs are really too small to carry in a pouch or on a dangler though so options are somewhat limited. The least I can do is add a paracord fob which helps me locate the knife in my pocket when its in there with a bunch of other stuff, and actually helps mitigate those uncomfortable pressure points by keeping the SAK more or less anchored to one side of the pocket. This fob took me about 5 minutes this morning.

-
Day 5
Skinning an Amazon Prime.

-
@Simon_Templar said:
Thanks
I spared you a picture of my orange peeled finger.You'll need that to get your badge for being wounded.

-
@cbl51 said:
Simon, I agree with soooo much of what you say! Theres so many ways of opening a bottle, that I don't feel the need to have a dedicated bottle opener with me though. To me, there is no perfect SAK, and they are all a compromise unless you get a maximum layer one. The beauty of a SAk is, the odd shaped bits of metal that make up SAK tools, are so handy for that odd job that needs a bit of poking, prying, nudging, or picking. Like the little SWD tip of the can opener being a good Phillips driver. Or the SD tip of the classic nail file making a decent bottle opener when used like you use the orange peeler tip. Tangled twine/string de-tangler for the SD tipped 58mm nail file is good use for the odd shaped bit of metal. I used the classic nail file so many times to untangle the knotted sneaker laces of my kids like magic. Not a job it was designed for, but it worked great at it.I guess thats why I love the small SAK's sooooo much; they all work great at jobs they were not designed for, just by virtue of those odd shaped bits of metal being far handier and more effective than human finger tips. Theres no perfect SAK for me, although I've looked, tried out, and experimented for 50 years to find one. The best I've managed is to figure out what SAK works for me in the everyday life I live at that time. Now, as a retired old fart living off the government dole, I find the little 58's and 74's to be it. If I need a can opener or bigger screw driver/pry tool, then I have the old army P-38 and Sear's 4-way keychain screw driver in my wallet. I find at this stage of my life, I need knife blade, (Small) scissors, SD tip nail file because the odd shape lets me do sooooo many weird things that it was never designed to do. Tweezers are nice to have.
The most perfect SAK is the one we have on us at the stage of life we need it's particular tool set for. That changes from our 20's, to the 30's, and then again by our 40's and 50's. As humans, we continue to evolve through our life as we age and gain life's experiences.
Thanks for your thoughts, Carl.
I believe we are thinking along the same lines: carrying as much as necessary and as little as possible is the way to go. The rub is in determining what's necessary.I agree that part of the charm of a SAK is finding a good off-label use for one of its implements in the face of an unexpected challenge. That's why I like the fish scaler and the awl, and I consider the orange peeler a great tool as well. However, for my daily routine tasks I don't want to become creative. I just want to make gentlemanly use of the corresponding SAK implement if it exists. Given that Vic makes excellent can openers (heck, it's one of the first implements they invented, clearly they knew why), it's deplorable they don't come in 74mm format. Not as unforgivable as the absence of scissors in the 84 mm line, but it's in the same ballpark (at least as far as I am concerned).
And that's a shame, because just like you I don't require a big SAK in my pocket and would happily settle for the Executive as soon as the need for a Lite module in my life subsides. It's really that good. But at the risk of sounding pedantic: without a bottle opener, it just feels incomplete to me, and I am afraid that will always bug me.

-
Day 05. Packet opening with small blade. Nothing thrilling to be honest.

-
@Fireman said:
You'll need that to get your badge for being wounded.
Well, at least I helped to advance SAK science. I honestly believe I found the best way to open a bottle with the Executive. Granted, you have to stay focused, but when you do it's quick and easy. A lot better than the file imho (in fact, I haven't yet managed to open a bottle with the file; it seems so fragile that I just cannot handle it confidently). -
Day 5
Set up at our campsite. Now to get the fire going to cook some pork bangers

-
@Alan K. said:
Day 04
The back scale has been successfully reattached to my Executive. There's no trace of looseness or any gap. That was the good news. The bad news is I glued on the scale with the tweezer slot at the wrong end and also I'm afraid that if I tried to insert the tweezer it would pop the scale off again because it is tight. The toothpick on the other side also fits tight and I think they may be the wrong size. Still, I'm calling it a success.Depending on the glue, there's little chance of it popping off again, Alan.
If you look closely at some of mine you'll see that the scale tools are generally pointed toward the keyring. If I ever just add it on to my keys they won't accidentally fall out. -
Day 5.
Not expecting any actual use, today, Patch accompanied us to Charleston for the Christmas light show.
Here he is relaxing on a post at the parking lot while the 3 ladies walk the beach.
-
@Max Stone said:
Day 5
Set up at our campsite. Now to get the fire going to cook some pork bangers
Nice SAK! But I must ask.. Is it an illusion or is that caravan tent absolutely huge? It looks like at least twice as deep as anything I seen before
[It's not failure if you learn something from it]
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
