I have transitioned...
-
@Farmer X said:
One might say I've transitioned, too. I spent 12+ years with a Super Tinker as my sole carrier. When I noticed its scissors weren't cutting like they used to, I decided it was time for a new SAK. The new SAK turned out to be so cool I wanted to get another and preserve it. Next thing I know, I'm participating in the 30 SAKs in 30 Days challenge, and I can (almost) show a different model for each of the 30 days.That is how I have started out (Super Tinker)

-
Usually if I find something that works, something that's perfect for my needs, it's certain to be discontinued. It's happened more times than I can count, aggravating. That is what started me buying multiples and models I might want someday. I figured they probably will never be any cheaper than they are today and who knows when I will need another one, but I'm sure it'll happen. At this point I really don't honestly think I'll need a 19th pioneer.........but that doesn't stop me from checking ebay for them

-
@Barry Rowland said:
About a year ago I transitioned from loading up with tools for every imaginable possibility to a 58mm with a Craftsman keychain screwdriver. The 58 varies between a Classic and a Mini Champ, but that's about all that rides with me anymore. I feel another transition coming with the Executive, although it would be a lot easier for me to do so if they were still in production. Still, this might just be it!My own transition took a lot longer than yours. Maybe over several years, I slowly downsized my SAK's, guns, knives in general. Once I went back to carrying a keychain one piece screw driver and my old army P-38 in my wallet, I didn't carry a SAK with opener layers anymore. I went down to a classic and there I was until Nix gifted me an executive. The executive was my infatuation for two years, but slowly I drifted back to the classic. I just nv er bonded with that orange peeler, and I like the SD tipped nail file on the 58mm. Better for medium Phillips screws than the executive.
I can't recall the last time I carried a 84 or 91mm SAK. many years now. If I carry another knife, its a dedicated cutter, like the Victorinox florist knife or my Christy knife.
Even the Sear's 4 way keychain screw driver has been transitioning to a Victorinox quatro for the better shaped Phillips bits.
-
@cbl51 said:
My own transition took a lot longer than yours. Maybe over several years, I slowly downsized my SAK's, guns, knives in general. Once I went back to carrying a keychain one piece screw driver and my old army P-38 in my wallet, I didn't carry a SAK with opener layers anymore. I went down to a classic and there I was until Nix gifted me an executive. The executive was my infatuation for two years, but slowly I drifted back to the classic. I just nv er bonded with that orange peeler, and I like the SD tipped nail file on the 58mm. Better for medium Phillips screws than the executive.I can't recall the last time I carried a 84 or 91mm SAK. many years now. If I carry another knife, its a dedicated cutter, like the Victorinox florist knife or my Christy knife.
Even the Sear's 4 way keychain screw driver has been transitioning to a Victorinox quatro for the better shaped Phillips bits.
Very interesting! I Imagine I might end up like you eventually. Before the SAK bug hit me, I had happily lived for years with nothing but a 58 mm on my keychain (first the Minichamp (too big), then the Rambler (brilliant toolset for its size) and finally the Manager (Rambler plus pen)), and I cannot think of any situation where I would have needed more than that without being close to the appropriate tool.
If you liked the Executive so much, how come you never went for the Ambassador? It's essentially a 74mm Classic. Still small enough to disappear in the pocket, but it might save you the trouble of carrying a dedicated cutter every once in a while.
-
@Simon_Templar said:
Very interesting! I Imagine I might end up like you eventually. Before the SAK bug hit me, I had happily lived for years with nothing but a 58 mm on my keychain (first the Minichamp (too big), then the Rambler (brilliant toolset for its size) and finally the Manager (Rambler plus pen)), and I cannot think of any situation where I would have needed more than that without being close to the appropriate tool.If you liked the Executive so much, how come you never went for the Ambassador? It's essentially a 74mm Classic. Still small enough to disappear in the pocket, but it might save you the trouble of carrying a dedicated cutter every once in a while.
Unfortunately, the ambassador has the same defect as the executive. Its just a tad bigger and heavier, but not enough in many instances to make a real difference. If the 58mm is too small, the 74mm is still enough to just barely make a difference. I found with the executive, that is was still just a wee bit too small for things that the classic wasn't up to handling. So a dedicated cutter like the florist knife, or excelsior, or bantam, was needed. I found that a well matched duo was more versatile and able to handle more stuff than one jack of all trades and master of none. And the dedicated cutters like a Christy knife was way easier to clean up after some messy BBQ or other food matter than a small lobster pattern like the 58's and 74's. An alox bantam can be washed out with soap and hot water or even put though the dishwasher if need be. And the open design of the Christy knife is very easy to rinse out with a bottle of water, a drinking fountain, or even a creek. It can also be taken apart wit the aid of a small screw driver to detail clean the inside mechanism. Two screw and its all apart or back together. I've had a life long love affair with the little Christy knife after my dad gave me one when I was a kid. I fond the 58mm SAK and my Christy knife makes a great EDC duo.
-
@Jackpine54 said:
Usually if I find something that works, something that's perfect for my needs, it's certain to be discontinued. It's happened more times than I can count, aggravating. That is what started me buying multiples and models I might want someday. I figured they probably will never be any cheaper than they are today and who knows when I will need another one, but I'm sure it'll happen. At this point I really don't honestly think I'll need a 19th pioneer.........but that doesn't stop me from checking ebay for them
I can sooo relate to this! And I bet just like me you haven't broken a single SAK in your life. But well, it could happen, and then the SAK might be discontinued (forgetting about Vic's lifelong guarantee), so better have a spare - or five...
-
@cbl51 said:
Unfortunately, the ambassador has the same defect as the executive. Its just a tad bigger and heavier, but not enough in many instances to make a real difference. If the 58mm is too small, the 74mm is still enough to just barely make a difference. I found with the executive, that is was still just a wee bit too small for things that the classic wasn't up to handling. So a dedicated cutter like the florist knife, or excelsior, or bantam, was needed. I found that a well matched duo was more versatile and able to handle more stuff than one jack of all trades and master of none. And the dedicated cutters like a Christy knife was way easier to clean up after some messy BBQ or other food matter than a small lobster pattern like the 58's and 74's. An alox bantam can be washed out with soap and hot water or even put though the dishwasher if need be. And the open design of the Christy knife is very easy to rinse out with a bottle of water, a drinking fountain, or even a creek. It can also be taken apart wit the aid of a small screw driver to detail clean the inside mechanism. Two screw and its all apart or back together. I've had a life long love affair with the little Christy knife after my dad gave me one when I was a kid. I fond the 58mm SAK and my Christy knife makes a great EDC duo.I know what you mean. Discounting the problem of the missing cap lifter, I start to suspect the 74 mm frame might just be a tad too small for its own good. In particular, there's no getting around the fact the Executive's large blade is very slim. I have a nagging feeling that at the end of this month's challenge, I will have grown fond of the Executive (heck, I like it already) but will put it back into the drawer nevertheless on account of all its little quirks.
-
Billy Bringdown here.
I am 72. I am in the process of dieing. I have a box full of SAKS among other style knives. If a Farmer style alox that had the tool set of blade, scissors, saw and screw driver came out, I would buy it. I'm an addict.The problem is, I am trying to clear up my mess, as will we all. What do I do with my box of knives that no family member wants, and I don't want to bother shipping? I'm also lazy while dieing.
Was Bhudda right? Desire is the base of all pain?
Sent from my SM-N970U1 using Tapatalk
-
Sorry to hear Gingerman. What to do with your box of knives? Well if you are not wanting to ship or sell something along those lines how about give away to the mail person, delivery person, neighbors, visitors if you have them, any random person you might encounter?
I do hope you are in comfort and will be thru your process.
-
That's a great idea. It's amazing how many people need a knife and just don't realize that they do. I wish you peace and comfort Gingerman. I'm really sorry to hear that. -
And that’s the final transition we all eventually face.
Sorry it’s upon you now gingerman.
I’ve left instructions for the most valuable and try to label anything worth selling.
-
@Simon_Templar said:
I know what you mean. Discounting the problem of the missing cap lifter, I start to suspect the 74 mm frame might just be a tad too small for its own good. In particular, there's no getting around the fact the Executive's large blade is very slim. I have a nagging feeling that at the end of this month's challenge, I will have grown fond of the Executive (heck, I like it already) but will put it back into the drawer nevertheless on account of all its little quirks.I wish I could fathom what Victorinox is thinking, as I think the executive cold be made much, MUCH more appealing to a wider consumer base with a few mods. One, get rid of the orange peeler and replace it with either a combo tool like on the rambler, or even a combo tool like on the alox bantam. That way the executive would have a cap lifter, and small Phillips driver. A huge increase of mission capability. The second would be, make the blade a bit wider for even better edge geometry and cutting. We already have a small pen blade on it, s why not give more cutting ability with a larger/wider man blade?
-
@gingerman said:
Billy Bringdown here.
I am 72. I am in the process of dieing. I have a box full of SAKS among other style knives. If a Farmer style alox that had the tool set of blade, scissors, saw and screw driver came out, I would buy it. I'm an addict.The problem is, I am trying to clear up my mess, as will we all. What do I do with my box of knives that no family member wants, and I don't want to bother shipping? I'm also lazy while dieing.
Was Bhudda right? Desire is the base of all pain?
Sent from my SM-N970U1 using Tapatalk
I'm so sorry to hear of your condition!!!
I thought of this years ago when my gun collection and knife collection was very large. I ended up giving the stuff away to family and friends who wanted them. The leftovers got sold off, and a lot of knives went as give aways on the forums that I was on frequently, like Blade Forums. That way I figured if I went, they knives would go to people who would appreciate them, and my family wouldn't have to deal with the overflow mess.
If all else fails, give the box of knives to a local boy scout troop.
-
You know, I can only wonder if this transition thing is age related.

It seems like when I was a young stud, full of p--s and vinegar, I tried to cover all the basis. Car breakdown, ship wreck, end of the world as we know it. In my 30's I was a prepper. Yeah, the guy with 5 years of freeze dried food in the basement along with the mini 14, a zillion rounds of ammo, and at least a half dozen high dollar 'survival knives'. My daily EDC pocket stuff was pants dragging.
Then...somewhere along the way, I think I grew up. Sold off the mini 14, the thousands of rounds of ammo, used up the freeze dried food,( the mountain house beef stroganoff wasn't bad) and I went mainstream. Sort of. My SAK obsession and knife nut cult worship lasted a little longer, but by my 40's that too had faded a great deal. I no longer tried to cover all the basis. If the world ended, it would just have to do it without me. I kept a few guns, and a small handful of pocket knives, and just went on with life. I thought of something my old man had told me when I was a kid, and had forgotten. He said; "remember who you are, what you are, and where you are.? This from a guy who was an old Great Depression era guy who went off and fought WW2, came home and built a life in the great suburbs of Washington D.C. as a suit guy going "downtown" to work.
Dad was a great minimalist. He carried a Case peanut, a Sear's keychain screw driver, and a P-38 in his wallet like I learned to do when it came my turn to serve in the army. For a while I had forgotten the lessons that he, and a few of my senior NCO's drilled into me. That simple is good, and you can't carry everything. You learn to adapt, improvise, and overcome. Just to carry the few bare necessities, and improvise as needed. It took me a while, but as I got older, I lost the need to try to carry everything and cover all the bases. Somehow, the world kept on turning on its axis, the sun still rose in the east, and life went on. I took stock of what I actually used on a day to day basis, and took to carrying just that. My wallet thanked me, my wife thanked me, and life was peaceful.
Nowadays, I find a small keychain size penknife good, the one piece keychain screw driver and P-38 in my wallet works, and the Bic lighter in my pocket gives me fire when needed. Especially when I want to light my pipe. I came to embrace the whole concept of [I]maximum minimalism[i] and lived to see another day. Yeah, there was some times when I needed to go above and beyond, but I found that if you just take a moment to look things over, think about what you really need to do, a surprising amount of stuff can be done with a small sharp cutter, or a basic screw driver to take the cover off something to see what wrong. sometimes a paper clip or a bit of wire can make do. I always carry two paper clips and a safety pin in my wallet as well. Paper clips are very good quality wire to fasten something down or secure a connection.
Dad always told me that a knife doesn't have to be big, just sharp. I figure if dad could get through the depression and a world war, who was I to think I knew better after reading and wasting my money on survival magazines and books?
I think it was Teddy Roosevelt who said "Do what you can, where you are, with what you have, and it will be fine."
Who and I to question Teddy Roosevelt and dad?
-
Right on sir, and it was TR that said that!

-
@Jackpine54 said:
Usually if I find something that works, something that's perfect for my needs, it's certain to be discontinued. It's happened more times than I can count, aggravating. That is what started me buying multiples and models I might want someday. I figured they probably will never be any cheaper than they are today and who knows when I will need another one, but I'm sure it'll happen. At this point I really don't honestly think I'll need a 19th pioneer.........but that doesn't stop me from checking ebay for them
You're lucky -- when I find out about something that works, it was discontinued a year ago and there's only one for sale on the whole internet for 1000x markup

Given how many times the things I like become discontinued, it's hard not to buy a "lifetime supply" of them (lifetime of a star, maybe
).In any case, my wallet sure transitioned into a bunch of SAKs.

-
@cbl51 said:
Unfortunately, the ambassador has the same defect as the executive. Its just a tad bigger and heavier, but not enough in many instances to make a real difference. If the 58mm is too small, the 74mm is still enough to just barely make a difference. I found with the executive, that is was still just a wee bit too small for things that the classic wasn't up to handling. So a dedicated cutter like the florist knife, or excelsior, or bantam, was needed.......I tend to agree with all your interesting posts in this thread. I do find that while the Executive is not much more useful than a Classic, it's much nicer in hand to use.
Your story about your dad reminds me of my own dad and grandfather, and some of my feelings towards much of the EDC scene (especially on youtube and such). Of course, if you treat it as a hobby or fashion rather than just trying to get the job done, you can forgive how silly it can get. It's more of an escape, interest, and collection for me. The spirit of it comes from the same mentality of "what do I actually need" since the SAK can be pretty minimalist in itself. Well, until you buy dozens of them.

-
@Altis said:
Of course, if you treat it as a hobby or fashion rather than just trying to get the job done, you can forgive how silly it can get. It's more of an escape, interest, and collection for me.I think that sums it up quite nicely. One mustn't take it all too seriously. It's really not about whether collecting SAKs or searching for the "right" EDC objectively makes sense, but rather whether one subjectively enjoys it. Every intelligent mature person knows that material things won't bring you happiness, so collecting SAKs or carrying one in your pocket will not give your life any meaning. But it might generate some happy moments and interesting memories, and ultimately this is what it's all about imho.
I might wake up one day to realize that all the SAKs in my drawer are in fact a huge waste of money, or that I have lost interest in SAKs altogether. After all, I spent most of my life without a SAK in my pocket, and my life wasn't any worse for it. If that day comes, I will not fret over whether or not I was stupid or whether I could have used the money I spent on SAKs more wisely. Because the nice memories my folly generated, like finding this forum and enjoying discussions like this one, will stay with me.
In view of this, I frankly don't give a damn what my heirs might think when one day they find my stock of SAKs. If they don't like them, they can just throw them all away for all I care. If they think I was crazy for wasting my money on them, they will be entitled to their option as far as I am concerned. It matters not.
-
@Simon_Templar said:
I think that sums it up quite nicely. One mustn't take it all too seriously. It's really not about whether collecting SAKs or searching for the "right" EDC objectively makes sense, but rather whether one subjectively enjoys it. Every intelligent mature person knows that material things won't bring you happiness, so collecting SAKs or carrying one in your pocket will not give your life any meaning. But it might generate some happy moments and interesting memories, and ultimately this is what it's all about imho.I might wake up one day to realize that all the SAKs in my drawer are in fact a huge waste of money, or that I have lost interest in SAKs altogether. After all, I spent most of my life without a SAK in my pocket, and my life wasn't any worse for it. If that day comes, I will not fret over whether or not I was stupid or whether I could have used the money I spent on SAKs more wisely. Because the nice memories my folly generated, like finding this forum and enjoying discussions like this one, will stay with me.
In view of this, I frankly don't give a damn what my heirs might think when one day they find my stock of SAKs. If they don't like them, they can just throw them all away for all I care. If they think I was crazy for wasting my money on them, they will be entitled to their option as far as I am concerned. It matters not.
Well said that man

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
