SAK Beginner Questions
-
I've been trying to decide which SAK(s) to add to my EDC and this forum seems to have the most comprehensive information in one place that I have seen. I've found some very good info so far and will continue to search through old threads to see what comes up. Meanwhile, I have a couple of questions that I have not seen addressed so far so I decided to post them and see what I can learn.
An emergency pen seems like a very useful item to have, but only a few SAKs have pens. Has anyone fashioned a reasonable way to add a pen to a SAK that is not designed for one? I think that it might be possible to take a standard D1 refill (used in many multipens) and fit it into the corkscrew, or maybe cut a regular ball point refill down to size and put it in the corkscrew -- but so far I have not found any info on this.
A great system idea that I came across here is one SAK in the pocket and one SAK on the keychain. That would avoid trying to have every possible tool needed on one knife (which means I would buy a SwissChamp and then never carry it because it is too heavy!). However, long go I had one of the small SAKs on my keychain (the SD?) and it got really scratched up, which bugged me. I know that I should just get over it, but, is there any way to prevent all the scratching on a keychain knife? I was thinking of possibly some kind of film or tape or maybe even some kind of wax although I question whether wax would be durable enough.
Last question -- is the MiniChamp too large for keychain carry? I've seen the Rambler mentioned a lot as a great keychain knife but nothing so far on the MiniChamp.
Thanks!
-
I have a few answers/suggestions for you.
If I wanted to add a pen to one of my SAKs, I'd put Plus scales on it. Swapping scales isn't difficult. The downside to that approach is that Victorinox doesn't sell replacement scales, and you may well have to order them internationally. But that it the best option, in my opinion.
Short of putting the keychain knife in a slip, I'm not aware of a way to prevent scratches, dings, gouges, and such. And I don't believe the MiniChamp is too large for keychain carry. I carry my 58mm knives on a neck lanyard, which is another viable option.
Hope that's been of some help.
-
Yes thank you that is helpful!
Is replacing the scales something that a tyro (like me) could likely do or is it best left to the experienced only?
I thought of a slipcase or pouch of some kind but have not been able to find such anywhere. I'll start looking for replacement scales and maybe both will come up.
-
I too belive that plus scales are your best choice for a pen. They are easy to find on the internet or the bay and don't cost that much and it's really easy to change the scales. If you want to keep the old ones just out your sak in hit water (not boiling, just hot tap water) for a bit then I usually put a small screwdriver in the t and t slot and a light pry will pop it of and after I dry it out just pop the new ones on. I usually clamp them on but you can do it by hand too
You usually get a small slip with the purchase of a 58mm,i don't like those and have never used them and I don't mind a few marks on my scales. Victorinox also have a few others that they sell
[It's not failure if you learn something from it]
-
I personally dont have any, but you can have plus scales in any 91mm model.
About keychain issues, you can have a small leather or syntetic protection around, like a roll... I have it in a small flaslight, but you will always have to put in on and take it out.About the saks...
Maybe a Manager (you got nail file and pen in a small size) or a Signature (a little bit harder to find) for the keychain ones.
And a Explorer (big scissors, inline screwdriver, magnifying glass, awl...)
That would by me choises.
Honorable mentions for first sak: Spartan, Climber, Compact (no awl on compact) -
Great info, thanks!
What is the T and T slot?
It seems to me that clear protective tape might work as far as the scratches, similar to what they put on cars (although it would not need to be so heavy duty).
-
You can add pen to the 84 models too - it is not difficult to remove the scale and file the slot for pen.
Or as others already mentioned, buy the plus scales for any 91.For the keychain - you may consider silver alox models to avoid the scratch issue. I think the silver alox is good in preventing to show any wear.
As well, if you have the plus scales on the larger SAK you are already covered for all scales tools and therefore do not need them on keychain.
But for standard alox 58 you are limited to Classic and Minichamp. I carry alox Minichamp on my keys. It is on the heavier side, but still OK. If there is Alox Rambler, there would be my choice, but unfortunately it is not available as standard. On Classic I miss the combo tool with Philips driver. -
@tm3 said:
Great info, thanks!What is the T and T slot?
It seems to me that clear protective tape might work as far as the scratches, similar to what they put on cars (although it would not need to be so heavy duty).
T and T would be the tweezers and toothpick slot
It took me some time to learn that too
[It's not failure if you learn something from it]
-
I concur with those who have said that the easiest way to add a pen is to put plus scales on any 91 mm SAK.
With regard to key chain knives getting scratched, one option is to use a slip or sheath to protect the knife. Also note that cellidor is the least durable of the common Vic scale materials, with nylon being next, and alox being most durable. As noted above, silver alox tends to show scratches less than colors because the coloring is done by anodizing the surface, so deep scratches or wear over time tends to remove the colored anodizing and reveal the silver-colored alox underneath.
As someone who carried a Spartan on his key chain for a while, I’m going to offer the opinion that the Minichamp is not too big for key chain carry, but it really comes down to personal preference so YMMV.
P.S. I too would like to see an alox Rambler become a standard offering.
-
@tm3 said:
Is replacing the scales something that a tyro (like me) could likely do or is it best left to the experienced only?Removing cellidor scales is easier than you'd think. They are pressed on over the rivets. If you put the knife in hot water to soften the plastic first and are gentle, you can pop them off without tearing off the plastic that fits around the rivets. If you're buying new scales and aren't going to reuse the ones you're taking off, you don't need to stress.
I'd suggest you still try it with hot water so you at least have practice taking them off without damaging them.
-
To protect your SAK you can also get some nice sheaths from Victorinox.
You can choose leather or silicone.
-
Thanks for the sheath pics. I'll see if I can find a source.
I'm probably going to experiment with applying some protective tape like is used to protect car paint,
-
I've used the leather key ring sheath for years now. I also made one to slip into my pocket and found a plastic one that also works. Good luck with however you decide to go about protecting your little SAKs.


-
Those are really nice leather sheaths! I'm not finding much for the smaller knives, just the larger ones.
-
I made one since I too was not finding what I wanted. The plastic one usually comes with cheap clones from what I can tell. The Leather one with split ring, I often see offered online. The color ones are pretty nice looking and Victorinox offered those so they should be fairly easy to locate.
-
If you need a pen in a minimalist carry, get a Manager; otherwise a Rambler as it has the same toolset except for the toothpick. The Rambler is a very functional wee knife, almost a mini Tinker.
@Masel said:
To protect your SAK you can also get some nice sheaths from Victorinox.
You can choose leather or silicone.Wow, never seen any of those before!
@Aloha said:
I've used the leather key ring sheath for years now. I also made one to slip into my pocket and found a plastic one that also works. Good luck with however you decide to go about protecting your little SAKs.Lovely!
I'm rough and just let my Rambler be bashed about by my keys. I did have to replace a lost scale last year, but.
-
I’m in agreement with X and others about the plus scales. Also The large pen in the plus scales is much more usable IMO and it really stays put. If you’re looking to avoid scratches another option may be to choose one of the ruby or sapphire translucent scales. They will scratch but it seems like it doesn’t show as much with these scales although my only experience with them so far is on my semi newly acquired cyber tool 34 so I can’t speak to long long term. Maybe someone else can chime in about this

Here is a picture of some ruby and sapphire plus scales just to give you an idea.
Also welcome to MTo!



-
As for keychain carry, I personally don't believe that a MiniChamp is too heavy, I love them. If you're concerned with scratches, I'd definitely go with Alox.
The Rambler is probably the handiest 58mm though, having both types of small screwdrivers.
Changing scales is very simple. There are plenty of YouTube videos that explain the process.
As has been said that a Rambler, in Alox should really be added to the Victorinox line, you can find more durable replacement scales for them. I rehandled one of my MiniChamps with carbon fiber and love it.
It's really easy to make a leather pouch that hangs on a keyring though.
I attached a photo of the CF MiniChamp as well as a pouch made from salvaged leather from an old purse.

-
Nice leather sheath

-
Thanks again for all of the valuable input! Certainly has given me lots to consider and look into.
As far as the visibility of scratches on the red scales, I'll add that a friend of mine who is a car collector once told me that red is the very worst car color as far as showing dirt and scratches. I thought that it was black but he says otherwise.
In re-reading I see that I kind of missed the neck lanyard suggestion and will now consider that if I can find one that has the safety feature (I think it is called breakaway?).
I've seen the Rambler praised a lot in various places around the www and it seems to me to be kind of a no brainer choice over the SD. In fact if I was going that route I'd likely just get the manager to have the pen as I don't see a downside.
This exercise has actually prompted me to start thinking about EDC more comprehensively ie not just which knife to pick. If for example I find a convenient pen carry then I don't need to consider having one as part of the SAK.
Again, thanks for the help!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login