Leatherman Garage
-
@Rich_SD said:
You're the only person saying "public". Powernoodle just said shareholders ("Making MTs is only ancillary to the primary goal of increasing share value and producing dividends for the shareholders.") This is an accurate statement.This is only an accurate statement if we know for a fact that Leatherman has shareholders and that the corporate culture and goals are solely based on financial performance.
Unless I'm missing something in their about us section that's shockingly frank, no we don't know any of that.
And the whole making money thing is primary is how a lot of corporations work, it's how Gerber went down the hill and off a sheer cliff because accounting got aheado of quality. But that doesn't mean that every company works that way nor that if it does work that way that we should just lie down and accept it.
The only reason they can get away with 'Leatherman Garage' is because there's a hardcore fanbase that would buy it regardless what it is. That fan base rolling over and saying things like they're only about money is part of the problem, even if Leatherman turns their nose up at us the consumer having these discussions are important.
-
Since it's so easy to miscommunicate tone in written messages, I'm not sure if you are confused or if you are just being argumentative. I'm going to assume the best and believe the former. Here is one last attempt -
@powernoodle said:
Making MTs is only ancillary to the primary goal of increasing share value and producing dividends for the shareholders.@gregpost said:
Leatherman is not a ***publicly ***traded company. No idea what your talking about with shareholders and dividends and such. It's a private business they don't have any fiduciary duty to public shareholders.(emphasis mine)
@Rich_SD said:
FYI - a lot of companies that are not publicly traded still have shareholders,
-
@GearedForwards said:
This is only an accurate statement if we know for a fact that Leatherman has shareholders and that the corporate culture and goals are solely based on financial performance.Unless I'm missing something in their about us section that's shockingly frank, no we don't know any of that.
And the whole making money thing is primary is how a lot of corporations work, it's how Gerber went down the hill and off a sheer cliff because accounting got aheado of quality. But that doesn't mean that every company works that way nor that if it does work that way that we should just lie down and accept it.
The only reason they can get away with 'Leatherman Garage' is because there's a hardcore fanbase that would buy it regardless what it is. That fan base rolling over and saying things like they're only about money is part of the problem, even if Leatherman turns their nose up at us the consumer having these discussions are important.
When Private companies offer shares as compensation they only have a duty to value the business competently but this can mean anything and short of outright fraud the employees basically have to accept the company's valuation, unlike public markets where the value is set by the public. So there is no fiduciary duty of a private company to maximize share price or pay dividends, this is pure nonsense. Private companies often stay private to control company culture, growth, the overall business environment, and not report to the tougher standards required by governing agencies.
The Advantages of Being a Private Company
Private companies do not have to plan for the short term as much as publicly traded companies do to satisfy shareholders and keep daily stock prices up. Eliminating this need to produce stellar quarterly results allows a private company to focus on long-term growth and manage accordingly. While businesses can still assess short-term goals, they can spend more time and research looking at ongoing, long-term objectives.
-
@GearedForwards said:
This is only an accurate statement if we know for a fact that Leatherman has shareholders and that the corporate culture and goals are solely based on financial performance.Yes, I agree with that. I was just trying to explain to Greg that a company doesn't have to trade stocks ***publicly ***to have stock or have a responsibility to shareholders.
-
@Rich_SD said:
Yes, I agree with that. I was just trying to explain to Greg that a company doesn't have to trade stocks ***publicly ***to have stock or have a responsibility to shareholders.But your not explaining anything because I think everybody knows this. You're just causing confusion because the matter here is public vs private company responsibilities and you went on an irrelevant tangent about private companies sometimes issuing shares, which I think everybody knows and is really irrelevant anyways to the discussion.
-
@gregpost said:
But your not explaining anything because I think everybody knows this. You're just causing confusion because the matter here is public vs private company responsibilities and you went on an irrelevant tangent about private companies sometimes issuing shares, which I think everybody knows and is really irrelevant anyways to the discussion.Hey, I'm sorry if I embarrassed you - my intent was just to help. I have no interest playing keyboard warrior with you.
-
Let's keep this discussion civil.
-

On a more positive note this speaks to Leatherman's great success as a business and if we take a moment to be less cynical about hype, resellers, and limited editions, the 1,000 run seems small today but the original PST launched with runs of 500 at time, then 750, then 1,000. So with that perspective maybe it's just their way of actually getting back to their roots.
My first million: Tim Leatherman, Leatherman Tool Group
Six months later, at $24, catalogues were more interested and Leatherman soon had an order for $12,000-worth 500 tools through the post. Berliner's father offered space in his business for Leatherman's machinery and they got working for a delivery date of December 1983. As it turned out, this wasn't quick enough for the catalogues. "They said we need them really badly, because they've all been sold. Here's an order for 500 more. And a week after that they said 500 have gone, here's an order for 750, and two weeks later the 750 had been sold, here's an order for 1,000."
-
@gregpost said:
Leatherman is not a publicly traded company. No idea what your talking about with shareholders and dividends and such. It's a private business . . . .Privately held companies issue stock. I have such a certificate right in front of me (in the course of doing my taxes), which has a share value and for which dividends are issued. :salute:
-
@powernoodle said:
Privately held companies issue stock. I have such a certificate right in front of me (in the course of doing my taxes), which has a share value and for which dividends are issued. :salute:Private companies can issue stock, again do we actually have any indication that Leatherman does this?
-
@GearedForwards said:
Private companies can issue stock, again do we actually have any indication that Leatherman does this?Tim Leatherman won't return my calls anymore, so I guess I'll never know.
But this whole stock thing is a red herring. The salient point (which I brilliantly articulated
) is that Leatherman Tool Group exists to generate revenue for its owners, and not to make the MTs we think it should make at the price we think it should Charge. [<< Leatherman pun].You lads and lassies are a passionate, passionate bunch about your MTs - I'll give you that - which is what makes MTO so much fun.

-
I am just happy I was able to procure one of these and now have to agonize if I will use it or put on a shelf to admire. I am excited about the innovation with the new plier head and chisel. Don't really care as much about the other tools since they all exist in different variants today.
-
@powernoodle said:
Tim Leatherman won't return my calls anymore, so I guess I'll never know.
But this whole stock thing is a red herring. The salient point (which I brilliantly articulated
) is that Leatherman Tool Group exists to generate revenue for its owners, and not to make the MTs we think it should make at the price we think it should Charge. [<< Leatherman pun].You lads and lassies are a passionate, passionate bunch about your MTs - I'll give you that - which is what makes MTO so much fun.

Here I thought it existed because Tim Leatherman had to keep fixing the motel plumbing whilst travelling

Why a company exists depends on what the people at the top prioritise, unless we're talking about the legal structure of what a company is, which doesn't seem pertinent or helpful.
I'll try and relate this to my own personal experience:
I used to work for a trailer manufacturer with a long history of quality and an excellent reputation. It was started by one guy making trailers and whilst he worked there employee morale and product quality was king. That built an incredibly successful company with a desirable product. When he retired from day-to-day operations things shifted to the bottom line and profit margins. It's now a dreadful, underpaid place to work that puts out a questionable quality product on the name quality once built.
I can't help but see comparisons and it's concerning.
-
@MrToolJunkie said:
I am just happy I was able to procure one of these and now have to agonize if I will use it or put on a shelf to admire.I am faced with this same dilemma. :ahhh I really want to use it, but I'm afraid I would break a one-of-a-kind part... not because it doesn't seem durable - it's just my luck.
-
Tim saw a need and put in a lot of hard work to fill that need. Yeah its about profits otherwise whats the purpose? Thats said, I really like what greg said.
On a more positive note this speaks to Leatherman's great success as a business and if we take a moment to be less cynical about hype, resellers, and limited editions, the 1,000 run seems small today but the original PST launched with runs of 500 at time, then 750, then 1,000. So with that perspective maybe it's just their way of actually getting back to their roots.
My first million: Tim Leatherman, Leatherman Tool Group
Six months later, at $24, catalogues were more interested and Leatherman soon had an order for $12,000-worth 500 tools through the post. Berliner's father offered space in his business for Leatherman's machinery and they got working for a delivery date of December 1983. As it turned out, this wasn't quick enough for the catalogues. "They said we need them really badly, because they've all been sold. Here's an order for 500 more. And a week after that they said 500 have gone, here's an order for 750, and two weeks later the 750 had been sold, here's an order for 1,000."
Maybe we all got it wrong? They're going back to their roots so to speak. Maybe Tim took someone out the the shed

-
And if you take the long view Leatherman is still offering good value. The original PST was $24 in 1983 dollars which today is around $67. You can buy a Leatherman Bond for $60 or Leatherman Rebar which arguably improves the design for not much more.
-
I still feel 200 asking price was fair
. I didn't get one as my lust for MTs is not as strong as it was. I give LM a hard time cause I know they are capable of more. I get its not good business sense to cater to the customers but I'm still gonna bust their chops when I see a reason. I'm a fan, I'm a user, I'm a collector of Leatheman, and I will always be. I'm stoked for those who got a tool. How fun is this? I don't think the FREE got this much excitement
. -
I'm not a fan, neither a collector, I simply enjoy light use of those shiny metal things. As far as I am concerned, the more designs see the light of the sun, the better for everyone. I don't need to own something to appreciate it. So, as long as I live, I'll be informed about Leatherman or Victorinox or even Gerber products. But as a person and as a user I may have an opinion and even complain for some issues, like making such good moves as engineering the bit holder and the t-shank holder and then restricting their use for some specific models. Or building a ton of different color versions, taking advantage of (or even manipulating in fact) the collector impulses (Vic does that also and perhaps more extensively). Or how easy these relatively expensive steels break or rust (neither ever happened to the inferior Swiss steels which I abused with more force and for more years).
However controversial this tool is, it's nice to have it and we need even more and, if possible, even better tools, at adequate numbers.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

Given how quickly they sold out, I'm going to expect the next Garage tool to cost more... I hope I'm wrong again.