UK Legal Carry Thread!
-
Glad you still have your trusty Classic! 
-
-
@GearedForwards said:
You got guts Surge 8) You also have a very weird key... wallet?I'm going to take a wild guess that you may be evaluating their 'airport style' security to see if it meets your lofty standards? Hopefully you won't be found out by someone with your enthusiasm

What's wrong with my key wallet

It has to hold a credit card sized access card (so I can get into the shopping centre I live in ::) )
I'm in Wales next week so don't make me come looking for you
-
@SurgeUk said:
What's wrong with my key wallet
It has to hold a credit card sized access card (so I can get into the shopping centre I live in ::) )
I'm in Wales next week so don't make me come looking for you
It's different from what I know and am used to, thus makes me scared of it and lash out appropriately, you weirdo

Mate, I know you're posh, but 'stealth camping' in Waitrose isn't the way to go

Pfft, you'll probably be dahn saff even this side of the border ::)
-
@GearedForwards said:
It's different from what I know and am used to, thus makes me scared of it and lash out appropriately, you weirdo
Mate, I know you're posh, but 'stealth camping' in Waitrose isn't the way to go

Pfft, you'll probably be dahn saff even this side of the border ::)
FYI: I don't "camp" anywhere
(did enough of that years ago!)I shall be arriving in Port ~~Toilet ~~Talbot tomorrow afternoon and then off to three cliffs the following day.
I shall leave the "Land of our Fathers" on Thursday morning and return to "Waitrose"

I will be equipped with the FX & Bond along with my Fenix E01 (I trust this meets with your foreign laws)

-
@SurgeUk said:
FYI: I don't "camp" anywhere
(did enough of that years ago!)I shall be arriving in Port ~~Toilet ~~Talbot tomorrow afternoon and then off to three cliffs the following day.
I shall leave the "Land of our Fathers" on Thursday morning and return to "Waitrose"

I will be equipped with the FX & Bond along with my Fenix E01 (I trust this meets with your foreign laws)

I should think your gear nice enough to warrant the cross border
muggingshake down yes, I've already called 'dibs' on you as an Englishman of 'taxing' interest
I've never been to Port water closet, but I hope you can make the most of your time in our lovely land given the unfortunate circumstances of your visit
...Wait that was far too nice to you err.... You smell of elderberries!
-
@GearedForwards said:
I should think your gear nice enough to warrant the cross bordermuggingshake down yes, I've already called 'dibs' on you as an Englishman of 'taxing' interest
I've never been to Port water closet, but I hope you can make the most of your time in our lovely land given the unfortunate circumstances of your visit
...Wait that was far too nice to you err.... You smell of elderberries!
Well, we survived the trip (although GWR First Class have let themselves go
)To be fair you're not missing much at Port Talbot these days, which is now looking very sad & dated :( It used to be a buzzing little town a decade or so ago but, with the steelworks on tenterhooks and the Covid issues, it's sadly in decline :'(
It awl went as well as could be expected and my father was laid to rest on the cliffs with a view of both Port Talbot & Oxwich Bay

It didn't seem appropriate to take MTO type pics, so I didn't :-\
However, here's a shot from the cliffs (towards Oxwich)
Also one of the EDC (which Welsh Customs missed
) back home with some Welsh pillow chocolates ;)*NB: Far too polite a response so I shall retort with something similar about 'amsters
*

-
@Moose said:
Boom.. And I'm back with my new favorite UK legal pocket knife.... The Bestech Junzi
Just got myself a Junzi from Twisted Assisted (half the price of the original Bestech, by the way). They do a budget version in D2 with a range of different scales, but it’s still a cracking knife. With companion Rambler in Brass.

-
@SurgeUk said:
Well, it worked
I wasn't selected for a "Private Search"

The problem is that I still don't know if it's allowed or not (if you ask, it's a whole world of pain) If you take the chance, as I did, and win
then it's all good 
Still, it was a great day and the views of London (and Essex, Kent, Middlesex & Surrey) were fantastic.
If you could, you should

What do you mean by allowed?
If its legal, its legal but as a private building they can have their own policy and refuse admission, you can't be arrested just turned away
-
Security
The safety and security of The Shard and everyone in it is of the utmost importance to us. It is protected by state-of-the-art technology and highly trained security staff.
(www.the-shard.com)
"PROHIBITED ITEMS
Please do not attempt to bring in firearms, ammunition, bladed articles, explosives or fireworks, hazardous liquids or chemicals or anything else that could cause harm to someone".Also:
"You can expect to see police patrols around the building, including by armed officers, and this is nothing to be alarmed about".
I imagine anyone causing a fuss might be given a free ride in the Blue Light Taxi to the local copshop, if only to give you a slapped wrist... and I imagine they'll still pinch your 3-incher, just to make the point. -
I see prohibited from their building - they would have just refused you entry
or anything else that could cause harm to someone
made me laugh though, that's pretty much anything
@Tasky said:
https://www.the-shard.com/about/securityAlso:
"You can expect to see police patrols around the building, including by armed officers, and this is nothing to be alarmed about".
I imagine anyone causing a fuss might be given a free ride in the Blue Light Taxi to the local copshop, if only to give you a slapped wrist... and I imagine they'll still pinch your 3-incher, just to make the point.Indeed but why would anyone cause a fuss - they have their own rules so follow them? However if they called in the cops, stand your ground you've not broken the law.
If they were foolish enough to arrest you, refuse any caution they might offer, get a solicitor and make a claim for Wrongful arrest / False imprisonment
you would get what they took back or they also face a charge of theft/damages
probably best have it on film and/or seek their body cam footage though...
-
Ahhhhh
Twould be nice to have a grubberment with some common sense rather than a cowardly grubberment who introduce draconian punishments for carrying a SAK mini in your pocket.
But I guess Australia is simply full of idiots, after all they did vote in howard the coward.
-
@SAKPal said:
Indeed but why would anyone cause a fuss - they have their own rules so follow them? However if they called in the cops, stand your ground you've not broken the law.Some people do like to cause a fuss, though. For the same reason people take it upon themselves to "audit" those in authority... which is basically pushing boundaries in the hope of getting an adverse reaction, which is why it's so often filmed and uploaded direct to YouTube at the time.
But more importantly, this thing about SAKs being legal to carry only applies to public places. The Shard is open to the public, but it is not a public space in itself.
High Court of Justice – claim no. QB-2018-0004473
"On 27 February 2020, an order was made in the High Court of Justice prohibiting anyone from entering in or remaining at The Shard or Shard Place without permission.
Anyone in breach of this injunction will be in contempt of court and may be imprisoned, fined or have their assets seized".So under this High Court order, if they tell you to go because you're packing a SAK and you kick up a fuss or start bleating legalities at them, you may well find your collar getting felt.
@SAKPal said:
If they were foolish enough to arrest you, refuse any caution they might offer, get a solicitor and make a claim for Wrongful arrest / False imprisonment
you would get what they took back or they also face a charge of theft/damages
probably best have it on film and/or seek their body cam footage though...Go ahead.
They can arrest you "on suspicion" of anything they like - After all, you will have been asked not to bring any bladed items and you show up with just such a thing... that's pretty suspicious, if you ask me!
They may not actually charge you with a crime in the end, but you'll still have to endure the inconvenience of being arrested, detained and processed, however long that takes... all because you wanted to be a smurf-head over a pretty minor legal interpretation. Even if it's just causing harassment, alarm or distress contrary to the Public Order Act 1986, or another similar offence, which in plain speak is known as being a smurf.
! -
@Tasky said:
Some people do like to cause a fuss, though. For the same reason people take it upon themselves to "audit" those in authority... which is basically pushing boundaries in the hope of getting an adverse reaction, which is why it's so often filmed and uploaded direct to YouTube at the time.But more importantly, this thing about SAKs being legal to carry only applies to public places. The Shard is open to the public, but it is not a public space in itself.
High Court of Justice – claim no. QB-2018-0004473
"On 27 February 2020, an order was made in the High Court of Justice prohibiting anyone from entering in or remaining at The Shard or Shard Place without permission.
Anyone in breach of this injunction will be in contempt of court and may be imprisoned, fined or have their assets seized".So under this High Court order, if they tell you to go because you're packing a SAK and you kick up a fuss or start bleating legalities at them, you may well find your collar getting felt.
Go ahead.
They can arrest you "on suspicion" of anything they like - After all, you will have been asked not to bring any bladed items and you show up with just such a thing... that's pretty suspicious, if you ask me!
They may not actually charge you with a crime in the end, but you'll still have to endure the inconvenience of being arrested, detained and processed, however long that takes... all because you wanted to be a smurf-head over a pretty minor legal interpretation. Even if it's just causing harassment, alarm or distress contrary to the Public Order Act 1986, or another similar offence, which in plain speak is known as being a smurf.
!You can't use a court injunction agains people trying to climb the outside of a building to cover somone turing up with a legal item on their person that an establihment has decided they don't want you to bring in.
The private establishment can refuse entry but that's it - anything else that might happen has nothing to do with the original issue of entry into a private establishment
my simple point was if you face such a situation don't be bullied into believing you've broken the law - you havn't, the law doesn't change because you've entered said establishment - only in a select few is it the case,
Of course if you kick off you are on your own
-
@SAKPal said:
You can't use a court injunction agains people trying to climb the outside of a building to cover somone turing up with a legal item on their person that an establihment has decided they don't want you to bring in.Of course you can - The wording is deliberately vague and covers a wide range of possibilities. This is what lawyers are for.
Context is key and discretion is paramount. Anywhere that has metal detectors and armed Police securing it is not the place to be testing the finer points of legal interpretation.@SAKPal said:
my simple point was if you face such a situation don't be bullied into believing you've broken the law - you havn't, the law doesn't change because you've entered said establishment - only in a select few is it the case,You don't need to break a law to be arrested. Also, Police officers won't always know the full nuances of every single law but carrying a knife in today's Knife-Crime UK climate, especially to a place that clearly prohibits such things, is reasonable grounds enough for a suspicion that can lead to an arrest.
It is a bit like carrying a jerry can of petrol into the pub - It's not illegal to carry petrol in a public place, but that doesn't mean you should.
-
@Tasky said:
Of course you can - The wording is deliberately vague and covers a wide range of possibilities. This is what lawyers are for.
Context is key and discretion is paramount. Anywhere that has metal detectors and armed Police securing it is not the place to be testing the finer points of legal interpretation.Context is key- indeed, that's my point,
- metal detectors and armed Police* I wonder how much Qatar pay for that and why they would need it for a commercial building...
and if they are in the wrong, call them on it, ignorance of the law is no excuse after all ;)
@Tasky said:
It is a bit like carrying a jerry can of petrol into the pub - It's not illegal to carry petrol in a public place, but that doesn't mean you should.And you could be asked to leave by the landlord, but you can't be arrested for it
Anyway I've derailed the thread and won't do so further
-
@SAKPal said:
Context is key- indeed, that's my point,- metal detectors and armed Police* I wonder how much Qatar pay for that and why they would need it for a commercial building...
Doesn't matter - They have the same kind of security that Windsor Castle has. Presumably there's a reason, but the end results are the same... and so are the prerequisites of entry, pretty much.
@SAKPal said:
and if they are in the wrong, call them on it, ignorance of the law is no excuse after all ;)Again not a factor, because you would only be arrested on suspicion of something.
The point is, they've asked you in advance not to bring any blades, so don't be an arse about it.
-
@Tasky said:
Doesn't matter - They have the same kind of security that Windsor Castle has. Presumably there's a reason, but the end results are the same... and so are the prerequisites of entry, pretty much.Doesn't matter to you that a foreign power are either using your taxes or paying members of the crown to 'protect' them from your legal right to do something?
@Tasky said:
Again not a factor, because you would only be arrested on suspicion of something.You cannot legally be detained for a suspicion of 'something'
@Tasky said:
The point is, they've asked you in advance not to bring any blades, so don't be an arse about it.there is no legal obligation if you are 'asked' - something is legal or it isn't
'terms of entry' are for the most part a civil matter
-
@SAKPal said:
Doesn't matter to you that a foreign power are either using your taxes or paying members of the crown to 'protect' them from your legal right to do something?Not a factor in this topic, especially without substantiation of such an assertion.
@SAKPal said:
You cannot legally be detained for a suspicion of 'something'So I don't know exactly which law or legislation a given officer will choose to arrest you on suspicion of breaking or breaching.
Doesn't change the fact that if you're being a smurf, they WILL find something on suspicion of which to arrest you.@SAKPal said:
there is no legal obligation if you are 'asked' - something is legal or it isn'tI'm sure shouting that as they drag you away that will sway the populace into rising up in revolution against the corrupt foreign-owned establishment, perhaps even singing stirring songs of the ilk most commonly found in musicals about Victor Hugo novels... but you'll still be dragged away.
You may not be breaking one specific law with this approach, but you're likely pushing your luck with several others in the process... and armed Police tend not to smurf about with malcontent pedants waving Gov.uk printouts at them.@SAKPal said:
'terms of entry' are for the most part a civil matterThe Police can still escort you off the premises, along with various other civil-based actions in order to 'keep the peace', plus various other actions under their powers if they believe you have committed or are about to commit a crime. That might need some questioning and sorting out down the station, but you're still going for that ride.
Or you could just... y'know... be reasonable and not take a knife where you've been asked not to.
-
Well, this has all kicked off since my last post, hasn't it

I only wanted to see what, if anything, would have been said/done. I work at an airport and carry some kit that I wouldn't be allowed to as a passenger (and I have no problem with that)
I was simply curious as to whether my Classic would get in, just because it says "airport style security" (the operative word being "style") Airports have various legislation & rules that they MUST enforce from both the DoT & the CAA etc (my Classic has travelled on numerous occasions with no issue) It would seem that, on my last visit to "The Shard" all was good as well.
Other points have been raised which, as someone whose job it was to enforce both the law (and bylaws) on the dirty streets of London, I shall refrain from commenting upon, mostly, lest I am out of date (I usually am
)I would just say that 99% of arrests made by me (and my colleagues) were "on suspicion of # offence" and moreover; you can be detained for various reasons, such as a search of person under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 (sect. 23) or PaCE 1984 (sect.1) These were my most used ;)
My experiment was just a bit of fun which stemmed from curiousity of how it might pan out

[i]NB: The MPS* do not guard the building (inside or out) but, as it falls within their jurisdiction, they are often seen out & about nearby on foot and in vehicles, both armed and unarmed. I think given it's attraction to those that would seek to harm all of us** then it's a jolly, damned fine splendid idea
- I've also seen CoLP, MoD and BTP units on patrol nearby (again armed or otherwise)
** Awlso SAK wielding maniacs ;)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
