The best "bare bones" SAK.
-
For me the best bare bones is a combo: Pioneer/Soldier and Classic.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
ALOX is thinner than comparable cellidor models because it doesn't use the same kind of internal framework as the cellidor models do.The Soldier is a great knife and has spawned many variations. I am certain you will find it to be pretty handy. The tools are also heavier duty than the cellidor tools so don't be afraid to punish this one a bit. It'll take it and come back for more.
But if you really want to go minimalist, check out the Waiter/Bartender. According to UnknownVT in the SOSAK forum, it has the highest function/size ratio of any SAK, and that increases greatly if you add Plus scales and an eyeglass screwdriver.
Def
If we're serious about thread resus then

The Waiter plus small screwdriver.
-
The first thing that comes to mind is Spartan or Tinker because these are really the basic SAK tools. I had a Tinker back in the 60's which had a cut groove nail file on the squared off side of the philips driver on the back and I suppose that epitomizes the basic bare bones knife for me. The current Spartans and two layer Tinkers don't have a file any more so I suppose a Sportsman or Cadet fits the bare bones category for me now. I have a Compact which I am still getting used to. In a way it's thin, but not bare bones. All sorts of bells and whistles. Honorable mention for Ambassador and Executive.
-
I've carried a 91mm Tinker for nearly 30 years. I wanted a nail file, so I cut off one of my wife's diamond nail files, rounded off the edges and super glued it to the back side scale. Have done that for two Tinkers in that ca. 30 years. Works great and adds almost no weight. My best "bare bones" SAK.
(Please don't tell my wife - I did buy her replacements) ;) -
Firstly; props for one of the biggest necro-threads I've seen.

Absolute minimum SAK for me is the Ambassador.
-
Bare bones = one layer!
For me the 93mm Solo.With more than one layer, the bone is not really bare.
Just my own unimportant opinion... :D -
Come to think of it the Pioneer is a pretty good 'bare bones' option. These 93 mm Alox knives are very robust and the silver ones are quite resistant to in-pocket scratching. I'm going to carry mine today. Pretty great for opening boxes, packages, etc.
-
Pioneer would be a very worthy choice. I like a manager on
My keys but even though it’s 58mm not sure such a tool heavy combination counts as bare bones so…what about the oft overlooked Rally? Opener, blade, file (must have for me) and a reasonable selection of drivers in 1 layer!I also like the Sportsman.
-
As others have said, it really depends what your definition of “bare bones” is.
The alox Bantam provides a decent-sized blade, and the ability to handle bottles, cans, screws, and some light prying, all in one single layer of alox awesomeness that pretty much disappears in a pocket or even in a wallet. Lack of scissors is a negative though.
-
@nate j said:
As others have said, it really depends what your definition of “bare bones” is.The alox Bantam provides a decent-sized blade, and the ability to handle bottles, cans, screws, and some light prying, all in one single layer of alox awesomeness that pretty much disappears in a pocket or even in a wallet. Lack of scissors is a negative though.
Bantam X :ahhh 
-
@Helvetica Bold said:
Pioneer would be a very worthy choice. I like a manager on
My keys but even though it’s 58mm not sure such a tool heavy combination counts as bare bones so…what about the oft overlooked Rally? Opener, blade, file (must have for me) and a reasonable selection of drivers in 1 layer!I also like the Sportsman.
Sportsman is a great choice. Very tool dense in a small package.

-

Bare bones will mean different things to us all. My mind goes to Tinker/Recruit. While I know thinner SAKs are out there those come to mind.
-
I'm somewhat surprised that nobody has mentioned the narrower, slightly pointy 84mm models (Excelsior, Pocket Pal, Secretary, and etc). Those, plus the Swiss Army 1/Solo (and a few others I'm possibly forgetting) would be great options if you're after just a blade or two. If one wants additional tools, any SAK with one or two layers would fit the "bare bones" rule. One of my favorites is the Alox Bantam, which carries beautifully!
-
@Aloha said:
Bare bones will mean different things to us all. My mind goes to Tinker/Recruit. While I know thinner SAKs are out there those come to mind.Ordinarily I'd have said anything that roughly matches the original Offiziersmesser idea, which would be the Spartan toolset in modern models, as any other tools are technically additions to the bare bones of a SAK... although I prefer a Sportsman, myself.
However, the OP specifically states: "the Swiss Army Knife that has everything you could need during the course of a day, and abslotely nothing you don't need"... which again is subjective according to any individual's needs, yet also far more specific.
In the main, I suppose it could primarily go two ways - Only the absolute essentials one knows one will need on any given day (my Hunstman Lite)... or all the things one might or possibly will need (my SwissChamp)... but both would then be limited by the omission of anything one absolutely does not need, as the exclusion of those tools' layers would likely also eliminate some of the needed tools. Don't need a hook, lose the scissors, for example.
-
My vote goes for the Cadet. Covers everything for my urban needs. Everything else I carry is more for just in case or gets used once in a blue moon.
Besides the official functions I’ve used the openers as a light pry bar, scraper, orange peeler, corkscrew, and the nail file as a Phillips.
I prefer having separate can and bottle opener as I’ve used both for prying. So after buying the Compact I ended up using it for a week then into the drawer. The combo tool seemed flimsy in comparison. May have to sell it actually.
-
Tasky. -
Well this thread that has come back to life has prompted some very interesting debate.
But very good point Tasky - The ultimate bare bones SAK has to be the first Offiziermesser now known as the Spartan.
And good point about the slim 84s or solos, Farmer X - However for me, as blade only models, they kinda defeat the purrpose of a SAK/multitool
And as mentioned in my post above I use the scissors every day - So that is a must have, according to the OP question
-
Lots of well thought out and entertaining replies on this thread! Another thought: I don't have one like this but most of the 2 layer Delemonts come with a file so those are pretty close to ideal for me as a bare bones alternative, similar to Sportsman or Cadet.
-
@Anthony said:
What in your opinion is the Swiss Army Knife that has everything you could need during the course of a day, and abslotely nothing you don't need?There are some great responses and Tasky sure has me rethinking mine. While I still think Tinker/Recruit preferably in 84mm there are times when scissors are so darn handy. I have a Salesman which fits the bill nicely. I could make a case for my Explorer Plus since it was a SAK that I carried for a long while. It had it all and tools I used a lot. There was nothing I didn't use on it. Strong case for my Explorer Plus.
-
To elaborate on my original answer: I find that I use the large blade, small blade (which automatically eliminates the Compact from my consideration), scissors, tweezers, toothpick, and large driver/bottle opener the most. I don't use all of the tools every day, but those are the tools that I want on my SAK.
Obviously this list limits the choices to 91mm cellidor models.
The SAKs that have all of these tools but few others are the Super Tinker and Climber.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login