Favorite Sharpener
-
@RatBikeRod said:
So you kinda hit the nail on the head. I am buying used Leatherman’s and some blades. I am noticing some damage that I will need to whet stone out I think. This on both straight edged and serrated.So if you were going to go out tomorrow and buy the right things to correct some blade damage and then put a nice edge on them, what would you suggest? My blades I treat pretty well, but I am finding these others I am getting are sometimes somewhat abused.
Honestly it just comes down to grits and what you feel most confident using. The more work you need to do (i.e. the more metal that needs to be removed) the lower the grit you should start with to make your life easier. Then progressively work your way up the grits to your desired level of polish and strop to finish.
What matters more than the system itself is your ability and confidence in using them, then the geometry you choose to apply to the blade. Turnboxes and Sharpmakers are popular because they make setting a consistent angle easy, that might be appealing to you, on the other hand your experience with freehanding it on whetstones might make that kind of set up more familiar to you.
Personally I have a few random stones, a Wicked Edge Pro system and a Victorinox pen sharpener. I've had the 4 stick turnbox and sharpmaker previously.
-
You can use whet stones so stick with those. I would suggest SiC ( silicon carbide ) in a 1000/3000 combination stone for 420HC steel. FYI if you see a stone with Corundum its Aluminum Oxide which is ok but a slower cutting stone. I bought a cheap combination stone from that big online store and it has been great on my carbon steel knives. It dishes out but that cause its not a real high quality stone. If you want a high quality stone go with King. Otherwise buy whats in your budget but just my opinion stick with SiC.
If you are trying to repair say S30V I personally think Diamond is best and a less irritating experience. Those doggone carbides in S30V getting bulldozed using Sic vs sheared off using Diamond. If you want to mess with high carbide steels then 325mesh to 1200mesh will get you sorted. You can get a 325 and 600 only and be good to go.
Leatherman uses 420HC and responds well to the SiC ( silicon carbide ) in 1000/3000 combination stones so if thats what you'll mostly be working on then you will be set. You can always refine the edge using a leather strop with White then Green compound. I use basic stuff from a box store. You can also use bare leather or not strop at all to be perfectly honest. I get a little whacko so I go thru a whole progression for a mirror edge
. Totally not best call for every edge.FYI if you see a stone with Corundum its Aluminum Oxide which is ok but a slower cutting stone.
I hope that answers your question. 1000/3000 combination Silicon carbide. If you cannot find that Aluminum oxide is fine.
1000 side can repair most damage on high carbon steel. 3000 side will refine the work done from the 1000 side. Leather Strop to further refine the edge or leave it as is.
The Lansky Turnbox is great but wont take out chips or rebevel an edge. It'll hone the edge ( realign ) wonderfully and to an extent do some decent work. Not chip removal tho.
-
Thanks guys, this is exactly what I was needing. Think I will look for the SiC stones in the combo you noted and get the Turnbox for the finer work.
Much appreciated.
-
Happy to help. Water stones over oil is my preference. A good soak before use and you'll be set. Many come with a flattening stone which is nice. Don't break the budget on them. If I recall correctly I spent less than $25 for mine. Of course there are very expensive ones but really not needed. I'd spend the extra cash on diamond if you get into tougher or powder steels. DMT is a good brand but again you can get some really nice budget ones. Thats another convo tho if you decide to go that route.
-
I have stones, diamond files, ceramics.
I experiment with everything. I recently bought some dull knives and diamond has proved the fastest and most efficient way.
First the diamond (rods work on serrations too), then the ceramic and finally some stroping on a leather belt or denim cloth to remove steel dust.
Stones are more rewarding, using them feels like participating in an ancient ritual. But it takes more time.Στάλθηκε από το MAR-LX1A μου χρησιμοποιώντας Tapatalk
-
I have all sorts of sharpeners, rods, stones, ceramics etc. But i have now long time only wheatstone, vic dual-knife sharpener and Worksharp guided field sharpener. Worksharp and Vic sharpener when blade needs touch up or little dull blade and wheatstone when fully dull blade.

Only Tools Matters
-
Im not too hard on blades so Lansky turnbox works for me.
Sent from my SM-A326U using Tapatalk
-
@Aloha said:
Happy to help. Water stones over oil is my preference. A good soak before use and you'll be set. Many come with a flattening stone which is nice. Don't break the budget on them. If I recall correctly I spent less than $25 for mine. Of course there are very expensive ones but really not needed. I'd spend the extra cash on diamond if you get into tougher or powder steels. DMT is a good brand but again you can get some really nice budget ones. Thats another convo tho if you decide to go that route.Yea, I ended up getting a set of 400/1000/3000/8000 stones on sale along with the Turnbox for like $60. I will start there and see how I do.
-
Yeah that'll do. -
@RatBikeRod said:
Yea, I ended up getting a set of 400/1000/3000/8000 stones on sale along with the Turnbox for like $60. I will start there and see how I do.That's actually a really good deal, considering with so many option of grit.
I might be late to post, but another vote for crock stick sharpeners, such as Spyderco sharpmaker or Lansky Turnbox. They requires no setup and yield pretty consistent result with minimum practice.
-
I’ve had a lot of success with the DMT diamond sharpener kit
I like this D2 steel Statgear flipper but disappointingly arrived about as sharp as a butter knife, 5 minutes with the DMT and it’s like a razor

-
DMT
thats a kit that will handle a lot of steel. Sweet knife 
-
thanks Aloha 
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login