Whats the most complex multitool?
-
Not a ground-breaking thread here, but I just recieved a new AL in the mail to give as a gift(/topic/1934) and while I was checking it over, I started thinking about how complex it is. Aside from all the standard blades and tools, it's got four liner locks, two bit holders, and two button-style locks, not to mention those little tabs that hold the blades closed when the pliars are opened. I was happy it was all done perfectly, but I started thinking about what a QC nightmare these things must be! The Wave and Surge would be in the same boat too, and the Surge would add that blade exchanger too. Can you think of any tools more complicated than these on the market? Do you see this complexity as a good thing or a bad thing?
-
I haven't seen one in the flesh so to speak, but it looks to me like the SpyderWrenches look to be the most complex.
I don't think complexity is such a great idea in anything, and especially not tools. It adds more pieces to get broken or messed up, and the last thing you need in life is to be by the side of the road with a broken tool.
Look at the standard M-16/AK-47 debate. Certainly the M-16 is a far superior weapon with much greater range and accuracy, better ergonomics, better sights etc. But when you get right down to it, the AK will shoot no matter what.
When the poop hits the fan, you need something reliable.
Def
-
Ahhh, yes... the Spyderench. How could I forget that one? Definetly another tool with a complexity complex.
I tend to agree with you about the complexity issue for most things, although a good warrenty can smooth over a lot of my concerns. Simplicity is good, especially if the situation is crucial. But for EDC and work, etc. I'm rarely (if ever :D) in a really precarious spot, so enjoy the extra features as long as the tool remains reasonably solid. For me, the LM tools have always been solid. I'd love to get my hands on the Spyderench and see how it passes. -
I like the warranty as a fallback, but unfortunately that doesn't help you when you are at the side of the road or otherwise screwed and needing your tool.
Def
-
I believe that the most complex multitool would be the Swisschamp XLT. Though not a "plier based multitool" it has a lot of stuff. It is reliable though at least every SAK I have owned has never failed me. The Charge is complex but it depends on the definition of complexity I guess.
-
What about the XAVT?
http://www.sosakonline.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=201&Itemid=35
Or the Wenger Giant?
http://www.sosakonline.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=117&Itemid=0
Def
-
I wouldn't call those "complicated", more like "complex".
I'm not sure I get myself either.
-
@Defender said:
What about the XAVT?Or the Wenger Giant?
Def
::)
Possibly, but I think those are like making a Dagwood sandwich. You just keep stacking up parts until you run out of rivet and viola. They might be busy, but I think someone at Wenger must have spent a lot of time on MT.org and said, "Hey guys check this out. :o ..what if we crammed everything we make in to one too...all we gotta do is make a honkin big rivet." Or however you would say that in German (or Swiss or whatever).
I think the Crunch is pretty complicated. Did you look to see how they folded the jaws inside of it and it is still only 4 inches long. Kershaw couldn't even top that. Theirs has that really long sheath to keep it contained. I wouldn't want to sit down wrong with that on my belt. ;)
Rick
-
Def, you definately have me there. The Wenger Giant is "the" most complex multitool. The XAVT is the most useable of the complex tools. I am a little disturbed by the fact that the warranty ends at 2 years for the electronic devices on the SAKS. I would have bought the altimiter model a long time ago if I did not think that I would eventually break the altimiter. The XAVT is cool as well. The clock on the tool is a great idea. Perhaps one could use it to time how long it takes to open all the blades. :)
Would that fall into the same category as a person that times himself disassembleing and reassembleing various rifles, pistols, and shotguns while blindfolded? Perhaps I should buy an XAVT and try.
-
The Crunch is indeed a fantastic and somewhat complex tool, and I have always liked it's design. Other than the hunk of plier head that sticks out the side when closed, it is quite sleek for such a strong tool. I'd actually like to see a bigger version of it as well- maybe something Core sized.
Yeah, I didn't think those big SAKs really qualified for this discussion! The Giant was originally built in very limited numbers for display at trade shows and the like, but my contact at Wenger NA decided to see about cranking a few out for the collector's market. I was thrilled, and I will be even more thrilled when and if I ever manage to afford one!
Def
-
I wish they would come out with a big Crunch too (the Smunch). I doubt it though. They have seemed to move away from that type of customer. That tool was very specific. I use my vise grips all the time, but I rarely need it. The regular pliers are more my speed. Still, if they had a huge Crunch it would be great for around the house .....plumbing is big thing I'd use it for.
Rick
-
That's pretty much exactly what I was thinking of using it for as well. The Crunch size is nice, but the same thing only bigger would be much handier.
Def
-
Hmmm. Who might have a CNC that could machine out a double sized Crunch....???? HMmmm. If he happens to make one, I need to get one.
Rick
-
I think a giant size Crunch would be cool. However, I'd rather just carry a pair of large vise grips for such a job that would require such a tool. Not saying that a large crunch could not do the job but it would just be one of those "job specific multitools" and I hate tools that do not have a multiple purpose. Then again it would serve many purposes if you did a lot of plumbing work. I guess that it would depend on what you do most. I debated buying a crunch a while back for the locking plier aspect. I dont do very much plumbing but I could sure use those locking pliers sometimes and they dont even have to be that big.
-
You have a good point there- the locking head pliers do seem like they are limited in their use versus a regular plier head, but they can also be used as regular pliers as well. They don't have to be locked.
The locking head isn't just for plumbing- we've probably all been in the situation where we've had a hell of a time trying to loosen a rusted or corroded bolt and just couldn't get a good enough hold on it with any other tool, and that's the kind of thing the Crunch really excels at.
Def
-
Locking pliers are great. Not to offend anyone but my friends used to make fun of me for using the "Polish socket set" far to often.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login