Corkscrew or Phillips SD (VOTE)
-
@marlowe221 said:
I know this topic comes up from time to time, but I think it's a good idea to revisit stuff like this because, as time goes on, people change their minds. And that's OK!For example, I would have said "corkscrew, of course!" if you'd asked me a week or two ago. But I'll be darned - for some reason I've been reaching for Tinkers and Tinker cousins a lot lately. And that back Phillips has come in handy on one more than one occasion too!
So, I'm not voting yet. I'm thinking...

This is so true, I have been all over the map on the corkscrew vs Philips but I have decided on the Recruit (no backside tools). Who knows I could change my mind again, always good to revisit the options.
-
I voted Phillips because I use that more than I use a CS!
However, I would prefer an 93mm Alox with an in-line option (4 layers max)
Basically a PX with a Phillips or an FX sans saw (either way it MUST have scissors) 2D is do-able awlso

-
I voted corkscrew, but honestly, I no longer have a strong preference either way. I like the Philips simply because it provides a more comfortable resting place for my thumb, and it also holds the straight pin in place even if the pin is loose in the slot. I like the corkscrew because it is great for untangling knots and holds the mini driver.
The fact is that there are simply more models with the corkscrew; the current Philips models stop at the Fieldmaster and Deluxe Tinker. So I had to get used to the corkscrew in order to expand beyond the Tinker and its relatives. My favorite model, the Explorer, has both the corkscrew and an inline Philips driver, which makes this question moot.
-
Matters not to me. Each has its purpose, and I have examples of each that see carry time.
-
Years ago I would have chosen the phillips but I am more a corkscrew fella these days. While I know the can opener can be used as a phillips I never or rarely do. I like the ability to carry my mini driver in my corkscrew.
-
I forgot to add that the corkscrew is great for opening hard to open jars, I tip I learned here - definitely a use I wouldn’t have thought of on my own!

-
How does that work? Does it wriggle under the lip to release the pressure?
-
The single biggest detractor to the Philips on SAKs is that they don’t fit into the recessed slots that are for kids toys battery compartments.
-
I’d have to go Philips, I have absolutely no use for wine, and I’d rather have a screwdriver on hand even if not in the best of locations, I customized a compact which I think is just about perfect, heck I drew one that I think makes total sense and would be perfect!
JR

-
Very cool drawing and design MP!

-
-
@MadPlumbarian said:
I’d have to go Philips, I have absolutely no use for wine, and I’d rather have a screwdriver on hand even if not in the best of locations, I customized a compact which I think is just about perfect, heck I drew one that I think makes total sense and would be perfect!
JRIs that specifically the old school square Phillips, or just drawn that way?
-
@mansedan said:
The single biggest detractor to the Philips on SAKs is that they don’t fit into the recessed slots that are for kids toys battery compartments.That is the case way too often! It's also the reason why, no matter which 84mm or 91mm SAK is in my pocket on a particular day, the Rambler is always with me. The 58mm combo tool is one of the best tools in all of SAK history IMHO.
-
@BPRoberts said:
Is that specifically the old school square Phillips, or just drawn that way?That was drawn freehand, I'm not the best, drafting with a tee and squares, then we’re talking!
JR -
@MadPlumbarian said:
I drew one that I think makes total sense and would be perfect!I might be missing something here, but it looks to me like you’ve drawn up the currently manufactured Vic Fieldmaster.
-
P.S. I can’t see the poll in Tapatalk, but I’m a corkscrew man all the way. I do use it for opening wine from time to time, but it’s good for so much more than that. Obviously it holds the mini-screwdriver, but it is also a fantastic little marlin spike for untying knots in just about any cordage whose diameter is less than the distance between the turns (e.g. shoelaces). In addition, it’s good for digging things out of small spaces, like a broken piece of plastic out of a USB port or rice out of the charging port of an iPod (both true stories).
The BSP, meanwhile, really only has one function. And, as others have noted, it isn’t even great at that one function due to it’s awkward position in the middle of the knife, and the fact that it is too big to fit most of the now-ubiquitous battery compartment Phillips screws.
-
@nate j said:
I might be missing something here, but it looks to me like you’ve drawn up the currently manufactured Vic Fieldmaster.Pretty much, no small blade and the scales are alox, I had a fieldmaster but someone stole it, if it had the file on the hook or the small blade was replaced with a nail file I think that would be pretty much perfect, I mean wenger made the handyman / evolution 18, which has the nail file but no hook, and is only 85mm, and I hate the openers,
JR -
Yes - put the tip under the lid and rotate gently until the seal goes “pop” - the lid can then be unscrewed with relative ease.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

