The October 2022 EDC Fixed Blade Challenge
-
The Guardian 3.5 has just enough extra length that it might make a difference to someone with larger hands. I think that's what I'd get if I ever decided to go that direction.
Glad to have you with us Echotech.
01 Alan K.
02 GA1dad
03 Sos24
04 Aloha
05 Pacu
06 comis
07 Nix
08 cody6268
09 GearedForwards
10 old Lefty
11 harm
12 LoopCutter
13 Echotech
14
15 -
[attach id=0 msg=2365662] In your picture the Guardian is the top knife in your picture and it is a ESEE knife?
The Izula II is the bottom knife pictured?

-
Those are both ESEE knives. Top is the JG3. Bottom is the Izula II.
I don't own a Bradford Guardian. -
@Aloha said:
I know you're a big fella. May want to handle a Izula. Your mitts might be too big? I love my Izula on that note. Small and capable. Plus it carries so darn nice. I do wish we could conceal carry our fixed blades. Just so I don't have to tuck in my shirt on the side I carry it on. I could also pocket carry my smaller ones.We can pretty much carry any fixed blade as well as long as its in clear sight in a sheath.
I do have some big hands.
I have my Ontario Airforce survival knife, not a good edc option
A Cold Steel Recon Tanto 3V , again not a great edc option. It is an awesome knife though. A bit silly but i grew up with Soldier of Fortune magazine ads with Cold Steel in the 80's.
::) ::)and a Spyderco Bow River that may be an option to carry.

-
I've brought out a few fixies for consideration:

Please vote for one of the above for me to carry for Fixtober!
A. Breeden Custom -- a simple design and a really nice knife
B. Becker BK11 -- solid drop point with some trail time behind it.
C. Buck 102 Woodsman -- a classic.
D. Fiddleback Bowlegged Joe -- eccentric design, small, but functional.
E. Fiddleback Bushboot (I think) -- sweet drop point.Vote by letter and/or name. Whichever blade gets the most votes is the one I'll use in Fixtober!

-
That's rather a bold move leaving your EDC up to the rest of us. Some of us might even be deranged. I'm not sure I could risk it myself. Since you are taking votes though, I vote for D, the Bowlegged Joe. It looks like an interesting piece.
-
Surprised you did not include your 113 Ranger? Is it much larger than your selected models?

I have selected B !
A’s handle appears larger and therefore may get in the way.
C is a option, slim and sleek , may be to long for pocket duty if had to visit a populace area.
D & E ‘s handle appear significant and may be too bulky.
-
@Alan K. said:
That's rather a bold move leaving your EDC up to the rest of us. Some of us might even be deranged. I'm not sure I could risk it myself. Since you are taking votes though, I vote for D, the Bowlegged Joe. It looks like an interesting piece.

D +1

Nix it’d definitely be interesting to see it an action for 30 days, the small size coupled with the wharncliffe/cleaver blade should do well at food prep and slicing but how much will you miss something larger and with a more all round blade shape ….if you’re up for the challenge we’re up for watching

Really like the look of E too so if D is a bit of an ask for 30 days, then E, they’re both very nice looking knives

-
D +1

Nix it’d definitely be interesting to see it an action for 30 days, the small size coupled with the wharncliffe/cleaver blade should do well at food prep and slicing but how much will you miss something larger and with a more all round blade shape ….if you’re up for the challenge we’re up for watching

Really like the look of E too so if D is a bit of an ask for 30 days, then E, they’re both very nice looking knives


-
@Pacu said:
I do have some big hands.I have my Ontario Airforce survival knife, not a good edc option
A Cold Steel Recon Tanto 3V , again not a great edc option. It is an awesome knife though. A bit silly but i grew up with Soldier of Fortune magazine ads with Cold Steel in the 80's.
::) ::)and a Spyderco Bow River that may be an option to carry.

Your Spyderco Bow River looks like a good carry however it'd be fun to see that Cold Steel in this challenge at some point.
-
@Nix said:
I've brought out a few fixies for consideration:
Please vote for one of the above for me to carry for Fixtober!
A. Breeden Custom -- a simple design and a really nice knife
B. Becker BK11 -- solid drop point with some trail time behind it.
C. Buck 102 Woodsman -- a classic.
D. Fiddleback Bowlegged Joe -- eccentric design, small, but functional.
E. Fiddleback Bushboot (I think) -- sweet drop point.Vote by letter and/or name. Whichever blade gets the most votes is the one I'll use in Fixtober!

I would say use them all!
However, if you want to carry only one my 2 cents go to Joe!Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
@Nix said:
I've brought out a few fixies for consideration:
Please vote for one of the above for me to carry for Fixtober!
A. Breeden Custom -- a simple design and a really nice knife
B. Becker BK11 -- solid drop point with some trail time behind it.
C. Buck 102 Woodsman -- a classic.
D. Fiddleback Bowlegged Joe -- eccentric design, small, but functional.
E. Fiddleback Bushboot (I think) -- sweet drop point.Vote by letter and/or name. Whichever blade gets the most votes is the one I'll use in Fixtober!

i like E
i'll be using as many as possible
-
You only get to vote twice if you live in Chicago or New Orleans.
Their motto was always, "vote early and vote often." -
-

@Sos24 said:
I’m another one for D or E. E looks like it would be a great all around user, but D looks very interesting and unique, so I would love to know how it works for all sorts of tasks.Right now I've tallied:
A: none
B: 1
C: none
D: 4!
E: 1So, Sos, I need a solid D or E. Doesn't feel right to vote split....

-
-
E is for Excellent!

Right now I've tallied:
A: none
B: 1
C: none
D: 4!
E: 2Looks like the Bowlegged Joe is still in the lead......might make for an interesting month.....

-
@Nix said:
E is for Excellent!
Right now I've tallied:
A: none
B: 1
C: none
D: 4!
E: 2Looks like the Bowlegged Joe is still in the lead......might make for an interesting month.....

I wonder, can you shave with that cutie?
Saw one similar on sale at Knives Center by CRKT. A neck knife. 🙄
[attach id=0 msg=2366271]

-
I'm not sure it is shaving sharp at present, but is suspect it could be used for shaving purposes. The one factor holing it back a wee bit might be the unsharpened heel. That might limit its use as a proper shaving razor.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



