The October 2022 EDC Fixed Blade Challenge
-
These are some I intend to use in no real order.
Fiskars Puukko--5" blade. I impulse bought it on eBay for $20 shipped, as the Fiskars knives that aren't fish fillet knives are rare. I suspect Fiskars discontinued production of most of their own-brand knives after they bought Gerber in the '90s.
I believe this one is from the '70s or '80s. I had to use a zip tie to make it retain the handle a bit better, as it was sliding out easily.

Morakniv Basic. I think this one was one of the annual colors series, produced for the 125th Anniversary.

The common Military Green. As you can see, it's predominately been the "backup"

Morakniv Robust. Basically, it's a Basic with a much thicker blade and a dual-molded handle with rubber over-mold. I've used it very hard around the farm, and it shows. Hacking, chopping, splitting, and all kinds of rough use.

Blade is too thick in my opinion for general and kitchen use. It is why that, later on, I got the two Basics.
The Bahco Carpenter's Knife (a rebranded Clipper) was my first Mora, and the first fixed blade my grandparents allowed me to purchase.
It's done farm work, general this and that, and has been used to clean a fish.

I have a Companion as well, I just forgot where it went.
The Eldris is my favorite pocket fixed blade--but it's been carried on my belt, around my neck, and even on the side button of my overalls.
Most small fixed blades use a skeletonized design that is very painful. The Eldris has a real handle, and it is really comfortable for extended use.

The Classic #2 is fairly lightweight and carries in a pocket pretty well. The old plastic sheath design was poor, and the belt loop snapped off the first week I bought it. The new ones with a (partially) leather sheath are a lot more than the $15 I paid for this one. The full guard can be a pain in the rear, but it's very safe.

-
US-made, or at least built.
Camillus USN MK1 Deck Knife, post WWII build (made from leftover war effort parts; as "USN" is missing from the opposite side of the tang) with Tenite pommel.
Bought this one in terrible shape on eBay for near nothing. It cleaned up into a decent user, and it's been in my rotation for 4 years.
The Randall sheath I picked up recently fits it well.

Camillus USN MKII Combat. Bought again, for fairly cheap. Produced from the late '70s to mid '80s. I assume it has seen combat at one point, as the swedge was (re) sharpened and the original leather sheaht was full of sand.
I switched to the Kabar plastic sheath as the very sharp tip was wearing through the original leather one. It's heavy, but can be mounted virtually anywhere--I usually carry it on my belt, but have used zip-ties to attach it to a my 3-Day Assault Pack's MOLLE webbing.

Boker USA 155. Needs a new sheath, as the original is shot. This is the '70s version that didn't get as nice as a sheath as the '50s examples.
The USAF used a modified version as their Strategic Air Command survival/hunting knife, and I can see why. It gets the job done, feels good in the hand, and is lightweight. I'm leaning heavily towards it as my go-to hunting knife since I plan to deer hunt this fall. I asked Boker if I could purchase the sheath used for the Orient-made replica of the USAF version (which arguably, is better than any of the sheaths Boker USA supplied), and I never got anything back.

Buck 105 Pathfinder--'72-74 production .If it wasn't for the dumb design Buck currently uses with the traditional fixed blades, I would likely end up choosing this one as my go-to hunting knife. I haven't carried this one since I chose it for the Nessmuk Challenge. Buck describes it as a "mini" 119, and I have to admit, that's pretty true. It's really versatile.
I am also looking at adding a 119 or 102 next month.

-
Interesting selection cody. I'm looking forward to seeing them in action.

-
Great selection cody

I'm with you on the eldris, fantastic knife, recommended one to a mate just this morning
-
@Cody - You never found your ElMorro?
I was looking forward to comparing notes.I too, have a couple Mora 511s, one red as yours
Also a HD Companion which a very good bush craft knife.I like the Mora sheaths for their versatility to carry. In winter with Carharts, the button hook or fit into level pocket. When cold but not frost bit cold east the rig a long lanyard to make a crossbody and hang sheath to carry easily under my coat.
Up in the air how I will carry in my suburban world. -
@cody6268 said:
These are some I intend to use in no real order.Fiskars Puukko--5" blade. I impulse bought it on eBay for $20 shipped, as the Fiskars knives that aren't fish fillet knives are rare. I suspect Fiskars discontinued production of most of their own-brand knives after they bought Gerber in the '90s.
I believe this one is from the '70s or '80s. I had to use a zip tie to make it retain the handle a bit better, as it was sliding out easily.

Morakniv Basic. I think this one was one of the annual colors series, produced for the 125th Anniversary.

The common Military Green. As you can see, it's predominately been the "backup"

Morakniv Robust. Basically, it's a Basic with a much thicker blade and a dual-molded handle with rubber over-mold. I've used it very hard around the farm, and it shows. Hacking, chopping, splitting, and all kinds of rough use.

Blade is too thick in my opinion for general and kitchen use. It is why that, later on, I got the two Basics.
The Bahco Carpenter's Knife (a rebranded Clipper) was my first Mora, and the first fixed blade my grandparents allowed me to purchase.
It's done farm work, general this and that, and has been used to clean a fish.

I have a Companion as well, I just forgot where it went.
The Eldris is my favorite pocket fixed blade--but it's been carried on my belt, around my neck, and even on the side button of my overalls.
Most small fixed blades use a skeletonized design that is very painful. The Eldris has a real handle, and it is really comfortable for extended use.

The Classic #2 is fairly lightweight and carries in a pocket pretty well. The old plastic sheath design was poor, and the belt loop snapped off the first week I bought it. The new ones with a (partially) leather sheath are a lot more than the $15 I paid for this one. The full guard can be a pain in the rear, but it's very safe.

Nice set of knives!
I can sort of confirm your view on those Fiskars knives or their rabbit of slipping out of sheaths:
Way back in mid '80's I was on a military exercise in Lapland. Whilst prepping for position somewhere I found a similar Fiskars, just the knife, no sheath..
Probably it had slipped out of someone's sheath un-noticed. Good knife, still have it today and now I must use it for this challenge as wellEDIT:
Walked up to my fixie basket and here’s a photo of mine:

Found in Rovajärvi area in ’87 and used some as a general house beater since
-
I just ordered a Bradford Guardian 3.5 with sheepsfoot blade and micarta handle for the challenge. I've been wanting one and found it on sale for the best price I've seen. It's better to ask for forgiveness than to beg for permission. Besides, in my experience, sometimes you have to jump on a bargain or you'll miss it.

-
that will do a chicken up very nicely👍Congratulations. 🎊
-
@Alan K. said:
I just ordered a Bradford Guardian 3.5 with sheepsfoot blade and micarta handle for the challenge. I've been wanting one and found it on sale for the best price I've seen. It's better to ask for forgiveness than to beg for permission. Besides, in my experience, sometimes you have to jump on a bargain or you'll miss it.A very good looking knife! Congrats!
Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
@LoopCutter said:
@Cody - You never found your ElMorro?
I was looking forward to comparing notes.I too, have a couple Mora 511s, one red as yours
Also a HD Companion which a very good bush craft knife.I like the Mora sheaths for their versatility to carry. In winter with Carharts, the button hook or fit into level pocket. When cold but not frost bit cold east the rig a long lanyard to make a crossbody and hang sheath to carry easily under my coat.
Up in the air how I will carry in my suburban world.I did! It turned out it had not been stored with the other fixed blades.
It came in a lot, and had been used hard previously. One of the studs that holds on the belt loop had broken, so I took it off.

-
This challenge is going to be so fun. Nice looking blades everyone.

-
@old Lefty said:
Way back in mid '80's I was on a military exercise in Lapland. Whilst prepping for position somewhere I found a similar Fiskars, just the knife, no sheath..
Probably it had slipped out of someone's sheath un-noticed. Good knife, still have it today and now I must use it for this challenge as wellI like that!
Definitely used it! 
-
Just Arrived! This Bradford Guardian 3.5 Sheepsfoot in N690 steel with natural micarta handles. I can't wait to start using it. Just one more week to go if anyone else wants to join us.


-
This is the sign up list as it stands so far. If anyone else wants to join us copy and paste the list and add your name.

01 Alan K.
02 GA1dad
03 Sos24
04 Aloha
05 Pacu
06 comis
07 Nix
08 cody6268
09 GearedForwards
10 old Lefty
11 harm
12 LoopCutter
13 Echotech
14
15 -
@Alan - Is this really a Sheepfoot blade, it is not a straight flat edge from tang to tip. It tapers appearing to be more of a spear point.
Nevertheless, it is a blade shape I am attracted to for camp, hiking, and even game prep.
-
@LoopCutter said:
@Alan - Is this really a Sheepfoot blade, it is not a straight flat edge from tang to tip. It tapers appearing to be more of a spear point.Nevertheless, it is a blade shape I am attracted to for camp, hiking, and even game prep.
Someone may correct me if I'm wrong, but my understanding is that any of the blade shapes in this class may be flat or have a curve to their edge. I think what distinguishes them more is the spine turning down towards the tip in either an abrupt or gradual curve rather than turning up to meet the tip or having a straight back.

-
I do not dispute that the manufacturer names the blade style.
I was referring to my shape guide -
[attach id=0 msg=2370295]Sheep foot and Lambsfoot are same profile, difference is the spine tapers thinner to the tip on the Lamb. Sheep the spine is same thickness from spine to tip. A Wharncliff profile begins taper to tip near the tang. At least that is how a knife maker explained to me as to his rules between the three. Confusing !
Still I like the blade shape!!!

-
It is obviously Bradford Larkin's personal adaptation of a sheepsfoot. I liked it enough to order it but the real proof will be in using it for some time during the challenge. It also looks very similar to the first generation Myerchin Rigging knives which I am fond of and you may see one or two of them in the challenge as well.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
