The October 2022 EDC Fixed Blade Challenge
-
TL;DR answer: Yes
The rest of the story:
It’s not actually the kydex that scratches the knife, as kydex is softer than knife steel. However, the extremely tight fit of most kydex sheaths means that a small bit of dirt or a grain of sand that gets in the sheath has a good chance of being held against the blade with enough force to scratch it as it is removed from and returned to the sheath during normal use. (Quartz, an extremely common mineral, is harder than knife steel.)
In spite of this issue, I personally have a strong preference for kydex over leather sheaths for fixed blades that I carry. I like that the kydex is impervious to moisture, but most importantly, it is incredibly unlikely that the knife will cut through or penetrate a properly constructed kydex sheath in the event of an accident (e.g. falling on the sheathed knife).
-
We've reached the halfway point. Good work everyone.

-
Day 15
I switched back to the Bradford Guardian 3.5. I wanted to like this knife. I have liked other knives instantly, but I'm still not sure about this knife. It didn't feel good in my hand right out of the box and it is awkward to carry because of the extra length of it. By contrast, both of my ESEEs and my DPX HEST felt great in the hand right out of the box. Might be I should've tried the shorter guardian 3 instead. Sometimes a 3 or a 3 & 1/2 finger grip can be more comfortable than a full 4 finger grip.

-
Day 15 -
No cutting till late for prep of a snack.
This little el Morro has been easier to edc than expected. Cuts everything I have attempted without issue and the 420HC has required no additional touchup as well as not biting its owner, yet!
[attach id=0 msg=2374113]
-
Day 16
Eldris in the New South Wales bush with native Colo bra tree ;)



-
Day 15
One of the few things that I didn’t like about the ATK was how slick the handle felt. My other skeloton blades are powder coated and/or paracord wrapped, which helps them feel less slippery. Because of the sheath. A full 550 paracord wrap was not going to work on the ATK due to part of the handle going into the sheath, so I decided to try a gutted paracord wrap. I think it is going to work nicely.


-
**Day 14 **

A more pocket friendly carry with this forged kiridashi, wicked tip and a nice medieval feel to it, this one will likely repeat with the alternate custom leather sheath I have for it, but the kydex is more convenient to draw from.
-
Day 15

Couldn't carry to my covid booster and groceries, but around the house I went a little more back to basics with this sinew wrapped blade. The wrap is coming loose which is a shame and holds me back from using it more.
-
@Sos24 said:
Day 15
One of the few things that I didn’t like about the ATK was how slick the handle felt. My other skeloton blades are powder coated and/or paracord wrapped, which helps them feel less slippery. Because of the sheath. A full 550 paracord wrap was not going to work on the ATK due to part of the handle going into the sheath, so I decided to try a gutted paracord wrap. I think it is going to work nicely.


Looks great!
-
@Farmer X said:
Is Kydex notorious for scratching blades?
If so, I'll need a contingency plan if I purchase a knife with a Kydex sheath.It's pretty common for the reasons that Nate mentioned, I will say that not all sheaths do it and not all 'kydex like' sheaths are susceptible to it. I've never had this problem, or think I could have it, with Cold Steel's 'Secure-Ex' sheaths for example.
I've seen some makers put a material like suede inside the sheath before, giving you the utility of kydex but with a guaranteed soft inside that won't scratch up the blade.
-
@LoopCutter said:
The crazy stuff I have heard about the wilds of the BUSH, would thought a BIGGER KNIFE would have been along!!![emoji2957]Haha you would think

That’s not a knife etc
-
@Sos24 said:
Day 15
One of the few things that I didn’t like about the ATK was how slick the handle felt. My other skeloton blades are powder coated and/or paracord wrapped, which helps them feel less slippery. Because of the sheath. A full 550 paracord wrap was not going to work on the ATK due to part of the handle going into the sheath, so I decided to try a gutted paracord wrap. I think it is going to work nicely.


Great job

-
Day15
Thought blue and orange would look nice in today's pic.*And no that extention cord is not plugged in. I need it earlier but after reeling it back into the cube thought it would make a good pic.

-
Day 16:
Fiskars helping with a snack and a wee drink:

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Day 16
I used the scrimshaw Schrade 152 Sharpfinger to remove the safety seal on a bottle of pills.
-
Day 16

Small fixed blade from Lou Humphery attended coffee duty.
-
@nate j said:
TL;DR answer: YesThe rest of the story:
It’s not actually the kydex that scratches the knife, as kydex is softer than knife steel. However, the extremely tight fit of most kydex sheaths means that a small bit of dirt or a grain of sand that gets in the sheath has a good chance of being held against the blade with enough force to scratch it as it is removed from and returned to the sheath during normal use. (Quartz, an extremely common mineral, is harder than knife steel.)
In spite of this issue, I personally have a strong preference for kydex over leather sheaths for fixed blades that I carry. I like that the kydex is impervious to moisture, but most importantly, it is incredibly unlikely that the knife will cut through or penetrate a properly constructed kydex sheath in the event of an accident (e.g. falling on the sheathed knife).
I too prefer Kydex most of the time, since it does 'hold' moisture and I could keep the blade inside the sheath, regardless of steel, and not to worry about it rusting in storage. But the falling on knife sheath 'issue' is a good call, more a reason for a kydex sheath. The only potential drawback of a kydex sheath is if you carry the knife in extreme cold condition, then the sheath maybe too brittle to use?
-
@Sos24 said:
Day 15
One of the few things that I didn’t like about the ATK was how slick the handle felt. My other skeloton blades are powder coated and/or paracord wrapped, which helps them feel less slippery. Because of the sheath. A full 550 paracord wrap was not going to work on the ATK due to part of the handle going into the sheath, so I decided to try a gutted paracord wrap. I think it is going to work nicely.


Nice looking wrap, and a good compromise with the gutted cord.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

