The October 2022 EDC Fixed Blade Challenge
-
Y'awl have gotten me much more interested in fixed blades...so much so that I'll need to create a new thread on that topic. Thanks to Alan for hosting this challenge and everyone who made it such a joy to follow. Congratulations in advance to those who will be earning a badge!

There’s a BADGE!!!

-
Fixed blade knife user badge.

-
Day 31
I've enjoyed occasionally carrying a fixed blade knife for many years and have tried many knives over that time. My ideal EDC fixie is a knife that does everything for me that I would otherwise do with a folding pocket knife including being easy to carry on the belt, in a pocket, or around the neck, but in a sturdier, non-folding, format. Sadly, I still have not found the answer to the question about which knife is "the best" EDC fixed blade. I liked most of the knives in the challenge. My takeaway from this challenge is this, that different people have different needs and what is ideal for one of us may not suit everyone else. I bought the Bradford Guardian 3.5S for the challenge and found that it is a good user, but I didn't really like carrying it. I did enjoy carrying and using the old Schrade Sharpfingers in my collection, but Loopcutter didn't care for his Sharpfingers. Echotech also got the bug and purchased a new Sharpfinger and seemed to like it and Cody seemed fairly happy with his off brand copy. I liked the novelty of the Bow Legged Joe but I would probably never buy one. The Bark River Essential was a fantastic knife that seems to be just about right for an every day carry, and the knife HARM's dad made years ago was just awesome, although I had some concerns about it prying open paint cans. I both liked and disliked the Mora Eldris because it was easy to carry just stuffed in a pocket, or belt carried in a flashlight pouch, but it took 2 hands to deploy it which defeats some of the utility or usefulness of an EDC fixed blade knife. I did not try out the Gerber Vertebrae because that is for the lucky recipient to use and review, in this thread, as soon as possible after they receive it. And with that I shall commence with the drawing without further delay.
Revising the list of participants by removing myself, and those who dropped out of the challenge for their own reasons, resulted in the following 9 members who finished.
01 Sos24
02 comis
03 Nix
04 cody6268
05 GearedForwards
06 old Lefty
07 harm
08 LoopCutter
09 EchotechStarting with <u>1</u> and ending with <u>9</u> the random number generator delivered a result of <u>8</u>. Congratulations LoopCutter! Gordon, please PM your address to me. I will get your prize out as soon as possible, unfortunately it will be at least a couple of weeks before I can get to a post office.



-
Wow, a birthday gift!
Totally unexpected to receive that baby blue cutter.Thank you!
-
Congratulations LC
awesome prize Alan 
You're quite correct about me liking the Sharpfinger, I like it a lot. It's a good size for me, why I like the Mora Eldris too, although agree about it needing two hands

-
Congrats LoopCutter. Awesome gift Alan.
-
@Alan K. said:
Day 31I've enjoyed occasionally carrying a fixed blade knife for many years and have tried many knives over that time. My ideal EDC fixie is a knife that does everything for me that I would otherwise do with a folding pocket knife including being easy to carry on the belt, in a pocket, or around the neck, but in a sturdier, non-folding, format. Sadly, I still have not found the answer to the question about which knife is "the best" EDC fixed blade. I liked most of the knives in the challenge. My takeaway from this challenge is this, that different people have different needs and what is ideal for one of us may not suit everyone else. I bought the Bradford Guardian 3.5S for the challenge and found that it is a good user, but I didn't really like carrying it. I did enjoy carrying and using the old Schrade Sharpfingers in my collection, but Loopcutter didn't care for his Sharpfingers. Echotech also got the bug and purchased a new Sharpfinger and seemed to like it and Cody seemed fairly happy with his off brand copy. I liked the novelty of the Bow Legged Joe but I would probably never buy one. The Bark River Essential was a fantastic knife that seems to be just about right for an every day carry, and the knife HARM's dad made years ago was just awesome, although I had some concerns about it prying open paint cans. I both liked and disliked the Mora Eldris because it was easy to carry just stuffed in a pocket, or belt carried in a flashlight pouch, but it took 2 hands to deploy it which defeats some of the utility or usefulness of an EDC fixed blade knife. I did not try out the Gerber Vertebrae because that is for the lucky recipient to use and review, in this thread, as soon as possible after they receive it. And with that I shall commence with the drawing without further delay.
Revising the list of participants by removing myself, and those who dropped out of the challenge for their own reasons, resulted in the following 9 members who finished.
01 Sos24
02 comis
03 Nix
04 cody6268
05 GearedForwards
06 old Lefty
07 harm
08 LoopCutter
09 EchotechStarting with <u>1</u> and ending with <u>9</u> the random number generator delivered a result of <u>8</u>. Congratulations LoopCutter! Gordon, please PM your address to me. I will get your prize out as soon as possible, unfortunately it will be at least a couple of weeks before I can get to a post office.

very cool,thank you Alan.
congrats LC -
Congrats LC and very generous of you Alan!
-
Congratulations to LoopCutter, and thanks to Alan for a great challenge and giveaway! Was good to hear feedback on the Eldris, too.
-
Congratulations, LC!

-
Thank you Alan for your generosity and congrats LC!
Also thanks for everyone who participated and commented!
Fun month it was!Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
I appreciate your participating with us old Lefty. I would have liked to have seen more of the TOPS Micro Hawk.

-
@Alan K. said:
I appreciate your participating with us old Lefty. I would have liked to have seen more of the TOPS Micro Hawk.
Thanks!
Yup, frankly I was thinking that I would use the Micro Hawk more. As stated early on, it is the best carry "fixie" in my book. Small, light and compact.
A challenge is a challenge and in quest to allow all my fixies their turn there were few days when normally the Micro Hawk would've gotten a nod over any traditional bladeLähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
Based on my findings in this challenge, I bought an Izula today at New Graham Knives.
Why I didn't buy this thing years ago when I was first getting into fixed blades is beyond me. It's perfect! I screwed on the clip plate, and it fits into my back left pocket very securely.

The clerk handed me scales to a Candiru, which I didn't realize until I got home. Not sure if I should return them, or stash them in case I buy a Candiru. The Candiru is a little smaller and more appropriate for "in town" EDC than the Izula; and should actually fit in my sweatpants/shorts pocket around the house. Unlike the Izula, i can probably carry it in the chest pocket of my coat.
-
on the Izula. It my only Esee and its fabulous. I would love to conceal carry this knife for no other reason that its a great size for that. I carry mine canted horizontally with handle facing inward at 1ish o'clock. -
Cody - congrats on the Izula. If the store was giving you scales then yes return to get the proper ones. I would doubt you would step down in size to a Candiru.
I used mine for a few years with paracord wrap on the handle, with sheath attached to life vest for canoe trips and fishing, and even kayak fishing on some small lakes.
As I have aged I seemed a longer handle and acquired a II, same blade and same sheath. Difference is handle length. Then discovered Knife Connection, he has G10 scales that fit the Izula and provide the same length as a II model. The Tiger orange is what I am waiting for restock.
[attach id=0 msg=2377592]
The red on the right is the Izula!
-
@old Lefty said:
Frankly I was thinking that I would use the Micro Hawk more. As stated early on, it is the best carry "fixie" in my book.Sounds like you're pretty happy with TOPS, eh? I've been wondering how good they are.
@cody6268 said:
Based on my findings in this challenge, I bought an Izula today.
@LoopCutter said:
The red on the right is the Izula!A nice group!

-
And per Cody’s tip, I found a 3” blade Ozark drop point at a Rural WalMart today for under $6. Pictures tomorrow after sharpening.
The other fix blade was a TANTO style with partial serrated edge and tactical style sheath.The skinner style I picked has a nylon sheath, but it actually fits better in the Fast Finger sheath my USA model arrived with.
Cody knows where the bargains are to be found. 👍
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

