What light did you carry today?
-

It is nice there is a battery replacement option for the one in the video I linked. I agree it will be a shame when the battery degrades and there is no other option to keep it going. We'll see just how long the A5 I have will last. In the mean time its a really good light.
I'm a bigger fan of AA/AAA lights and more so ones that can take their lithium equivalents. I did dip my toe into the 18650 pond and wow. There's a lot of fun to be had. Not sure I'll fully submerge since its more practical to say in the shallow end for my purposes.
Time change tomorrow so I'll typically carry my keychain light, AAA light, and light saber.
-
@NutSAK said:
That's just semantics to me. I use a Sharpie marker (not abused) until it doesn't work anymore. It's a disposable item. You use it until you have no other choice than to dispose of it.I have LED flashlights that are nearly 20 years old and I still use. I can still buy cells for them and they still perform the task they were designed for perfectly fine. Nothing has made them truly obsolete, so I don't have to dispose of them. I can buy replacement parts for them. In many cases, I can buy parts to upgrade them to current technology, with more efficient drivers and emitters.
When you get to the point where your battery has degraded until the runtime is no longer useful for the tasks you ask of it and you can't buy a replacement cell to run your otherwise perfectly good flashlight on...well, I guess another way to put it is "engineered obsolescence". Tools should not be designed that way, in my opinion.
Clearly we disagree, and I'm going to highlight that by pointing out what you just mentioned is essentially Trigger's broom, or for international members, the ship of Theseus.
If you replace the emitter and the driver in a flashlight, then all that remains is the hollow tube. That is not a testament to 'repairability,' that's you building a new flashlight in the corpse of the old one. It's a testament to your desire to recycle and your love for a certain form factor, but if your argument goes down this route, you may as start talking about disassembling lights and replacing cells that were never intended for that, who cares about the intended design when you're just going to use the shell how you see fit, right?
-
The nights are fair drawing in (as they say around here) so it's time to get a bit more punch and runtime in the pocket. This Eagtac D25A Clicky has never let me down.

-
@GearedForwards said:
Clearly we disagree, and I'm going to highlight that by pointing out what you just mentioned is essentially Trigger's broom, or for international members, the ship of Theseus.If you replace the emitter and the driver in a flashlight, then all that remains is the hollow tube. That is not a testament to 'repairability,' that's you building a new flashlight in the corpse of the old one. It's a testament to your desire to recycle and your love for a certain form factor, but if your argument goes down this route, you may as start talking about disassembling lights and replacing cells that were never intended for that, who cares about the intended design when you're just going to use the shell how you see fit, right?
You may want to re-read what I said. I didn't refer to updating the driver or emitter as repair-ability, I referred to it as upgrading.
@NutSAK said:
In many cases, I can buy parts to upgrade them to current technology, with more efficient drivers and emitters.Please don't put words in my mouth. Repairing would be disassembling or replacing a switch, a lens, or off-the shelf orings. I was pointing out that, along with repairing, upgrading is another thing you can't do with that Rovyvon.
Your diatribe after misinterpreting my comments does make me curious however; do you consider replacing an engine in an automobile repairing it, or building a whole new automobile in the corpse of the old one?
-
@NutSAK said:
You may want to re-read what I said. I didn't refer to updating the driver or emitter as repair-ability, I referred to it as upgrading.Please don't put words in my mouth. Repairing would be replacing a switch, a lens, or replacing off-the shelf orings.
...
"I have LED flashlights that are nearly 20 years old and I still use. I can still buy cells for them and they still perform the task they were designed for perfectly fine. Nothing has made them truly obsolete, so I don't have to dispose of them. I can buy replacement parts for them. In many cases, I can buy parts to upgrade them to current technology, with more efficient drivers and emitters."
The first statement in bold and the last statement in bold are what I took issue with. You focused on the word repairability, I'm focused on it not being the same light for 20 years.
Note: saying that you do still have some that are 20 years old and still use stock doesn't invalidate this.
Like how you could use the same PC case, but replace every internal component. It wouldn't be the same PC, it would be a different PC in the same case.
But whatever, you prefer a certain approach, I prefer a mix. c'est la vie.
-
@GearedForwards said:
..."I have LED flashlights that are nearly 20 years old and I still use. I can still buy cells for them and they still perform the task they were designed for perfectly fine. Nothing has made them truly obsolete, so I don't have to dispose of them. I can buy replacement parts for them. In many cases, I can buy parts to upgrade them to current technology, with more efficient drivers and emitters."
The first statement in bold and the last statement in bold are what I took issue with. You focused on the word repairability, I'm focused on it not being the same light for 20 years.
Note: saying that you do still have some that are 20 years old and still use stock doesn't invalidate this.
Like how you could use the same PC case, but replace every internal component. It wouldn't be the same PC, it would be a different PC in the same case.
But whatever, you prefer a certain approach, I prefer a mix. c'est la vie.
I'm merely pointing out things that I can do with my flashlights that you will not be able to do with a Rovyvon for 20 years. Use them, replace the cells, repair them, and upgrade them.
How you thought all of my comments were about repair is beyond me. I also never said that those 20 year-old lights I still use had been upgraded. I only said that in many cases that is an option.
Either way, I will end the discussion to avoid further misinterpretation of my statements that may lead to argument.
-
I’m pretty much rolling with the PD40R V2 daily, and probably will continue to do so until something comparably sized comes out that soundly beats it in brightness, run time, or both.
Yes, it’s a bit on the large and heavy side for an EDC light. But it’s stunningly bright on the high end, while on the lower end it can easily go all night long, or last a full week of camping if used somewhat judiciously.

-
Wurkkos TS10, because it runs on Anduril 2

-
This one ;)

-
I keep lights with my leather slips. Fenix E05ss and Manker are great lights.

-
Been rocking this fenix ld01 as my edc for 9 years.

-
@gustophersmob said:
Been rocking this fenix ld01 as my edc for 9 years.I've got it's older brother, the L0D. Still a usable little light, even 15 years (!) later.
-
Solid lights -
@Aloha said:
I dont know if its regular item stocked
.On/off would suffice. I was pretty well set with my Zebralight SC52 L2 till I picked up an Olight S1R when they came out. I've always been intrigued by the Tiki and such so when Rovyvon came out with the Auroa with RED Aux LEDs I snapped it up. Its been on my keychain since and has really proved itself. Its more of a back up light.
I also have an early TOOL AA. Great light. I like both it and the ZL for their ability to use whatever cell I have handy, Eneloops are my go to but I also have 14500s for extra punch. The Olight sits at my bedside these days. Now to complicate my answer even further, I really love gadget-y so Anduril was on my radar for a long time. I was generously gifted a D4V2 that I LOOOOOOOOOVE. Talk about fun. Necessary? I'd say so since al my light bases are totally covered and whats wrong with a little fun?
I've got a handful of AAA lights as well and one in particular I have 2Xs, Fenix LD02. Brilliant light.
Again I can't argue with your logic with proprietary cells in particular the one we are discussing
.I'll say that since my "bases" are well covered it is super fun to have a play with new gadgets. YMMV as well as others milage. On/Off is all that is needed but I do enjoy the fun. Did I tell you about my D4V2 with aux LEDs?
I cannot begin to be thankful enough to Sos
. On Halloween I used lightening mode in my window and it was such a blast. My dear Sir, you'll get no push back from me when your right you're right. My other lights do what they need and some go a bit further with options. That's all fine and dandy. My Aurora with flashing red LED recently was used as I changed a flat on the side of the road. Whether it helped or my cars flashers helped or the fact I was well off the road or where I positioned myself or that I can change a tire in no time flat it was another level in my mind of safety.I do love my Eneloops and I do love a light that can take multiple cell chemistries.
Been away from this part of MTO too long.
I also have a TOOL AAA and love it so much. Sits in my Skinth until I need it. More of a back up role which is a shame as it’s modified and very bright.
Still dark in the morning while I do my pre trip so this old soldier has been putting in some work. Sunwayman V11R. Best variable light in the game imo. Just works.
Running a 14500 with the extender since there was an extra one laying around. Give the light a little extra brightness and can use Eneloops or regular AAs in a pinch. Actually like it being a little longer so there is more to grip when using the brightness wheel.

-
Nice light. Variable light is a very nice feature. I appreciate being able to adjust output that best suits what I need. Any light that accepts various cells is a bonus tho I am still loving my 18650 D4V2. Anduril is so much fun.
-
@Aloha said:
Nice light. Variable light is a very nice feature. I appreciate being able to adjust output that best suits what I need. Any light that accepts various cells is a bonus tho I am still loving my 18650 D4V2. Anduril is so much fun.Best thing about variable lights is being to have the light come on almost exactly as bright as you need.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

