Combo Edge Cooperative - partial to partially serrated blades
-
The serrations were not required in the making of "Chicken Ding" for Mrs Surge ;)

-
/topic/87756
I started a thread for the Combo Edge Challenge for next February

-
@ElevenBlade said:
/topic/87756I started a thread for the Combo Edge Challenge for next February

Joined

-
Went out for a camping trip with some pals.
One of them brought this knife along (or something similar). Being a user but not a knife-knut like me, both his fixed blade and the folder in his pocket have a serrated portion at the base of the blade. He's had this for many years, and the folder has been in his pocket for who-knows-how-long. He's never had any complaints with either. He keeps the pain edge sharp (the sheath has a honing rod on it that is small enough to fit the serrations too). He used the serrated edges for some paracord this time around... no trouble at all. The fixed blade did a bit of batoning, just being careful to use the middle of the length of blade.

-
The inaugural Combo Edge Challenge will commence on February 1st. (8 days from now)
Join us for the Challenge!!
/topic/87756
-
/topic/87756
The challenge begins tomorrow. Jump in with any knife of multitool that has a partially serrated blade. It looks like we have enough participants to get our own badge. Join us!!

-
@ElevenBlade said:
/topic/87756The challenge begins tomorrow. Jump in with any knife of multitool that has a partially serrated blade. It looks like we have enough participants to get our own badge. Join us!!

The first ever Combo Edge Challenge is in the books. Thanks to the mods for supporting our endeavors, and creating an official badge for a 30 Day Combo Edge Challenge.
Thanks to all the participants in the first challenge. We saw some awlsome blades in the fray - Benchmade, Spyderco, Gerber, Leatherman - and many others.
I'm already planning on hosting another 30 day Challenge starting February 2023, so do join us and get your badge!
-
Combo Edge Challenge!
February 2023. Use your combo-edged multitool or knife exclusively for 30 consecutive days, and get the 30-day Challenge Badge.
Show off your combo-edged multitools, and join the discussions.
/topic/90183
-
A Hogue K320A that I just got. It cuts pretty well!

-
I'm contemplating to join the CE challenge, but to the best of my recollection I don't own a CE blade of any kind.
This means that to join, I most likely have to get myself a CE blade. And this of course opens up to a philosophical thought process around what to get, and why.
The why, or what for, is probably the most important detail to address, and the "what" should hopefully follow quite logically from that.At some level I feel like this have to logically narrow down to a weight restricted activity. I mean, if weight (or bulk) isn't a big concern, and I know I might need one or the other - I'll likely bring both types.
There could be practical considerations as well, e.g. situations where you might need both types in rapid succession and don't have time to fiddle around with different blades or tools. Climbing or working at height comes to mind, where you often have only one hand available and want to finish off what you're doing before you lose your grip, concentration, dexterity or all of the above. I know this situation all too well, but for what I do, I need both types of edge close to the handle to achieve the right balance of force and control. YMMV.Then there's the intuitive bias against CE altogether, that makes this even harder. CE by its very nature gives you two short stretches of each edge type and if, like me, you prefer short blades. Each type of edge can quickly become too short to be useful.
Once you go from two blades to a CE blade, you also have to decide in advance where on your blade you will have the most utility from each edge type. Maybe a middle portion with serrations would be the best compromise? With a short stretch of PE at both ends, you can still make precision cuts against your thumb where you need very controlled force and feedback, like removing cable sheaths. PE toward the tip lets you finish off cuts against a cutting board or make precise cuts with the tip of the blade. SE in the middle, and pretty far back toward the heel, will still enable a lot of force to be transferred when cutting fibrous material. Both suspended and against a cutting board. Not sure such a CE blade exists, but I'd be very tempted to try one.I have quite a few full SE Spydercos, and I think they do great serrations. Especially after I've thinned- and shortened them out a bit they bite into material like nothing else. But even as much as I like them, I generally find a coarse PE to perform almost as well and be a better all round performer for generic use. CE could potentially be the best of both worlds, I'm just afraid that the caveats mentioned above quickly eats away on the perceived advantage.
If there was a perfect use case for CE in my life, I would probably have identified it by now, but sometimes we just can't see the forest for the trees, so I'm open to suggestions.
-
@aicolainen said:
Each type of edge can quickly become too short to be useful.
Once you go from two blades to a CE blade, you also have to decide in advance where on your blade you will have the most utility from each edge type. Maybe a middle portion with serrations would be the best compromise? With a short stretch of PE at both ends, you can still make precision cuts against your thumb where you need very controlled force and feedback, like removing cable sheaths. PE toward the tip lets you finish off cuts against a cutting board or make precise cuts with the tip of the blade. SE in the middle, and pretty far back toward the heel, will still enable a lot of force to be transferred when cutting fibrous material. Both suspended and against a cutting board. Not sure such a CE blade exists, but I'd be very tempted to try one.I was about to post something very similar haha! I definitely want PE closest to the handle for best control when doing things like trimming cigars and fingernails, and PE at the tip for puncturing, cleaning fingernails, etc., which leaves the middle section for SE.
I agree a blade would need to be at least 3” long (1” serrated in the middle, and 1” plain on each end) for this to possibly be practical, and longer would probably be better.
-
@nate j said:
I was about to post something very similar haha! I definitely want PE closest to the handle for best control when doing things like trimming cigars and fingernails, and PE at the tip for puncturing, cleaning fingernails, etc., which leaves the middle section for SE.I agree a blade would need to be at least 3” long (1” serrated in the middle, and 1” plain on each end) for this to possibly be practical, and longer would probably be better.
Great minds think alike :P
-
That was a good read aicolainen. I dont think I have any CE blades? Oh wait, I do, its a Vic. Carry on.
-
So far so good Elevenblade!

@ElevenBlade said:
That looks like it cuts REALLY well.
-
@aicolainen said:
I'm contemplating to join the CE challenge, but to the best of my recollection I don't own a CE blade of any kind.
This means that to join, I most likely have to get myself a CE blade. And this of course opens up to a philosophical thought process around what to get, and why.
The why, or what for, is probably the most important detail to address, and the "what" should hopefully follow quite logically from that.At some level I feel like this have to logically narrow down to a weight restricted activity. I mean, if weight (or bulk) isn't a big concern, and I know I might need one or the other - I'll likely bring both types.
There could be practical considerations as well, e.g. situations where you might need both types in rapid succession and don't have time to fiddle around with different blades or tools. Climbing or working at height comes to mind, where you often have only one hand available and want to finish off what you're doing before you lose your grip, concentration, dexterity or all of the above. I know this situation all too well, but for what I do, I need both types of edge close to the handle to achieve the right balance of force and control. YMMV.Then there's the intuitive bias against CE altogether, that makes this even harder. CE by its very nature gives you two short stretches of each edge type and if, like me, you prefer short blades. Each type of edge can quickly become too short to be useful.
Once you go from two blades to a CE blade, **you also have to decide in advance where on your blade you will have the most utility from each edge type. **Maybe a middle portion with serrations would be the best compromise? With a short stretch of PE at both ends, you can still make precision cuts against your thumb where you need very controlled force and feedback, like removing cable sheaths. PE toward the tip lets you finish off cuts against a cutting board or make precise cuts with the tip of the blade. SE in the middle, and pretty far back toward the heel, will still enable a lot of force to be transferred when cutting fibrous material. Both suspended and against a cutting board. Not sure such a CE blade exists, but I'd be very tempted to try one.I have quite a few full SE Spydercos, and I think they do great serrations. Especially after I've thinned- and shortened them out a bit they bite into material like nothing else. But even as much as I like them, I generally find a coarse PE to perform almost as well and be a better all round performer for generic use. CE could potentially be the best of both worlds, I'm just afraid that the caveats mentioned above quickly eats away on the perceived advantage.
If there was a perfect use case for CE in my life, I would probably have identified it by now, but sometimes we just can't see the forest for the trees, so I'm open to suggestions.
This is one reason why I like combo edges. On a Leatherman Wave and a Gerber MP600, which I carried for a good 7 years between the two, you have to decide which blade to choose at the outset. Once you choose, and do the job, you're all but finished before you decide you chose wrong. With a combo edge, you just adjust your angle of attack.
-
Less than a month to go. Join us!
/post/2386650
-
@ElevenBlade said:
Less than a month to go. Join us!/post/2386650
Just a few more days. Come join the fun!

-
Combo Challenge 2026, mini bonus, add favorite pictures here of combo blades being used.
[attach id=0 msg=2565050]
Two of my favorite knives with combo blades I enjoy using and carry. CASE COPPERHEAD with twin blades. A pumpkin carver.[attach id=1 msg=2565050]
My most favorite challenge, cutting natural and manmade materials
Shared tasks with two different styles of combos. SE forward, and, SE at pivot area.Opinel No8 Outdoor and Vic OHT


Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
