Recruit vs Cadet
-
I voted Cadet because I love Alox, find the nail tool more useful than a pen blade, and don't need the scale tools desperately. But, if the vote had been between Cadet and Sportsman? Now that I would truly struggle with.
-
Cadet. Without the backside tools, there's no justification for the extra bulk of the cellidor scales. Now a Salesman...
-
The added comfort in holding the thicker Recruit is all the justification I need. It’s not the tool set of the Cadet that’s the problem - it’s just too thin!
And it’s not that I don’t like the Cadet. I just like the Recruit more for reasons I’m not sure I can fully articulate yet. If I could buy a Cadet that is just like it is but with a “spacer” in the middle to add a little thickness, I would do it.
The Sportsman is the obvious halfway point between the Recruit and the Cadet, of course. And I own one but haven’t carried it much yet.
I do think of the Recruit, Cadet, and Sportsman as being very closely related though.
-
@marlowe221 said:
The added comfort in holding the thicker Recruit is all the justification I need. It’s not the tool set of the Cadet that’s the problem - it’s just too thin!I agree with this. Once it is that thin, it actually becomes too thin for me to feel good using. I voted recruit, but more often I will carry my sportsman.
This thread actually has inspired me to build a recruit with a file. Maybe the best of both worlds. May just be a lesser sportsman.
-
@Enginears said:
I agree with this. Once it is that thin, it actually becomes too thin for me to feel good using. I voted recruit, but more often I will carry my sportsman.This thread actually has inspired me to build a recruit with a file. Maybe the best of both worlds. May just be a lesser sportsman.
I haven't voted since I haven't used a Cadet, though I've been on the lookout for a used one. I'm curious how it feels in the hand.
I carry a Sportsman or a Tourist, but if you aren't pulling corks, I recommend the Recruit without hesitation. If you wear a suit to work and have to keep your nails extra tidy, a slim Alox Cadet would be ideal, but a two-layer Cellidor knife is far from inconvenient.
-
Another vote for the Cadet. because of awl the reasons awlready mentioned.

-
I cast my vote for the cadet. While I do own several recruits, my cadets get more pocket time. I keep a cadet in my phone case along side my folding reading glasses,
-
Recruit for me. Not much I can add that hasn’t already been said about reasons. The sportsman on the face of it should be the best combo of the current 84s but I haven’t carried the ones I’ve had over a recruit, waiter or walker. One of those three and a midnight manager on the keys pretty much takes care of everything for me…;0)
-
@proletenstahl said:
I haven't voted since I haven't used a Cadet, though I've been on the lookout for a used one. I'm curious how it feels in the hand.I carry a Sportsman or a Tourist, but if you aren't pulling corks, I recommend the Recruit without hesitation. If you wear a suit to work and have to keep your nails extra tidy, a slim Alox Cadet would be ideal, but a two-layer Cellidor knife is far from inconvenient.
I agree the recruit is very thin but the Alox makes it feel very solid and gives you a great grip. I was worried it would feel to slim but it doesnt at all. Its my EDC now
-
Cadet II is the answer. Too bad it's been discontinued for what, 50 years?
I have both, and I use both. I actually gave away two Recruits, but it wasn't until my current one that I started using them a lot.
-
Interesting you say Cadet 2, thats the one I have. I like it but I seem to carry my Recruit more. Great SAK and love the Red Alox one I have but I lean towards my Recruit more.
Its neat to read all the responses. Good thread.

-
Recruit for me, just that bit thicker makes it worlds more comfortable and the t &t come in handy .
-
Cadet for me, I don't really "get" the Recruit. When I want slim (and classy) I'll take the Cadet. If I don't mind the extra bulk of the plastic scales, I'd much rather have the back tools of a Sportsman or a small Tinker. To each their own I guess.
-
You're definitely right - the low profile of the back tools of a Small Tinker make it awfully close to the Recruit in terms of how it feels in the hand, etc. And while there's an argument to be made that the back Phillips isn't that useful (and the awl isn't ideal in that position either), at least they are there and not bothering you much even if you never touch them.
-
I'll abstain from voting. I own neither a Cadet nor a Recruit, and I don't believe I could pick one or the other.
-
Between the Cadet and Recruit, I'd go with the Tinker Small :D
Cadet is very thin in hand to use and the omission of scissors while including nail file irks me to the point where I built a Cadet X, which is slightly thinner still than the 2-layer cellidor 84mms, but feels better in hand than the Cadet and has an near-perfect toolset.
Tinker Small feels almost identical in-hand to the Recruit but adds T-Phillips, Awl, and the pin -- yet same thickness and only a hair heavier.
If you want a nail file, then pairing the Tinker Small with a Classic SD Alox, being so thin as to have effectively zero carry cost (can even be kept in a wallet), gives both scissors and nail file (which IMO should be together... most urgent nail issues for me are hangnails or cracked, both of which need scissors).
If I had to choose between Cadet and Recruit, I'd go with Cadet because it's a much slimmer carry (8mm vs 14mm) and cleans up really easily.
-
I’m with you on the combo. My vote for the Recruit was absolutely with the idea that my Rambler would also be in my pocket.
But I like the Small Tinker too and think the back phillips definitely has its place despite any flaws it may have.
-
Both useful to carry.
But one is more of a " gentleman's" knife and one isn't.I didn't vote.
-
Looks pretty decisive so far. I know Alox seems to be the tougher material but being able to change out scales is a nice refresh to any old haggard SAK. Also, of all the SAKs I've seen at the flea market that were clearly abused few has scales that were totally goners.
Not trying to change anyones opinion just saying celidor is tough enough for what a SAK does.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

