Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

~ The legendary PST challenge Nov 2022 ~

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Leatherman Tools
872 Posts 1 Posters 27.0k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Leatherman Tools
  4. ~ The legendary PST challenge Nov 2022 ~
~ The legendary PST challenge Nov 2022 ~
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Rich_SD Offline
    Rich_SD
    Posts: 4,339
    Rich_SD Offline
    Rich_SD
    wrote on last edited by
    #860 Quote Reply

      @McStitchy said:
      To everyone who watched us from the sidelines...

      :rofl:

      1 Reply Last reply
      • Adam5 Offline
        Adam5
        Posts: 8,411
        Adam5 Offline
        Adam5
        wrote on last edited by
        #861 Quote Reply

          Day 30

          As always, it has been a great time sharing photos, jokes, stories, etc... with you guys. And it has been a joy for me to carry a PST and related MTs. There are many more options nowadays in regards to plier-based multi tools, but none much better than the venerable PST.

          I leave you all with this message:

          1 Reply Last reply
          • WillieTheJanitor Offline
            WillieTheJanitor
            Posts: 537
            WillieTheJanitor Offline
            WillieTheJanitor
            wrote on last edited by
            #862 Quote Reply

              :woohoo: Day 30 of 30 :woohoo:

              It was an awesome 30 day challenge with PST and a bunch of great people... thanks a lot :cheers:

              lm.pst.ch.55.jpg

              1 Reply Last reply
              • nakken Offline
                nakken
                Posts: 3,732
                nakken Offline
                nakken
                wrote on last edited by
                #863 Quote Reply

                  @McStitchy said:
                  To everyone who watched us from the sidelines...

                  :rofl: :pok:

                  @Adam5 said:
                  I leave you all with this message:

                  Likewise, Adam :hatsoff:

                  Very cool photo, Willie :like:

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • Poncho65 Offline
                    Poncho65
                    Global Moderators
                    Posts: 88,523
                    Poncho65 Offline
                    Poncho65
                    Global Moderators
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #864 Quote Reply

                      Great pic, Willie :like: and badge awarded :woohoo: :like:

                      Great final pics, everyone 8) :salute: :like: :like:

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • WillieTheJanitor Offline
                        WillieTheJanitor
                        Posts: 537
                        WillieTheJanitor Offline
                        WillieTheJanitor
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #865 Quote Reply

                          :hatsoff: ... it was my pleasure gentlemen :cheers:

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • Grand_Banana Offline
                            Grand_Banana
                            Posts: 1,603
                            Grand_Banana Offline
                            Grand_Banana
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #866 Quote Reply

                              Day 30 of 30

                              Great challenge everyone. :cheers: Lots of great pics and uses for the good ol PST with a great group. Thanks, Steve for hosting! :hatsoff:

                              The Marlboro Country Store PST looks pretty good on the office book shelf. It might be on display for a bit.
                              [attach id=0 msg=2382893]
                              :multi:

                              E0AE7CEF-2608-4EDC-B307-6C256E805F73.jpg

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • BPRoberts Offline
                                BPRoberts
                                Posts: 3,383
                                BPRoberts Offline
                                BPRoberts
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #867 Quote Reply

                                  Day 30

                                  Handoff day for the Executive challenge next month!

                                  The best part of doing these challenges is having to carry a tool outside my normal comfort zone for a month. How annoying is it to have a multitool with no knife for a month? Do I really need scissors, or can a knife get the job done? How many tools can you cram into a multitool and still have it be pocketable. Is it worth it to cram a chisel into a pocket knife anyway? I especially like challenges that go back to the basics. The classic/original/minimalist models. It’s cool to see how much you can get done without all the extra doodads, or to try and figure out why a designed made some of the decisions they did when they didn’t have today’s technology, experience, etc. So when I started dropping the PST in my pocket late last month, I was pretty excited to see what I learned from the month. Instead, I was honestly left with more questions than answers. Mostly, how did this thing manage to launch one of the biggest multitool companies in the world?
                                  
                                  The basic tradeoff for any multitool is convenience vs capability. A Leatherman, Gerber, SAK, etc. will never have as good of a saw, screwdriver, or whatever as a single use tool. It does, however, fit in your pocket. Which means you can grab it to fix little stuff without having to walk across the workshop, over to the garage, into your car, or wherever for the toolbox. A good multitool is usually not “best” at anything (although we occasionally find a gem) but “good enough” (or ideally a bit better) at a lot of things, in a usable package. When we select a multitool, we have to decide how large of a tool we’re willing to carry, and what level of capability we want from it. Some people love keychain tools, because they’re light and handy, and always there. Other people would rather strap on a belt pouch and haul around a Surge, because they want to be able to fix as much as possible with the most usable tool possible. The “Goldilocks” mulitool for any person is the one that balances these conflicting desires as effectively as possible.
                                  
                                  The original Leatherman PST, was developed with the goal of adding an additional capacity that Tim Leatherman felt was essential, but lacking, in the traditional Swiss Army Knife: Pliers. After carrying it for a little over a month, I’m honestly baffled by how this thing ever managed to move units, let alone found a revolutionary mulitool empire. If Goldilocks is the mulitool that combines the greatest number of good enough features into a convenient package, the PST combines a lot of crap into an awkward one.
                                  
                                  Let’s start with the pliers, the keystone tool of the PST. The end of the tips are too thick to be good for a lot of needle-nose jobs (electronics, jewelry, etc.) but the base doesn’t open wide enough for something as basic as changing a shower head. Like any multitool implement, there’s an element of trying to split-the-difference here to hopefully be good enough at most stuff. Instead, they just wind up sucking at a lot of stuff. Awkward head size aside, the folding handles also limits the amount of force you can put on them when *opening* the jaws, leaving them unusable for an entire range of plier tasks. That’s not even getting into the hotspot issues of the unfinished edges. If I actually needed pliers regularly (as opposed to maybe kind of wanting them once a week or so) I think I’d just find a way to carry a small actual pair with me.
                                  
                                  
                                  Multitool pliers are tricky (I don’t know that I’ve ever used a multitool with a pair that I’d describe as *good*, but the PST pliers are both incapable and the starting point for many of the other design decisions on the tool. The 91mm Victorinox pliers aren’t great (a lot of times, they feel closer to a pair of glorified tweezers than pliers) but all they do is add a bit of bulk. They don’t make you turn your whole Swiss Army Knife inside out. 
                                  
                                  But the pliers are responsible for the inconvenient deployment (and selection) of the rest of the tools. On a light-medium duty multitool like the PST, convenience is key. It don’t mind having to fiddle a bit with my Supertool, because it’s doing heavier jobs and has more implements. But when I’m doing something basic like snugging up a screw on a dresser drawer or slicing an apple, I just want to get the job done. Easy enough on a traditional pocket knife: pull it out of my pocket, find the tool, pinch and go. With the Leatherman, I have to open the whole tool, perform the clump-fan dance (probably nicking my finger in the process), and make sure the rest of the tool is out of the way if I want to close the handles. There were a lot of times this month I kind of looked at a problem, sighed, and decided I didn’t care about that random loose screw enough. I’m usually the fix-it-guy when I’m out with friends and family, and the moment as they all stared at me getting the PST out for a job I’d normally have done in seconds was awkward every time. I kept half an eye on the Minichamp challenge on the SAK board this month, and you can see the disparity in usability there. Despite the fact that MC’s are smaller than one handle of the PST (but with about the same number of tools by the official count) people actually enjoy using them! The thread is full of people *using* their Minichamps, while this one has so many glam shots of PSTs doing nothing (except hanging out with other PSTs that also aren’t doing anything.) There are plenty of posts of people using the MCs just because they want to use them for something. No one is going to haul out a PST and pull out the knife just because it’s fun to open the mail with them, it’s a chore.
                                  
                                  And even once you get through all that to get out your tool, the spread that the PST leaves you with is pretty lacking. 4 different screwdrivers!? On a modern tool, we’d (rightly) decry this as padding just to move up the tool number (interestingly, the PST was originally listed with 11 tools, but Leatherman has apparently found 3 more over the years). In a tool that feels as cluttered as the PST, I’d rather have less filler and easier deployment. Do we really need 3 different sizes of flathead? If we do, is here a reason one of them couldn’t be built into the file or something? I don’t know how much difference going to 3 tools a side would make, but it couldn’t have hurt with clumping. Or they could’ve simply made room for a more useful tool.
                                  
                                  Speaking of which, where’s the saw on this thing? It’s one of the classic multitool implements, and instead we get a file? Not a bad tool to have, but (like the 4th driver) it just feels like a weird prioritization of space. If only those plier heads weren’t in the way, there’d be room for another “full length” tool and we could have both. About the best thing I can say for the handle tools on the PST are that they all work. None of them are exceptional, but they all do the jobs they’re supposed to.
                                  
                                  But all of this is looking back with 30 years of hindsight and development. It’s only fair to try to compare the PST to other tools in it’s size/price/age bracket. So I found one of the old ‘84 Cabela’s ads, and matched it up with a 1989 SMKW Vic brochure for prices (giving the Leatherman the advantage of 5 years of inflation) and the models from the 84-85 Vic catalogs. $40 to SMKW would get you: any 91mm up to 5 layers (the Champion isn’t listed, and the Swisschamp wouldn’t have been in production yet, without the pliers or bit-driver, 6 layers is a stretch), the 93mm Soldier (the Farmer isn’t on SMKW’s brochure, but since the Soldier is only $15, it’s a pretty safe bet that it would’ve been within the price range), or the 108mm Mauser (and presumably 2 layer GAK/Trooper/Safari). The 111mm line was probably just entering development, and not available yet (though again, most cost under $40 in 1989).
                                  
                                  The closest direct comparison would probably be the 91mm Ranger, which isn’t in SMKW’s catalog, but the equivalent Master Craftsman is $40, so it seems fair enough. Length, width, and weight all come in just a bit under the PST, so size isn’t a factor. You get Vic’s trademark doublesided slipjoint deployment, making it a lot handier to actually use. 
                                  

                                  Implement-wise both tools contain:

                                  1. Blade
                                  2. Can Opener
                                  3. Bottle Opener
                                  4. “Medium” Flathead
                                  5. Double-sided File
                                  6. Awl

                                  The Ranger also adds:

                                  1. Small blade
                                  2. Metal saw
                                  3. Wood saw
                                  4. Scewdriver/nail cleaner tip
                                  5. Scissors
                                  6. 2D Phillips
                                  7. Corkscrew
                                  8. Chisel
                                  9. Tweezers
                                  10. Toothpick
                                    (Not playing Vic’s game with counting the keyring, and the PST also has one anyway. Plus scales are just coming onto the scene, so we’ll leave those out as well.)

                                  The PST gives you:
                                  7. 3D Phillips
                                  8. “Large” Flathead
                                  9. “Small” Flathead
                                  10. Needle-nose Pliers
                                  11. “Regular” Pliers
                                  12. Hard wirecutters
                                  13. Soft wirecutters
                                  14. Ruler

                                  Even with counting the pliers/wirecutters as four seperate tools (feels like a stretch) the Ranger still comes in two tools ahead. Both have some stinkers (Vic’s chisel and LM’s pile of screwdrivers), but I think it’s a stretch to say that a mediocre (at best) pair of pliers can cancel out multiple extra tools, and better deployment. Were there that many people out there in the 80s who needed pliers, but didn’t need them to be very good, on their multitool that much? I’d love to hear from someone who was actually shopping for multitools when the PST came onto the scene. While I’m happy to sling around a Supertool or something for heavier jobs, the PST seems like it was hopelessly outclassed even when it first came out.

                                  handoff.jpg

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • Farmer X Offline
                                    Farmer X
                                    Posts: 13,847
                                    Farmer X Offline
                                    Farmer X
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #868 Quote Reply

                                      @McStitchy said:
                                      To everyone who watched us from the sidelines...

                                      Oh, but I have one. I'm just a little hesitant to carry it. I'll get another PST before next November, though.

                                      This was a great challenge to follow. The PST has aged well and endured. Truly a great job by awl! :hatsoff:

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • McStitchy Offline
                                        McStitchy
                                        Global Moderators
                                        Posts: 19,785
                                        McStitchy Offline
                                        McStitchy
                                        Global Moderators
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #869 Quote Reply

                                          Badge :salute: awarded Grand_Banana and BPRoberts

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • McStitchy Offline
                                            McStitchy
                                            Global Moderators
                                            Posts: 19,785
                                            McStitchy Offline
                                            McStitchy
                                            Global Moderators
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #870 Quote Reply

                                              @Farmer X said:
                                              Oh, but I have one. I'm just a little hesitant to carry it. I'll get another PST before next November, though.

                                              This was a great challenge to follow. The PST has aged well and endured. Truly a great job by awl! :hatsoff:

                                              :cheers:

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • Steelej1976 Offline
                                                Steelej1976
                                                Posts: 389
                                                Steelej1976 Offline
                                                Steelej1976
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #871 Quote Reply

                                                  @BPRoberts said:
                                                  Day 30

                                                  Handoff day for the Executive challenge next month!

                                                  The best part of doing these challenges is having to carry a tool outside my normal comfort zone for a month. How annoying is it to have a multitool with no knife for a month? Do I really need scissors, or can a knife get the job done? How many tools can you cram into a multitool and still have it be pocketable. Is it worth it to cram a chisel into a pocket knife anyway? I especially like challenges that go back to the basics. The classic/original/minimalist models. It’s cool to see how much you can get done without all the extra doodads, or to try and figure out why a designed made some of the decisions they did when they didn’t have today’s technology, experience, etc. So when I started dropping the PST in my pocket late last month, I was pretty excited to see what I learned from the month. Instead, I was honestly left with more questions than answers. Mostly, how did this thing manage to launch one of the biggest multitool companies in the world?

                                                  The basic tradeoff for any multitool is convenience vs capability. A Leatherman, Gerber, SAK, etc. will never have as good of a saw, screwdriver, or whatever as a single use tool. It does, however, fit in your pocket. Which means you can grab it to fix little stuff without having to walk across the workshop, over to the garage, into your car, or wherever for the toolbox. A good multitool is usually not “best” at anything (although we occasionally find a gem) but “good enough” (or ideally a bit better) at a lot of things, in a usable package. When we select a multitool, we have to decide how large of a tool we’re willing to carry, and what level of capability we want from it. Some people love keychain tools, because they’re light and handy, and always there. Other people would rather strap on a belt pouch and haul around a Surge, because they want to be able to fix as much as possible with the most usable tool possible. The “Goldilocks” mulitool for any person is the one that balances these conflicting desires as effectively as possible.

                                                  The original Leatherman PST, was developed with the goal of adding an additional capacity that Tim Leatherman felt was essential, but lacking, in the traditional Swiss Army Knife: Pliers. After carrying it for a little over a month, I’m honestly baffled by how this thing ever managed to move units, let alone found a revolutionary mulitool empire. If Goldilocks is the mulitool that combines the greatest number of good enough features into a convenient package, the PST combines a lot of crap into an awkward one.

                                                  Let’s start with the pliers, the keystone tool of the PST. The end of the tips are too thick to be good for a lot of needle-nose jobs (electronics, jewelry, etc.) but the base doesn’t open wide enough for something as basic as changing a shower head. Like any multitool implement, there’s an element of trying to split-the-difference here to hopefully be good enough at most stuff. Instead, they just wind up sucking at a lot of stuff. Awkward head size aside, the folding handles also limits the amount of force you can put on them when opening the jaws, leaving them unusable for an entire range of plier tasks. That’s not even getting into the hotspot issues of the unfinished edges. If I actually needed pliers regularly (as opposed to maybe kind of wanting them once a week or so) I think I’d just find a way to carry a small actual pair with me.

                                                  Multitool pliers are tricky (I don’t know that I’ve ever used a multitool with a pair that I’d describe as good, but the PST pliers are both incapable and the starting point for many of the other design decisions on the tool. The 91mm Victorinox pliers aren’t great (a lot of times, they feel closer to a pair of glorified tweezers than pliers) but all they do is add a bit of bulk. They don’t make you turn your whole Swiss Army Knife inside out.

                                                  But the pliers are responsible for the inconvenient deployment (and selection) of the rest of the tools. On a light-medium duty multitool like the PST, convenience is key. It don’t mind having to fiddle a bit with my Supertool, because it’s doing heavier jobs and has more implements. But when I’m doing something basic like snugging up a screw on a dresser drawer or slicing an apple, I just want to get the job done. Easy enough on a traditional pocket knife: pull it out of my pocket, find the tool, pinch and go. With the Leatherman, I have to open the whole tool, perform the clump-fan dance (probably nicking my finger in the process), and make sure the rest of the tool is out of the way if I want to close the handles. There were a lot of times this month I kind of looked at a problem, sighed, and decided I didn’t care about that random loose screw enough. I’m usually the fix-it-guy when I’m out with friends and family, and the moment as they all stared at me getting the PST out for a job I’d normally have done in seconds was awkward every time. I kept half an eye on the Minichamp challenge on the SAK board this month, and you can see the disparity in usability there. Despite the fact that MC’s are smaller than one handle of the PST (but with about the same number of tools by the official count) people actually enjoy using them! The thread is full of people using their Minichamps, while this one has so many glam shots of PSTs doing nothing (except hanging out with other PSTs that also aren’t doing anything.) There are plenty of posts of people using the MCs just because they want to use them for something. No one is going to haul out a PST and pull out the knife just because it’s fun to open the mail with them, it’s a chore.

                                                  And even once you get through all that to get out your tool, the spread that the PST leaves you with is pretty lacking. 4 different screwdrivers!? On a modern tool, we’d (rightly) decry this as padding just to move up the tool number (interestingly, the PST was originally listed with 11 tools, but Leatherman has apparently found 3 more over the years). In a tool that feels as cluttered as the PST, I’d rather have less filler and easier deployment. Do we really need 3 different sizes of flathead? If we do, is here a reason one of them couldn’t be built into the file or something? I don’t know how much difference going to 3 tools a side would make, but it couldn’t have hurt with clumping. Or they could’ve simply made room for a more useful tool.

                                                  Speaking of which, where’s the saw on this thing? It’s one of the classic multitool implements, and instead we get a file? Not a bad tool to have, but (like the 4th driver) it just feels like a weird prioritization of space. If only those plier heads weren’t in the way, there’d be room for another “full length” tool and we could have both. About the best thing I can say for the handle tools on the PST are that they all work. None of them are exceptional, but they all do the jobs they’re supposed to.

                                                  But all of this is looking back with 30 years of hindsight and development. It’s only fair to try to compare the PST to other tools in it’s size/price/age bracket. So I found one of the old ‘84 Cabela’s ads, and matched it up with a 1989 SMKW Vic brochure for prices (giving the Leatherman the advantage of 5 years of inflation) and the models from the 84-85 Vic catalogs. $40 to SMKW would get you: any 91mm up to 5 layers (the Champion isn’t listed, and the Swisschamp wouldn’t have been in production yet, without the pliers or bit-driver, 6 layers is a stretch), the 93mm Soldier (the Farmer isn’t on SMKW’s brochure, but since the Soldier is only $15, it’s a pretty safe bet that it would’ve been within the price range), or the 108mm Mauser (and presumably 2 layer GAK/Trooper/Safari). The 111mm line was probably just entering development, and not available yet (though again, most cost under $40 in 1989).

                                                  The closest direct comparison would probably be the 91mm Ranger, which isn’t in SMKW’s catalog, but the equivalent Master Craftsman is $40, so it seems fair enough. Length, width, and weight all come in just a bit under the PST, so size isn’t a factor. You get Vic’s trademark doublesided slipjoint deployment, making it a lot handier to actually use.

                                                  Implement-wise both tools contain:

                                                  1. Blade
                                                  2. Can Opener
                                                  3. Bottle Opener
                                                  4. “Medium” Flathead
                                                  5. Double-sided File
                                                  6. Awl

                                                  The Ranger also adds:

                                                  1. Small blade
                                                  2. Metal saw
                                                  3. Wood saw
                                                  4. Scewdriver/nail cleaner tip
                                                  5. Scissors
                                                  6. 2D Phillips
                                                  7. Corkscrew
                                                  8. Chisel
                                                  9. Tweezers
                                                  10. Toothpick
                                                    (Not playing Vic’s game with counting the keyring, and the PST also has one anyway. Plus scales are just coming onto the scene, so we’ll leave those out as well.)

                                                  The PST gives you:
                                                  7. 3D Phillips
                                                  8. “Large” Flathead
                                                  9. “Small” Flathead
                                                  10. Needle-nose Pliers
                                                  11. “Regular” Pliers
                                                  12. Hard wirecutters
                                                  13. Soft wirecutters
                                                  14. Ruler

                                                  Even with counting the pliers/wirecutters as four seperate tools (feels like a stretch) the Ranger still comes in two tools ahead. Both have some stinkers (Vic’s chisel and LM’s pile of screwdrivers), but I think it’s a stretch to say that a mediocre (at best) pair of pliers can cancel out multiple extra tools, and better deployment. Were there that many people out there in the 80s who needed pliers, but didn’t need them to be very good, on their multitool that much? I’d love to hear from someone who was actually shopping for multitools when the PST came onto the scene. While I’m happy to sling around a Supertool or something for heavier jobs, the PST seems like it was hopelessly outclassed even when it first came out.

                                                  I enjoyed reading the PST Challenge, it is always fun. I think your post is really good and spot on about the PST and multitools in general. I really liked your in depth and historical analysis of a SAK vs the PST. I do disagree with you about the needle nose pliers part of the PST, I think they can do 90% or better of needle nose pliers tasks but where I do agree with you regarding the pliers is they don't open up enough for many regular pliers jobs.

                                                  I do think the Leatherman Wave (which I carry when I carry a multitool) solved many of the problems you listed with the PST but even the Wave is still a bunch of compromises. My own feelings regarding multitools match much of what you listed and that is why I typically just carry my SAK Tinker a pair of regular slip joint pliers but I do appreciate the PST and the revolution in multitools it inspired.

                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                  Register Login

                                                  1. Home
                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                  3. Leatherman Tools
                                                  4. ~ The legendary PST challenge Nov 2022 ~
                                                  Reply
                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                  Log in to reply
                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                  Operational Funds

                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                  Make A Donation
                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                  0% funded
                                                  • Login

                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                  • First post
                                                    Last post
                                                  0