✬ 2022 Chuck Yeager Memorial Challenge ✬
-
@aicolainen said:
Thanks for your elaborate comment.
I very much agree regarding the toolset preference. I would even like to see more models without knives. And SAKs with more than one knife blade is hard for me to even consider. Not because blades has become totally useless, far from it. They're still useful enough that I usually carry a dedicated folding knife, but when you on top of that mix and match a couple of MTs for optimal tool selection, the knife redundancy can quickly become ridiculous. It's sometimes (sadly) also nice to have knifeless options for legal reasons.
Deliberate mixing and matching of MTs is probably something only practiced by a small subset of nerds like us, so there's probably not a big incentive for the makers to make very specialized knifeless MTs. Thinking back to when I was a total noob myself and had a crush on the OG LM supertool, it was because it had the biggest and most of everything. Those types of tools are probably still hottest sellers in the noob demographics :)
Outside of these challenges, I usually carry a Cadet as my office MT. The can opener is ground down to make the 3mm slotted more useful for hard to reach screw heads. And with the large slotted and the 2D-ish philips provided by the file - it handles a surprising amount of the not so well planned needs in a very conveniently sized package. Still I try to come up with ideas on how to improve on this, i.e. even more driver tools, possibly pliers and/or a disposable blade holder, without going up significantly in size and weight. Another tangent, but those are my thoughts and I can't help thinking about this stuff ;)Yeah, the multiple blade thing can get kind of silly pretty quickly. For example, if I have a Spartan and Rambler in my pocket that's three blades between the two SAKs. Three blades! Do I really need three different blades on a day to day basis? Maybe there are folks out there that do... but I certainly don't! In theory, I get the idea of having separate blades of different sizes/shapes/one for backup/etc. But I'm honestly struggling to remember a time when that was really necessary for me - a time when I thought "It's a good thing I had blade #2 on me!" Then again, I don't often use a SAK for food related purposes, so that kind of thing probably varies by individual.
On the other hand, multiple tools capable of handling screws is something I find that I need on a regular basis. But one blade + scissors would probably see me through 95% of my days just fine in terms of actual cutting tools. I really like the Vic wood saw and have used it a good bit around the house and while camping but... that's why we own multiple SAKs!
Basically, I need Victorinox to start making the Alumnus (Sportsman + scissors) again. I did recently get an Evolution 14 as a "next best thing" but it wasn't long before this challenge started and I didn't have much time to carry it and test it out. To me, the nail file, bottle opener, can opener, and corkscrew all have a lot of "unofficial" uses and are all extremely versatile tools. Having them all on one SAK would be great!
To bring this back around to the Executive... It covers a lot of bases for me on a day to day level. I think I prefer the 84mm (and 91mm) chassis over the 74mm one though. It's not about size, particularly. I just like the way the tools are laid out on the 84mm and 91mm frames. The 74mm frame is more or less the 58mm frame supersized and I think it only scales up well to a limited degree. The tool layout/general mechanics of the knife are fine at 74mm but I have a hard time imagining that it would be if the Executive were scaled up to 84mm or even 91mm. But that's just me.
It's pretty darn good at 74mm though!
-
@marlowe221 said:
To bring this back around to the Executive... It covers a lot of bases for me on a day to day level. I think I prefer the 84mm (and 91mm) chassis over the 74mm one though. It's not about size, particularly. I just like the way the tools are laid out on the 84mm and 91mm frames. The 74mm frame is more or less the 58mm frame supersized and I think it only scales up well to a limited degree. The tool layout/general mechanics of the knife are fine at 74mm but I have a hard time imagining that it would be if the Executive were scaled up to 84mm or even 91mm. But that's just me.Well said....

Is the Exec the perfect SAK.... no. But the perfect SAK hasn't been made yet. What I do like about the Exec (and 74mm Ambassador) is that it is easy to carry and still very capable. The 74mm provides more handle to hang on to than the smaller SAKs like my beloved Classic, and the larger 74mm blade is definitely more useful. While I might, at times, want a larger SAK--love that Outrider--I don't really need a smaller SAK than the 74mm's. If that makes sense....

-
As stipulated, today has an executive with a shot glass of bourbon in honor of Gen. Yeager.
[attach id=0 msg=2384211]
As also stipulated a salute for reusing the photo from last year because I don't have an open bottle of bourbon handy for this year's photo, sorry.
[attach id=1 msg=2384211]
¯\_(ツ)_/¯

-
@marlowe221 said:
You're right about cutting tasks. In the Victorinox reddit, I often see people touting the Explorer and Deluxe Tinker as great EDC SAKs. And they are, even if they are a little bulky in some ways. But I wonder if people say that because those SAKs feature more tools for opening/manipulating things (screwdrivers, pliers, magnification, etc) versus actually cutting things. For myself, I use the opener layer of a SAK for all kinds of miscellaneous things at least as often as the blades, if not more so.When I actually DO need to cut something, it is opening a package or a product's packaging 95% of the time. But I find myself putting a lot of emphasis on a SAK's ability to handle screws (especially Phillips) when deciding whether to buy one. Hence my love for the Rambler!
But it's interesting - the world has changed a lot even in my lifetime so far. I'm 40 years old and spent almost my entire childhood in the "analog" era before this more "digital" one came along and changed everything. Having a blade is still useful, of course, and I am often glad I have one in my pocket. But how many blades do I actually need? I find myself needing non-cutting tools just as often as cutting tools these days it does have an effect on which SAKs I tend to use and carry on a regular basis.
Sorry to go off on a tangent there but I thought your comment was really interesting and it got me thinking about the tools I regularly need, something these challenges also get us to think about.
I think what you said made a lot of sense, and that's probably why Victorinox has such high sales volume, as compared to regular 'knives'. As much as I like all things sharp and pointy, if I can only choose a SAK or a blade for EDC, it will always be the SAK.
-
@marlowe221 said:
Yeah, the multiple blade thing can get kind of silly pretty quickly. For example, if I have a Spartan and Rambler in my pocket that's three blades between the two SAKs. Three blades! Do I really need three different blades on a day to day basis? Maybe there are folks out there that do... but I certainly don't! In theory, I get the idea of having separate blades of different sizes/shapes/one for backup/etc. But I'm honestly struggling to remember a time when that was really necessary for me - a time when I thought "It's a good thing I had blade #2 on me!" Then again, I don't often use a SAK for food related purposes, so that kind of thing probably varies by individual.On the other hand, multiple tools capable of handling screws is something I find that I need on a regular basis. But one blade + scissors would probably see me through 95% of my days just fine in terms of actual cutting tools. I really like the Vic wood saw and have used it a good bit around the house and while camping but... that's why we own multiple SAKs!
Basically, I need Victorinox to start making the Alumnus (Sportsman + scissors) again. I did recently get an Evolution 14 as a "next best thing" but it wasn't long before this challenge started and I didn't have much time to carry it and test it out. To me, the nail file, bottle opener, can opener, and corkscrew all have a lot of "unofficial" uses and are all extremely versatile tools. Having them all on one SAK would be great!
To bring this back around to the Executive... It covers a lot of bases for me on a day to day level. I think I prefer the 84mm (and 91mm) chassis over the 74mm one though. It's not about size, particularly. I just like the way the tools are laid out on the 84mm and 91mm frames. The 74mm frame is more or less the 58mm frame supersized and I think it only scales up well to a limited degree. The tool layout/general mechanics of the knife are fine at 74mm but I have a hard time imagining that it would be if the Executive were scaled up to 84mm or even 91mm. But that's just me.
It's pretty darn good at 74mm though!
Is the Exec the perfect SAK.... no. But the perfect SAK hasn't been made yet. What I do like about the Exec (and 74mm Ambassador) is that it is easy to carry and still very capable. The 74mm provides more handle to hang on to than the smaller SAKs like my beloved Classic, and the larger 74mm blade is definitely more useful. While I might, at times, want a larger SAK--love that Outrider--I don't really need a smaller SAK than the 74mm's. If that makes sense....

It's probably just me, but I always see 74mm and 58mm quite differently--maybe it has more purchase in hand or the larger scissors...but it certainly is a much closer relative to 84mm than 58mm(at least for me).
-
Day 7

No use today, but did put on a new lanyard and find a trad case to host the Executive in.
-
Day 07:
Here's to the man, not just the legend!


In addition, the Executive helped packaging a return item for Mrs Nix:

And sliced up some training treats for Adventure Girl:

A good day for the Exec. :D
-
Day 07.
Time for a toast to the memory of a quite remarkable man.
I'll spare you the T&T use pic.


-
Exactly! More handle and longer scissors. It does everything a Classic can and more.
Is the Exec the perfect SAK.... no. But the perfect SAK hasn't been made yet. What I do like about the Exec (and 74mm Ambassador) is that it is easy to carry and still very capable. The 74mm provides more handle to hang on to than the smaller SAKs like my beloved Classic, and the larger 74mm blade is definitely more useful. While I might, at times, want a larger SAK--love that Outrider--I don't really need a smaller SAK than the 74mm's. If that makes sense....

-
Day 7
A toast to an inspiration

The Executive also opened some dog food

-
Day 7:
I used the main blade to open a box with some Christmas inflatables for the front yard. I also used the scissors to trim a little nose hair.
No pictures of either, so have this one!
[attach id=0 msg=2384269]

-
Day 7
To chime in on the number of blades/size discussion: I think 74mm is the ideal keychain knife size. I've tried putting a Bantam on there, but it's too bulky, but the extra space over the 58s has obvious advantages.
I do use my SAK for food a fair bit, so I like having 2 blades. It's true that I sometimes wind up with 3, 4, or even 5 (a "main" 84 or 91mm and whatever is on the keychain), which is excessive, but I generally think of the Exec's (or whatever is on my keys) blades as a backup, not as excess.
On the Executive specifically, I kind of question the small blade. The large blade handles most food prep. The peeler handles packages. The small blade... exists? But as I've said before, I'm not sure what else could go in that slot. Wenger's tiny awl? The 58mm divot tool? A slightly larger screwdriver? There's not a lot that the Exec doesn't already have that can fit in that tiny half layer. Since I learned to open bottles with the peeler, the only "core" SAK tool missing would be a can opener. I'm not sure you could fit a satisfactory one in that slot, but I'd love to see the mod if someone could figure it out.
Regardless, I regrettably have no bourbon for The General, and today's use was slicing the worst pear I've ever had. I didn't even finish it.
General Quote: At the moment of truth, there are either reasons or results.

-
Do I need to carry six blades in total? No. But that doesn't stop me from carrying several knives at a time. (Today it's the Executive, a Pioneer, an Opinel No. 6, and a Schrade 77OT.) I guess I just like a little variety?

And a great Day 7, with some superb parting glass photos!

Day 7
A parting glass, containing Seagram's 7. It serves as a tribute both to BGEN Yeager and the souls who lost their lives in the attack on Pearl Harbor.
[attach id=0 msg=2384296]

-

@Farmer X said:
Do I need to carry six blades in total? No. But that doesn't stop me from carrying several knives at a time. (Today it's the Executive, a Pioneer, an Opinel No. 6, and a Schrade 77OT.) I guess I just like a little variety?
And a great Day 7, with some superb parting glass photos!

Day 7
A parting glass, containing Seagram's 7. It serves as a tribute both to BGEN Yeager and the souls who lost their lives in the attack on Pearl Harbor.
[attach id=0 msg=2384296]
-
I, too, lack anything for a toast as I'm away from home and bourbon is a definite no no where I'm at. My salute and respect to BG Yeager and those lost at Pearl and in the Far East that fateful morning 81 years ago.
-
@BPRoberts said:
On the Executive specifically, I kind of question the small blade. The large blade handles most food prep. The peeler handles packages. The small blade... exists?The small blade on the Executive is smaller than the "main" blade on the Classic....

When I first looked at the small blade, I wondered.....why? However, the small blade does have its place, I think. The orange peeler is good for cutting open tape and clam shell packaging, the hard plastic type, but it doesn't do so well with soft plastic bag material. So today, for example, I use the small blade to open a soft plastic bag, and the main blade to cut up dog treats. If I had to get rid of one of the three cutter blades, I'd ditch the orange peeler. Then I'd have a large blade for food tasks and the small for package and string duty. But, that orange peeler has its place and uses, so I'm glad to have it!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


Phil!
Looks perfect!