The October 2022 EDC Fixed Blade Challenge
-
Love seeing fixed blade built for other purposes doing all kinds of tasks. -
My apologies to the members of this challenge as I had been tardy posting the pictures of gift received from AlanK
I received his package with the Vertabrae around Thanksgiving. When pulled from mail box I just knew he had either misled on the size of the knife or fill the box with some real dense packing.
He included several surprises, 2 Tactcal stockings, a Gerber Mullet keychain tool, a Buck 875 folder, and the Vertabrae.
[attach id=0 msg=2384418]
[attach id=1 msg=2384418]
[attach id=2 msg=2384418]
The Buck 875 was a new knife I had no knowledge of. It is a sturdy liner lock, sharp as any Buck I have handled prior. After a little searching I learned it was part of a Buck gift pack that also included a Fix Blade model 876. Likely sold via a Sporting Goods store in the Central Southern States, West Mississippi, Louisiana, and Eastern Texas.
It feels good in the hand, with no edges, and the blade has a swedge on the blades back side starting just before the B, to the tip.Thank you Alan, for hosting the challenge, selecting a gift knife, conducting the drawing and then including the additional goodies👍🤪
I will post my experiences with Vertabrae (blue fixie) in a day or two, as I am still fiddling with it!



-
Thanks for the update LC, the Vertabrae looks a very practical size and shape with a comfortable handle

Great work Alan

-
Sweet looking gift pack.
Very generous AlanK
-
I'm glad you found everything to your liking LC. The Vertebrae is about the same size as the Mora Eldris so it should be very easy to carry. I'm looking forward to learning from you how good (or bad) it is in use.

-
The Vertabrae -
This knife was selected by Alan K as a gift to be awarded to a selected member who completed the OCTOBER EDC FIXED BLADE CHALLENGE.
I was selected the recipient of this knife!
I knife is a very familiar size, the blade is short, drop point, ideal of cutting many standard materials encountered on an adventure around camp or on a hike, and even doing tasks around the homestead.
The handle, is large, provides a round forgiving material that is comfortable and without hotspots that other smaller edc knives do provide 😉
The sheath, or more correctly identified as blade protector is imho is the Vertabrae’s downfall.
A long metal clip
Is connected to the cover and extends up the back side along the knife’s handle, preventing you from gripping the handle easily and release the cover from the locking latch.I did file the covers internal latch, reducing the bump and did improve my ability to release and remove the cover, when not attached to my belt or pocket.
I used the knife frequently these past several days instead of either my Buck or Izula II, cutting paper outlines, preparing supper by trimming meat and even cutting chicken quarters to have a leg and a thigh.
The handle is comfortable and blade indexing was natural.
Here are some comparison pictures with other two users.
[attach id=0 msg=2385214]
[attach id=1 msg=2385214]
[attach id=2 msg=2385214]
[attach id=3 msg=2385214]Continued…




-
Part 2, pictures of the release and blade indentation…
[attach id=0 msg=2385215]
[attach id=1 msg=2385215]Image of the inscription
[attach id=2 msg=2385215]In summary, as a result of my old fingers releasing the latch whil the knife is riding of my belt more importantly the inscription, I will not carry this knife, or will I leave and use for tasks.
In honor of my fellow members who completed the challenge and those that attempted (my MTo family), I am displaying the knife on my family room fire place mantel along with pictures of family , grandkids and other momentous friends have sent to be these past couple years.
[attach id=3 msg=2385215]Thank you Alan K and thank you friends!





-
Thanks for the write-up! I guess I'd consider a Vertebrae despite the lackluster sheath/blade guard.
-
thanks LC 
I'm a big fan of the Mora Eldris and this sized fixie in general, always good to know about the options

-
I'm glad you found the Vertebrae usable. Unfortunately, the scabbard has commonly been mentioned as the least favorite aspect of this knife according to several online reviews I saw. I think the extra long pocket clip was due to the Vertebrae being handle heavy. If they had a pocket clip that was just the height of the scabbard then the knife being handle heavy would want to roll out of the pocket and hang upside down. :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh It might have been better if they just made a deep leather sheath that the knife fit down into, the kind that covers most of the handle. It's an EDC knife for daily carry. It will never be confused for a combat knife, but trying to make everything they make appear (at least somewhat) tactical seems to have been Gerber's gimmick for the last 20 years. In this case they may have taken it too far.

-
, must say though the baby blue handles do make it a pretty bench knife.
And, with the engraving an attractive mantle piece for me😀 -
Since the end of the challenge I ordered myself another Schrade Sharpfinger. I was thinking to replace the sheath I had but found a new knife in the leather sheath was about the same price as just the leather sheath from most of the sellers on the bay. Comparing my old U.S.A. made Sharpfinger 152 to the new Chinese made 152OT there are subtle differences. First the Chinese knife is made of a cheap stainless while the U.S. Sharpfinger is an unknown high carbon. The blade on the U.S. knife has smooth transitions but the Chinese knife has hard lines. It's kind of like comparing a flat grind to a sabre grind, and the new knife also has a pronounced heel or sharpening stop. The handle on the old knife is very comfortable, with rounded edges but there are hotspots all over the wider handle of the new knife. It is so noticeable that I'm considering sanding the corners off the handle. I don't think it's just the difference of years of use either. I think the new knife's handles are just molded blockier than the original's saw cut Delrin. If anyone of you bought a Sharpfinger due to this challenge and found it uncomfortable that is something you might want to consider as well.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login