What's your latest flashlight?
-
@GearedForwards said:
Will be very interested in how you get on with it's performance as a powerbank, I can't imagine a light would be any good at that kind of thing but it will be interesting to see the results!I'll try to remember that.
I should say I don't use powerbanks a lot. I don't use my phone for power hungry tasks and I have steady access to chargers throughout the day, most of the time. It's mainly an emergency device/feature, and usually if I have to take out my powerbank, it's for somebody else's emergency.Now, besides being limited by the capacity of a single 21700 Li-Ion cell, I'm not sure exactly why I shouldn't expect a light to perform well as a powerbank.
The fact that it's a high output light, means they can't cheap out on some of the components that one might be tempted to save some money on in a dedicated powerbank. Now, this equation is obviously not just in favor of the flashlight. The fact that they have a more constrained weight, size and form factor canvas to work with, means that they might not de able to fit the most effective DC-DC converter, and with ample heatsink compared to most powerbanks, that isn't likely to be a problem heat-wise, but may translate to more heat loss and less energy transferred to the target device.
The specs are a bit mushy when it comes to charging speeds, as it doesn't differentiate between input and output, so I suspect it's only valid for input. If it's the same spec either way, I'd be very impressed:
5V/3A, 9V/2A and 12V/1.5AAt this point it's still a guessing game, and with my very basic needs concerning powerbanks, it may take some time for the facts to be revealed. My basic needs are also part of why it makes sense to opt for a dual use device, it might not be everybody's cup of tea.
-
@aicolainen said:
I'll try to remember that.
I should say I don't use powerbanks a lot. I don't use my phone for power hungry tasks and I have steady access to chargers throughout the day, most of the time. It's mainly an emergency device/feature, and usually if I have to take out my powerbank, it's for somebody else's emergency.Now, besides being limited by the capacity of a single 21700 Li-Ion cell, I'm not sure exactly why I shouldn't expect a light to perform well as a powerbank.
The fact that it's a high output light, means they can't cheap out on some of the components that one might be tempted to save some money on in a dedicated powerbank. Now, this equation is obviously not just in favor of the flashlight. The fact that they have a more constrained weight, size and form factor canvas to work with, means that they might not de able to fit the most effective DC-DC converter, and with ample heatsink compared to most powerbanks, that isn't likely to be a problem heat-wise, but may translate to more heat loss and less energy transferred to the target device.
The specs are a bit mushy when it comes to charging speeds, as it doesn't differentiate between input and output, so I suspect it's only valid for input. If it's the same spec either way, I'd be very impressed:
5V/3A, 9V/2A and 12V/1.5AAt this point it's still a guessing game, and with my very basic needs concerning powerbanks, it may take some time for the facts to be revealed. My basic needs are also part of why it makes sense to opt for a dual use device, it might not be everybody's cup of tea.
Ahh that makes more sense, if you rarely need one yourself then it'll likely do the job just fine.
As for why a flashlight wouldn't be a good one:
-
Ergonomically you can't practically hold both your phone and it in one hand like a powerbank, or rest the phone on top to take less space on a surface.
-
The charging is not only going to be slower, but also less intelligent in reacting to the different types of devices you're charging.
-
Single output
-
Less capacity for the weight/bulk you're carrying
-
The more you use your flashlight, the less charge you have available for your devices and vice versa.
I'm not opposed to this functionality, and for those like yourself, it might be more than sufficient. However, I'd never personally rely on one as my powerbank or choose a light based on it having that functionality. That's a personal preference, and I use powerbanks regularly with multiple devices, so a different set of needs.
-
-
@GearedForwards said:
Ahh that makes more sense, if you rarely need one yourself then it'll likely do the job just fine.As for why a flashlight wouldn't be a good one:
-
Ergonomically you can't practically hold both your phone and it in one hand like a powerbank, or rest the phone on top to take less space on a surface.
-
The charging is not only going to be slower, but also less intelligent in reacting to the different types of devices you're charging.
-
Single output
-
Less capacity for the weight/bulk you're carrying
-
The more you use your flashlight, the less charge you have available for your devices and vice versa.
I'm not opposed to this functionality, and for those like yourself, it might be more than sufficient. However, I'd never personally rely on one as my powerbank or choose a light based on it having that functionality. That's a personal preference, and I use powerbanks regularly with multiple devices, so a different set of needs.
You sound like a more advanced powerbank user than myself, so that shuffles the priorities around.
To your points (not to disagree, because I don’t, but rather to clarify my reasoning for anyone else who might see this as a relevant option::- Ergonomics is a none issue. I would normally charge my device in the backpack, and if for instance I need to use the phone while charging, the charging cable is long enough (1.5m) that I can have the light/PB in my pocket or on my desk while using the phone. I used my old PB the same way, and the light is more comfortable in pocket.
- I need to test/measure the charging speed, as the spec. is a bit ambiguous, but if it can deliver 15/18W as it kind of suggests, that’s the same as my (iPhone) wall charger - which isn’t bad in my book. By intelligent, I suppose you mean able to negotiate the fastest supported charging protocol? I wouldn’t know, but it supports multiple voltage levels in at lest one direction, so there is some intelligence.
- Single output could become an issue. Not typically a problem I’m likely to run into, but if it comes to show that the charging output is mediocre, one output could be a bottleneck. Though slow charging is really the underlaying issue in that case.
- 5000mAh is probably less capacity than most PB’s on the market these days. It’s not terrible for the size and weight though. My old PB, based on size and specs, contains 4x18650 with a combined capacity of 10000mAh. While not double the size and weight, it’s bulky and fragile. Which means I have to add impact and water protection for backpacking, hunting and similar scenarios. That’s added weight, bulk, worry and inconvenience I don’t have to deal with anymore. The ruggedness and dual use capability of the light comes at a slight disadvantage in mAh/(weight x bulk), but it’s worth it. And while not a practical solution for everyday use, it’s also adaptable. Let’s say I take it for a longer backpacking trip, e.g. a week or more, I could add the number of separate 21700 cells I deem necessary - and adapt the capacity to my needs. I.e. I don’t have to buy different size PBs to accommodate variable needs.
- The last point isn’t an issue with the device. The user just has to be mindful about what it’s for. I consider it a PB for all practical purposes, another device will be my primary light source. So it won’t be used as a light unless I’m in a pinch, and in that case I rather have a PB with a light feature than one without.
Some of this reasoning may fall apart if I find out that it does a poor job as a PB, but this is the hypothesis I’m working with.
-
-
After all the hype I decided to give the A5 a shot. I’m diggin the size.

-
-
*
The Rovyvon A28 gets about 50% of my EDC time, with the Streamlight Protac 2AAA get the other share. It has a pretty awesome feature set, including a side-mounted UV. I also have the A5 like ROC, which is my fidget and nighttime light when I'm wandering around the Powernoodle Compound.* -
Nitecore MH10S

-
Not exactly my latest flashlight, but my latest modification :
SFT40 emitter
OP reflector
and "tactical" forward switch (instead of the factory reverse clicky) ==> got some trouble to get it working and had to "shave" the rubber boot because the forward switch is taller than the factory one.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
-



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Red only? I like it. I carry a light with red accessory LEDs.
-
Thats great. I thought red was a gimmick because I was new to lights with anything other than white or back then amber. I have a cheap headlamp with red and green in addition to white. I love the red for exactly what it does, preserve night vision when in a tent. HAHAHA, my partner is very appreciative of that, as am I :D.Great at halloween too.
-
.
Sofirn
-
@Aloha said:
Thats great. I thought red was a gimmick because I was new to lights with anything other than white or back then amber. I have a cheap headlamp with red and green in addition to white. I love the red for exactly what it does, preserve night vision when in a tent. HAHAHA, my partner is very appreciative of that, as am I :D.Great at halloween too.
Night vision, meh. Not having insects flying in and around your mouth when you're trying to have dinner at camp .... Awesome :D
-
Yet another great use. Last night we dropped off my partners son to a shuttle bus for a party on the military base. They could have chosen a darker parking lot I'm sure ;). We get there and the chaperone had a clip board with the list of kids invited to the party. Not sure why she didn't have a light? A kid takes out his phone and POW, I was already reaching for my red led light. I turn mine on shine on the clip board, he turns his phones light off. Lighting a path bright is great, super dark parking lot, clip board with white paper, not so good.This is also where low lumens SHINE 8).
-
Ordered myself a Lumintop Frog, with both 10180 and 10440 options. Coming from China so I suspect it's going to be next year before I get to try it out.
-
NEBO Torchy 2K my wife got me for Christmas.
-
@Gareth said:
Ordered myself a Lumintop Frog, with both 10180 and 10440 options. Coming from China so I suspect it's going to be next year before I get to try it out.I was about to get one, but finally pulled the trigger on a Lumintop D1, I already have 10440 flashlight (Manker E02 II) and 10180 (Fenix UC02SS), and battery life is ... as expected
(and for what's worse, I couldn't find any 10440/10180 that doesn't have a bad self drain)
my preferred form factor is now 16340 for compactness (or 18350 if I also want to be able to use it as a full sized flashlight once in a while with 18650 battery and tube), I never go smaller (even 14500 aren't that good imho)But I am very interested with your feedback when you get it, maybe I'll reconsider my position

-
@m47mu74nt said:
I was about to get one, but finally pulled the trigger on a Lumintop D1, I already have 10440 flashlight (Manker E02 II) and 10180 (Fenix UC02SS), and battery life is ... as expected
(and for what's worse, I couldn't find any 10440/10180 that doesn't have a bad self drain)
my preferred form factor is now 16340 for compactness (or 18350 if I also want to be able to use it as a full sized flashlight once in a while with 18650 battery and tube), I never go smaller (even 14500 aren't that good imho)But I am very interested with your feedback when you get it, maybe I'll reconsider my position

Just got it in this afternoon. In it's 10180 form it has to be the cutest little light I've ever seen. :D First impressions are good, but I'm also a bit concerned by the battery life. We shall see if it's a problem in real life (and for my uses). I do find the illuminated switch an...odd (?) choice given the tiny cell capacity. I will be using the 10440 tube for the moment though. You can, of course, lock it out by giving the head a slight twist, but that gives you quite a faff of work to do in order to get your light on when you need it.

-
@Gareth said:
Just got it in this afternoon. In it's 10180 form it has to be the cutest little light I've ever seen. :D First impressions are good, but I'm also a bit concerned by the battery life. We shall see if it's a problem in real life (and for my uses). I do find the illuminated switch an...odd (?) choice given the tiny cell capacity. I will be using the 10440 tube for the moment though. You can, of course, lock it out by giving the head a slight twist, but that gives you quite a faff of work to do in order to get your light on when you need it.That backlight annoys me, I'm pretty sure there's a UI way to turn it off if you don't fancy hardware lockout.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login