Poker Face Challenge - January 2023
-
I now have 5 tabs of small fixed blades open. I was (mostly) done buying SAKs, and you guys had to start another challenge so I'd have something to buy!

My wife really likes the Mora though.
-
@BPRoberts said:
I now have 5 tabs of small fixed blades open. I was (mostly) done buying SAKs, and you guys had to start another challenge so I'd have something to buy!
My wife really likes the Mora though.
We try to be helpful......

-
@BPRoberts said:
I now have 5 tabs of small fixed blades open. I was (mostly) done buying SAKs, and you guys had to start another challenge so I'd have something to buy! :rant:My wife really likes the Mora though.
Seeing that we are talking fixed blades and trying to be helpful, I thought I’d let you know Arizona Custom just got a used Bark River Necker and Bravo EDC in and they’re still available.
-
I am looking forward to this challenge and how it is the luck of the draw. A good hand with a nice variety is always welcome and hoped for, but how do you choose if you only get 1 or 2? Especially if limited to one folder or one SAK.
-
Haven't done the challenge before, but my thoughts for if I could only carry 1 of each type:
Pliers: Probably my PST. It did me alright for November, and it's small enough to go most places without issue.
Trad/Folder: Some people say linesman or scout patterns count as traditional, so maybe one of them. Otherwise, you can't go wrong with a medium sized stockman.
SAK: I'm torn here between not wanting to lose my trusty Executive, and wanting a larger 91mm to do EVERYTHING given the lack of other options.
Fixie: I guess I'm sticking with the Mora. Unless I give in and try to express ship/find one of the others I'm looking at...
-
@BPRoberts said:
Haven't done the challenge before, but my thoughts for if I could only carry 1 of each type:Pliers: Probably my PST. It did me alright for November, and it's small enough to go most places without issue.
Trad/Folder: Some people say linesman or scout patterns count as traditional, so maybe one of them. Otherwise, you can't go wrong with a medium sized stockman.
SAK: I'm torn here between not wanting to lose my trusty Executive, and wanting a larger 91mm to do EVERYTHING given the lack of other options.
Fixie: I guess I'm sticking with the Mora. Unless I give in and try to express ship/find one of the others I'm looking at...
:D
-
Just double checking as I plan. There is no situation where I'd need more than:
-
More than 6 tools total (straight flush).
-
More than 2 of the same category, except for the very off chance that I get 3 or 4 (but not 5) of the same suit in a straight.
Correct?
-
-
@BPRoberts said:
Just double checking as I plan. There is no situation where I'd need more than:-
More than 6 tools total (straight flush).
-
More than 2 of the same category, except for the very off chance that I get 3 or 4 (but not 5) of the same suit in a straight.
Correct?
Here Nix did a great explanation on this challenge works:
You are right. Your hand determines which tools you CAN carry, but not must carry. If you end up with one of each, you can carry one, two, or all four for that period. So a high hand pays off in term of having flexibility and choices. ;)
Now, if you end up with just one tool, say a SAK, you must choose one SAK from your collection and use that one SAK for the period in question. Rotating through a bunch of tools from one category is not permitted. So chose wisely!
:ahhhSo basically the minimum requirement to enter the challenge is 1 tool from each category(SAK, MT w/ pliers, Trad/folder, Fixed blade), of course, if you have multiple in each category, you will have more choices to choose from if your hand allows it.
For example, if player has gotten a "straight flush" with Spades, then he/she could carry at least 1(any one, and can be switched daily), but up to 5, SAKs of his/her choice.

-
-
Looking/commenting on the OP, we're explicitly not suit locked for any flushes, or for 4 of a kind. I assume to avoid making higher hands "worse" than middling ones. Happy to play it otherwise if I'm misreading, but going by RAW:
Suit locked wording bolded, any tool italicized, interpretation <u>underlined</u>:
-
High card — you start the challenge with one (1) tool that corresponds to the suit of your high card.
<u>Max 1 of 1 type</u> -
A Pair — you start the challenge with one tool that corresponds to each of the suits of the two pair cards.
<u>Max 1 of 2 types</u> -
Two pair — you start the challenge with four (4) tools, one corresponding to each suit of the four cards that make up the two pairs.
<u>Max 2 of 2 types</u> -
Three of a Kind — three tools, one to correspond to each suit of the three of a kind.
<u>Max 1 of 3 types</u> -
Straight — five tools,** must correspond to the suits of the straight.**
<u>Max 5 of up to all 4 types, or as few as 2 types depending on the straight</u> -
Flush — four tools* of any type.*
<u>Max of 4 of 1 to 4 types of your choice</u> -
Full House — five tools, must correspond to the suits of the Full House.
<u>Max of 5 of 3 or 4 depending on the composition</u> -
Four of a Kind — five tools of any kind.
<u>Max 5 of 1 to 4 types of your choice</u> -
Straight Flush — Six(!) tools of any kind .
<u>Max of 6 of 1 to 4 types of your choice</u>
Generally, I assume most of us would rather carry more types of tools than more of the same type. No fixie is going to give you the versatility of an SAK, no SAK is going to give you as good pliers as a Leatherman, no Leatherman is going to give you as good of a blade as a good fixie, etc. Trad folders are up to your personal feelings on blade quality/deployment vs pocketability vs tools against fixies and SAKS.
There's a clear progression from high card to a pair (more types and tools) and pair to two pair (same number of types, but more tools.) Three of a kind is mostly a win. You lose a tool but gain a type.
Straight is the most variable, since you could (I think I did the combos right) wind up with a 4/1 split (arguably a small upgrade to two pairs, and a toss up the other way for three of a kind), a 3/1/1 (straight upgrade for three of a kind, mostly better than two pairs), or a 2/1/1/1 (a clear win unless you really like carrying 2 of 2 different types of tool).
Flush is an upgrade over most of the straight combinations, except for the 2/1/1/1, where it loses a tool but keeps the same type spread. Otherwise you gain a tool type (or 2) in exchange for a tool. It does give you the option to really load down on one type if you want though.
Full house is 5 tools of at least 3 (potentially all 4) types. Again, assuming my figuring is right you could have: 2/1/1/1 (same as the best straight) or 2/2/1 (a marginal downgrade to the flush).
Four of a kind is finally a straight upgrade over a straight (:D). Same number of tools, full choice.
Straight flush is, suitably (:D) also a flat upgrade.
-
-

I will be the dealer for the first round. Comis will take the deck on the second round.

As part of my duties, I have to declare the trump order of suits. As a romantic at heart, I'm setting Hearts, Clubs, Diamonds and then Spades:

For those who are new to poker, this means that if you have a high card hand with an Ace of Clubs as your high card, your hand can be beaten by an Ace of Hearts. A Diamonds flush will beat a Spades flush.
Don't worry if this still sounds confusing, your dealers are here to explain things as we go.
First hand to be dealt tomorrow! There is still room at the table, but after Jan 01, the table will be closed until another year!

-
I'm in need of a distraction. If my hand could be dealt early that would be appreciated, if not no worries.
-
Just to simplify things, here are two pieces of info for anyone entering this challenge for the first time:
-
Any players could enter this challenge <u>only needing 1 tool from each category</u>--they are 1 SAK, 1 plier-based MT, 1 Traditional knife/Folder and 1 Fixed blade. Of course, more tools in each category yields more option, subject to your hand/suits.
-
Please notice your hand (and suits) will dictate the max number of tools and the tool combination you can carry or choose from correspondingly.(Pls refer to the first post) If you are allowed up to 5 tools, you don't have to carry all five, but any number from 1 to 5 tools.
-
-
@GearedForwards said:
I'm in need of a distraction. If my hand could be dealt early that would be appreciated, if not no worries.This can be arranged. ;) And will be informative for the other new players. :D

-
@GearedForwards said:
I'm in need of a distraction. If my hand could be dealt early that would be appreciated, if not no worries.I second this.
Due to tine difference it would be great to get my cards some time tomorrow to not fail on day one (or is this already planed and meant by day0?) -
Might as well just do everyone's early. We're all so excited.

-
@Shuya said:
I second this.
Due to tine difference it would be great to get my cards some time tomorrow to not fail on day one (or is this already planed and meant by day0?)Yes! Day 00 is Dec 31. That way everyone can start the challenge on 01 January with a tool in his or her pocket. No one wants to be caught with out a tool! :ahhh
-
Ok, I've dealt four starting hands for the guys who live on the early side of the date line. I'll deal the rest in the morning, mountain time.
These should get us started and serve as examples for everyone. It felt like I had a hot hand this evening! Sorry if tomorrow's hand is a bit cooler......that's lady luck!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

