✬ 2022 Chuck Yeager Memorial Challenge ✬
-
@pa_strunk said:
Showing my “collection” of executives and a few directors.
-
The grandkids got a crawling tunnel for Christmas which was held closed by a piece of nylon webbing. Used Patch to cut out the seam holding it together to use on another project.

-
Day 30. Used the small blade to open a packet of mince pies today but an air map is more in the spirit of this challenge. I think you mentioned at the start of the challenge Nix that this was smaller than the Classic main blade. Like everything else about the Executive it nevertheless does everything you reasonably ask if it.
I've had a great time in this Challenge and thank you Nix for arranging it


-
Day 30:
Congratulations to awl who completed this challenge. And a special thank you to everyone who chipped in with snippets of and quotations by the good General Yeager.

Once again I find the Executive to be a fantastic little EDC. While I didn't do much on the great outdoors this past month, the Executive was perfect as an EDC for me. I'm in no rush to switch out to another knife tomorrow. (But participation in the Poker Face Challenge may require a new knife or tool..... :ahhh)
The nail file got used to help switch out some batteries on the thermostat. Sort of important at this time of year....


-
Day 30:
More Christmas-related toy surgery!
[attach id=0 msg=2389314]
I’ll post some final thoughts on the challenge later today, if I get a chance. If not, then tomorrow for sure.

-
My final thoughts on the challenge:
Overall, I think the Executive is a great SAK at a size that I find to be somewhat awkward in certain ways.
The orange peeler was definitely the standout tool on the SAK for me. I got a lot of use out of it - opening packages, using the screwdriver tip, and even peeling an actual orange. Meanwhile, I found the phillips capability of the nail file to be... just OK. Also, the nail file is also just OK. The blades and scissors are the usual Victorinox quality (which is to say they are awesome), but that mostly goes without saying.
Could I use the Executive as my EDC? Yes, I could. It covers a lot of bases for me, though I do wish it was better at phillips screws than it is. It comes close to being equivalent to my usual 2-layer 84mm/91mm plus Rambler EDC in one SAK. That, in and of itself, is very impressive.
That said, I think a larger SAK combined with a 58mm is still my preference for a few reasons. For one thing, as versatile as the Executive is, the combo is even more so with the ability to change up SAKs day by day with no difference in weight/carry profile. Another is the form factor - Personally, I prefer the 84mm/91mm form factor over and above any other size category. Also, I love the opener layer on the 84mm and 91mm SAKs.
The 74mm Executive is a little awkward in some ways. I did not find it to be any more capable than a 58mm SAK to any appreciable degree despite it being significantly bigger than a Classic SD or Rambler. Sure, the 74mm size disappears in the pocket. But so does an 84mm or 2-layer 91mm, at least to me. And the addition of the 58mm is basically "free" in the sense that I cannot tell a difference in weight (or anything) if I am carrying the 58mm or not. In other words, the Executive isn't "more pocketable" enough for me to make a permanent switch over my usual preference. At least, not in the same way that I find a 2-layer plus a 58mm SAK to be easier to carry over an Explorer or Deluxe Tinker, for example.
So, I like the Executive but not quite enough for it to become my new EDC. It's a great combination of tools though and it really makes me wish the Alumnus was still in production (or a Sportsman X or Cadet X) because that would be the closest tool set in the 84mm form factor.
As always, it's fun to do these challenges and really get to know SAKs that I'm not too familiar with. Not to mention seeing the uses everyone else gets out of them too. It's also a great way to get to know your own needs/wants better too because it forces you to really pay attention to what you're using a pocket knife for on a day to day basis.
I look forward to another challenge in a month or two (I don't like to do two in a row). In the meanwhile, I'll be going back to my beloved Recruit + Rambler, giving the Evolution 14 a real chance, and generally not being able to decide what my favorite SAKs are :ahhh
It's all of them!
-
Day 30 and no action for us. As always, thanks to everyone for a great challenge and to Nix for hosting it for us. Mine is going to ride along with me for awhile longer. I like how it fits in my hand and that small blade is a cutter!

-
Barry, what about the Poker Face Challenge?

-
@Farmer X said:
A thanks to everyone who participated, and to Nix for hosting. Special thanks to the unsung hero of the challenge, BPRoberts, who sent me a couple of Executives so I could participate!Happy to help out, Farmer. If you decide you want any of the others, drop me a PM.

I also want to thank Nix. It was fun to do a challenge with my "normal" carry. I also haven't gone keychain only in a while, so it was nice to scale back a little. I missed having a larger knife, but not too much. If I get a 2 SAK hand in the Poker Face challenge, the Exec will be right back on the keychain.
I don't really have a ton of reflection beyond what I put in my Day 0 post. The Executive adds quite a bit to the already capable Classic toolset, and has slowly supplanted the (deservedly) well loved Rambler as my favorite keychain SAK. While I did have to grab a larger SAK or Leatherman a few times this month, it was always for a dedicated project. For basic day to day use at the office, running errands, or bumming around the apartment the Exec passes with flying colors.
My wife borrowed the Executive today to help with a hangnail. She was a little doubtful at first, but I said try the scissors first and then the file if you need it. One snip got the job done. No pics, because while I think every inch of her is beautiful, you all probably don't want to see her feet.
Instead, enjoy the Exec taking a well earned bath in the sonic cleaner after a hard month's work. I think I'll have one too in the regular tub later tonight.
Final Quote: You concentrate on what you are doing, to do the best job you can, to stay out of a serious situation. That’s the way the X-1 was.

-
Day 30
I used the Executive to cut a couple zipties off my new ice cream scoop (Christmas present). Never too cold for ice cream

In closing, the Executive is one of the best size vs utility SAKs imho. I do wish it had a bottle opener, but it is not that big of an issue with so many other options. The orange peeler did prove to be more useful than expected as I experimented with using it on different tasks. That being said I still prefer the regular (84/91/93) SAKs.
-
@BPRoberts said:
Instead, enjoy the Exec taking a well earned bath in the sonic cleaner after a hard month's work. I think I'll have one too in the regular tub later tonight.:D Love those sonic cleaners. Wish they came in human size.....
-
DAY 30
Was out late with the boys last night so I haven’t been to bed yet :ahhh
Used the main blade to cut some plug tobacco for my pipe and the tip of the blade to cut some of me mates cigars. Scissors also snipped the tags off a new sweater.This challenge has left me even more confused than when I first started ha :D
After coming off the minichamp challenge last month I wanted to pit the executive against the minichamp. After about day 10 thought my mind was made up and that the minichamp had won the face off. However as I used the executive more and more I’ve really started to bond with it. Now I can’t say which one I like the best as each has its own things that it brings to the table.In doing this challenge i’m really seeing how the executive could be used as a lone EDC. Now I’m very curious to take just the executive into the wilderness on my trip next month just to see how it would fare and to maybe... just possibly, unlock more of the wisdom of the great Chuck Yeager


Thank you to Nix, awl of the challenge participants, and to awl who made this challenge happen

Have a great new year everybody!

-
Happy NYE awl and congratulations on completing the challenge

If you requested the badge it has now been approved

-
Thanks, Surge!

-
Day 31- and why not end 2022 on a high. Cut the tag of a new T shirt.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
