Sharpening a 58mm???
-
I've had my Rambler for years now. I've gotten so much use out of it that the blade is now pretty dull.
But I just can't seem to get this thing sharp! I've been trying, off and on for a couple of weeks now, to put a good edge back on this thing and I just can't seem to do it.
I have no problem sharpening the blade of a 84mm or 91mm SAK. But this 58mm blade just has me defeated and I'm not sure why. To the point that I've had serious thoughts about throwing it away and buying a new one - I realize that's silly but that's just how frustrated I am with this.
I may have ruined this blade - the beveled area of the blade is so small that it's hard to even see at this point. Especially compared to my almost-unused Classic SD or Minichamp blade.
I've tried the coffee cup method, the official Vic pen sharpener, a generic round ceramic rod, and a small Arkansas stone I got in Boy Scouts..... Does any one have any advice on how to sharpen this tiny blade? I would really appreciate any help or advice anyone can offer on this.
-
I like a 15 degree angle myself, so are you holding it so the back of the blade is nice and close to the stone while sharpening? Also, you need a real steady hand to freehand sharpen. If the angle you use varies even a bit while sharpening, you're just rounding off the edge. Keep it steady until you see no shiny spots when there'e a light above you, and you're looking down at the edge. Then move to a fine stone, do a few passes the same angle, Then, I like to extremely lightly do a pass on each side at a much higher angle to remove the wire edge (burr). Then I strop a bit.
The key to a knife that's sharp and cuts well is keep the angle constant, and with a decent angle. I don't at all like Victorinox's 20 degree angle. Doesn't cut wood worth a darn. 15 degrees, and it's a world of difference. To touch up my edges, I use a steel backwards to keep the edge straight.
I hope this makes sense and helps.
-
Yes, I am free hand sharpening. It’s never been a problem before with larger knives but this little one… it’s like there’s less margin for error because it’s so small.
I’m trying to be as consistent as possible but I have no real way to tell what my angle is, honestly.
-
Get a block of wood as thick as the blade is long.
Cut the block along its length, on a diagonal at the same angle you wish to sharpen the blade.
Then place the blade on the top of the block, edge-on to the diagonal, so the bevel (once properly ground) will sit at the same angle.
Now run your sharpening stone of choice along the edge (draw, sweep, whatever you prefer) to sharpen it.Hard to describe without drawing some janky pictures, but thankfully good old Felix shows the same method to sharpen the awl:
-
Thanks! I’m always game for a Felix SAK video.
I’m still not sure why this little blade is so hard to sharpen!
-
Get yourself a loupe or a magnifying glass so you can see what's going on with your bevel. I find that it doesn't take much to get off your angle when sharpening the smaller SAK's. With such a tiny blade, sometimes it's hard to tell just how it's oriented.
Also, I find I have better luck using coarser stones sharpening SAK steel.
-
Here’s an interesting picture.
[attach id=0 msg=2393364]
On the left is my Classic SD and the troublesome Rambler on the right. The shiny part on the Classic blade is the factory bevel. The Rambler basically has none.
How do I fix that? Do I need to fix it?

-
@marlowe221 said:
Here’s an interesting picture.[attach id=0 msg=2393364]
On the left is my Classic SD and the troublesome Rambler on the right. The shiny part on the Classic blade is the factory bevel. The Rambler basically has none.
How do I fix that? Do I need to fix it?
As nearly as I can tell from the pics, it looks like the edge on the Rambler is either rounded off, or sharpened at such a wide angle that it won’t cut well.
As previous posters have suggested, 15 degrees per side (30 degrees inclusive) seems to be the sweet spot for SAKs. (Vic recommends 15 - 20 degrees per side IIRC.)
It also looks like quite a bit of steel has been removed. I would guess the blade is still salvageable, although one thing that needs to be checked with folders is that edge and point still sit low enough in the handle when closed not to be dangerous.
I find that:
- A sharpmaker or similar can make it much easier to maintain a consistent angle than trying to do it freehand.
- Whether you end up getting your Rambler back to sharp or replacing it, going forward it is often easier to maintain a blade sharp by stropping it a bit regularly than it is to wait until the blade is really dull and then having to bring it back to sharp.
-
Yeah, I didn’t notice the difference in blade shape until I had them side by side.
My Rambler is a good 10+ years old and has seen a LOT of use. It might be worth sending to Victorinox and requesting a new blade.
You’re right about being more proactive about blade maintenance though. I’ve done that with other SAKs and had no issue keeping the blades on them sharp. The blade on this one was pretty well past that point before I learned that lesson, unfortunately.
I’m not sure what a sharpmaker is, but I’ll look into it!
-
Would convexing it be easier?
Typos courtesy of Samsung Auto-Incorrect™
-
@marlowe221 said:
I’m not sure what a sharpmaker is, but I’ll look into it!Spyderco Sharpmaker. There are now a number of other manufacturers offering similar products. Basically keeps a nice consistent angle for you, as long as you keep the blade vertical. The good ones come with two or three sets of stones of varying coarseness.
-
Well, I had some Amazon gift card money kicking around so now there’s a Spyderco Sharpmaker on its way to my house!
On closer examination of my Rambler, I’ve also noticed that the Phillips tip has gotten pretty worn down (I have noticed it slipping a few times lately) and the scissors are still working fine but they are pretty dull too.
I guess I’ve got my money’s worth out of it! :D
-
@marlowe221 said:
Well, I had some Amazon gift card money kicking around so now there’s a Spyderco Sharpmaker on its way to my house!On closer examination of my Rambler, I’ve also noticed that the Phillips tip has gotten pretty worn down (I have noticed it slipping a few times lately) and the scissors are still working fine but they are pretty dull too.
I guess I’ve got my money’s worth out of it! :D
Big fan here, am glad to see a Sharpmaker is on its way to you, personally, it is perfect for all things SAK/MT, and my most of my knives. Having said that, the original two sets of rods are best for light touch-up. For heavier sharpening, reprofiling or restoration, I would really recommend the Sharpmaker CBN rods.
-
@comis said:
For heavier sharpening, reprofiling or restoration, I would really recommend the Sharpmaker CBN rods.Thank you, comis...you've reminded me that I still need to get hold of some coarse rods for my Turnbox.
If the roughest medium obtainable doesn't help that blade, the best bet is likely sending it to Victorinox for service. Under absolutely no circumstances would I take it to a grinder...but that's just me.
-
@comis said:
Big fan here, am glad to see a Sharpmaker is on its way to you, personally, it is perfect for all things SAK/MT, and my most of my knives. Having said that, the original two sets of rods are best for light touch-up. For heavier sharpening, reprofiling or restoration, I would really recommend the Sharpmaker CBN rods.Good to know! I’ll have to pick up a set of those at some point in the near future.
@Farmer X said:
Thank you, comis...you've reminded me that I still need to get hold of some coarse rods for my Turnbox.If the roughest medium obtainable doesn't help that blade, the best bet is likely sending it to Victorinox for service. Under absolutely no circumstances would I take it to a grinder...but that's just me.
Yeah, I’m leaning towards sending it in. Especially since the Phillips has become worn over time and the scissors could use a look too… That said, I wonder what that will cost me from Victorinox versus buying a replacement Rambler? It’s not like I still have the receipt!
-
@marlowe221 said:
I’m still not sure why this little blade is so hard to sharpen!With a deeper blade, lifting the spine off the stone to 15º or 20º means the back moves quite a long way, whereas creating the same angle on a narrow blade like the 58mm takes only a small movement. This then means any small change in that spine height off the stone results in a big difference down at the bevel. It requires greater precision.
This is why I suggested the wooden cheek method as, aside from being dirt cheap and easy to make, it holds the blade in place while you just move the sharpening stone.
It can also work for other blades, sch as scissors or woodworking tools. -
@Farmer X said:
If the roughest medium obtainable doesn't help that blade, the best bet is likely sending it to Victorinox for service. Under absolutely no circumstances would I take it to a grinder...but that's just me.I definitely wouldn’t put it on a grinder either. But the CBN (as suggested by comis) or diamond stones will remove metal fast.
-
@marlowe221 said:
On closer examination of my Rambler, I’ve also noticed that the Phillips tip has gotten pretty worn down (I have noticed it slipping a few times lately) and the scissors are still working fine but they are pretty dull too.I guess I’ve got my money’s worth out of it! :D
The scissors can be sharpened too. It has to be done in a particular way though or they can be ruined. Again Felix comes to the rescue with video instructions.
-
@marlowe221 said:
I wonder what that will cost me from Victorinox versus buying a replacement Rambler?You'll pay shipping both ways. I've only used their warranty/repair service one time, but I wasn't charged for work done to one that was obviously abused. I'd imagine that since your Rambler is just used, you'd likely be out just the shipping costs. (Sending more than one in can help ease the costs for the trip to Victorinox.)
-
@marlowe221 said:
Here’s an interesting picture.[attach id=0 msg=2393364]
On the left is my Classic SD and the troublesome Rambler on the right. The shiny part on the Classic blade is the factory bevel. The Rambler basically has none.
How do I fix that? Do I need to fix it?
You're definitely not holding the blade at enough of an angle towards your sharpener, as others have noted. I saw someone illustrate how low it should go by placing a pair of coins just under the spine of the blade. I can't recall the coin, but you get the idea - it's pretty low.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login