Leatherman Garage 4
-
@McStitchy said:
Aloha !I did not like Mr.Crunch as it is build onto the Free platform. Somehow I think that doesn't fit together.
The only thing that makes me want a Dark Side Charge is the screwed pliers. They should make that a standard.
The exchangeable blades do not look very practical and sturdy.
And now we have this scout knife.
Oh... and wasn't there a problem with the warranty?
Sorry if this comes off like a rant

The darkside was a way to cash in on the tom sachs charge. it was essentially the extra tools stolen from that limited edition puked out again with goofy g10 scales. What is crazy is all the broken carbide scratchers. Carbide is hard but brittle. the scribe should have been made out of 420 with a carbide tip insert, rather than all carbide.
I got in an argument on reddit with someone that thought, if only leatherman would release the Mr Crunch as a regular tool. LOL with the fiddly plier caps it would end up spending more time in service than in anyone's pocket.
-
@SteveC said:
I decided to cancel my order. When I spoke to the women on the phone she said that they are holding orders 5-7 days until they are reviewed by there team for eligibility.I wonder how many tools that are listed on eBay will end up getting cancelled by Leatherman

if only it was all of them.
actually I don't care about the speculators, i'm hearing they got plenty burnt on the Parts release. Guy on reddit can't get rid of his for even $120
If they would have led with parts no one would have paid attention to mr crunch or darkside.
The ideas seem to get weaker and weaker as it goes along.For an ideas group Garage seems to be pretty lacking.
-
anyone else wish we could give the garage ideas?
Like i would love a charge surge mashup with a spot in the scales to store a saw or file in addition to the one installed.
a pin in the replaceable cutters so they don't rotate when you grip on something larger.
a firestarter with a blade angle guide built in so you could take the t shank diamond file and sharpen your knife.if they gave a tool to people who made suggestions, they would have enough for a lifetime of garage projects and perhaps even a few tools.
@legend any chance you could suggest this? I am sure the garage team underwhelmed with the cheers they are getting over tool 4
-
I can only go by the fella from LM who came here specifically to tell us to go to reddit to talk to them.

They seem to know what they are doing
. To say he/they seemed uninterested would be a understatement. I am underwhelmed by what I took as their mission statement. I have been known to get it totally wrong so I may have misunderstood LM Garage purpose. If its solely about creating excitement/sales for limited edition tools then
. I can get behind that. Goodness knows I enjoy being 1 of XXX owner of something neat."The Garage puts innovation first, pushing the limits of design, engineering, and even ourselves."
-
I feel like people would like the garage more if they used it as a test bed/preview for new ideas. Charge people a premium to get "collector" models early, use the feedback to find out if it's a viable idea, bring the good ones to full market (maybe with some tweaks) 6 months or a year later.
People loved Mr. Crunch. It came out almost a year ago. Why can't I get a Free P4 with convertible pliers yet? Even if they basically just made the same tool, people who bought the garage model would still have had it a year in advance, and collectors would probably pay enough (even with production models on the horizon) for people to resell them for a profit if they didn't want them anymore.
Darkside was a cool new aesthetic. If nothing else, why can't we buy Darkside Surges or something? It was also another toe in the "scale slot" style tools after the tweezers on some of the Free knives. I really like having a pen on my multitool, that'd be a great feature to add to the next generation of mainline tools.
Parts was a disaster. It happens. Take the L and accept it as part of being the "experimental" line. They still probably made money with the garage premium.
Europe75 is... something? As a mostly SAK guy, I'd love to see another company (especially a US based one) take on Vic for the knife based multitool market. If we get a Free K6 (not sure how the numbering works...) with a similar load out (fix the stupid driver awl) I'd probably buy one.
The issue is that they're these flash in the pan sometimes good, sometimes not, ideas that get scalped to hell and then we never hear about them again.
-
Quick edit: I was typing and posted while BPRoberts replied and looks like we share some thoughts.
I don’t know if I would agree that the garage mission statement is being realized. I don’t see any “pushing themselves” with 003 and 004. Mr crunch pliers are neat and that probably took a bit to get right, but putting it on a Free frame with most the same tools felt lazy to me. I liked the added features to the Tom Sachs charge, but again for the dark side garage adding to the existing charge platform didn’t feel that innovative. I would however like to see it as a production model.
In my opinion, I think innovative would be taking ideas from the mod community. Give me a wave or Free with blade exchanger, outside access scissors, a spirit like chisel, SOG like wire strippers, etc. limited release to test the waters maybe even with premium materials. Follow the garage innovation with production releases later using what is feasible based on machining and cost and all that.
I think maybe I’m just more disappointed than I thought i would be. I bought a wave+ as my first quality pliers based MT because I thought out of every option available it was innovative and well rounded. It was either that or a surge, or a Swisstool. I thought we were going to see an evolution from the free or wave series.
C’mon ARC be real…
-
I agree. The Waves modded here on MTO with Blade Exchanger and Vic Scissor seem more innovative. I'd love to see them do something with the JUICE. That size MT with much better inner tools would be terrific. Heck the LEAP would be a great IMO platform with the removable blade. Some tweaks would make it one heck of a brilliant tool.
They need to fit the blade exchanger on the Wave/Charge frame. Much of what they've done is cobbled tools using left overs.
Exactly what is INNOVATIVE? I really don't understand design/engineering but I am not seeing any pushing
.The backsprings on the Juice need re-engineering. Its a weak point. The small drivers are not good. To me the Juice was a direct threat to the SAK but it failed. It would seem the JUICE could have been what Tim needed vs his pocket knife.
Today I am carrying mine but it has a broken spring. Its usable but I do worry once it becomes unusable then what?
**"The Garage puts innovation first, pushing the limits of design, engineering, and even ourselves." **
We know they can do much more. We have the Crunch for goodness sake. That is a wonderfully engineered tool.
-
@SteveC said:
I decided to cancel my order. When I spoke to the women on the phone she said that they are holding orders 5-7 days until they are reviewed by there team for eligibility.I wonder how many tools that are listed on eBay will end up getting cancelled by Leatherman

well that is going to screw some people selling on ebay no matter what. the sales are 7 days and ship in 2. they'll never get them in time to ship
-
@Aloha said:
Today I am carrying mine but it has a broken spring. Its usable but I do worry once it becomes unusable then what?you know you can replace the springs fairly easily without having to drill rivets, right?
https://youtu.be/PgxObO4qoXksome springs here or find a trashed one on ebay and use it for parts
https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2380057.m570.l1313&_nkw=leatherman+juice+springs&_sacat=0 -
Yes. I have a "couple" spares and I should pickup a busted on for sure. -
@Aloha said:
I can only go by the fella from LM who came here specifically to tell us to go to reddit to talk to them.
Honestly, I wouldn't want to post here if I were them either. We're not really the most pro-Leatherman group. :ahhh At Reddit, they can reach far more Leatherman fans , and they even have more control over content there.
-
Well, another uninteresting rehash of an existing tool. I guess the Europe part of this is... that it has a corkscrew? OHO locking blade won't go over great legally with some of those European countries, they could have at least used this to test out more legal-friendly blades. Free series? double detent knife but with magnets sounds cool and low-hanging fruit, but alas.
-
@Rich_SD said:
Honestly, I wouldn't want to post here if I were them either. We're not really the most pro-Leatherman group. :ahhh At Reddit, they can reach far more Leatherman fans , and they even have more control over content there.A Lot of that is their own fault for dismissing MTO for so many years though
I don't bash LM but I do find it stupid that they haven't ever really tried to make an active presence here
they have had almost 17 years to do so (most all the brands in fact) 
-
Whilst I don't think most brands would really care enough to make a presence here, I think Leatherman in particular should have made the effort. Not only is it a good way to get meaningful feedback, but from a business standpoint it's like wading into the whale pool.
Though I don't get a brand choosing favourites with social media participation, if you're going to be on a trashfire like /r you may as well be on speSmurfpillst boards.
-
I am interested to see these in the hands of our members. Let us see the pictures and tell us what you think.

-

Garage batches 002 or 003 didn't strike me as anything innovative or groundbreaking. Neither does 004; to me, it looks like..
@GearedForwards said:
Another uninteresting rehash of an existing tool.I thought the Garage was supposed to be all about innovation. Yet I certainly can't think of any functions that could be added to a multi that would be of great use for great numbers of users.
However, they absolutely should focus on being evolutionary rather than revolutionary. I'd love to see an improved Juice, with better springs and Micarta scales (if they could get Micarta thin enough). While I'm dreaming, why not have multiple scale options that could be easily changed by the user?
At least the price of batch 004 isn't horrible.
-
I saw someone post on Facebook that they have their new tool in hand
-
I saw a couple people but none of the ones I saw are US based
maybe they are holding on to the US orders for the week but nowhere else :D -
Any links? First impressions? I am mostly wondering about the construction of the corkscrew lever because lots of folks said it was 3D printed by Leatherman.
-
Just saw pics, nothing said about the tool other than it was in their possession

If I hear anything else I will let you all know

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login