Huge Discontinuation
-
@MacGyver said:
It would made way more sense to me to discontinue the Spartan and Tinker than the 84mm counterparts.
In these times, when it comes to knives, <u>smaller is better.</u> The same is true for EDC pocket carry, especially Urban/Suburban, 91mm is just too bloody big with no justification for it.
Why would i want a 91mm SAK when i can have a similar smaller 84mm version of it?Very much agree!
-
Good point on the size - From a legal carry perspective
- Although the legal carry length in the UK (for example) does seem to be set at the 91mm blade length.
Also, even though it is only another 7mm - It is surprising how much more pocketable the 84s are compared to the 91s
-
I am trying to stave off a flurry of 84/85mm purchases but this thread is not helping. I agree with MacGyver as well. 91 is better to use for me, but 84 is so much more comfortable in the pocket. I think a lot of people only ever see the 91mm size so they don’t realize what the 84s have to offer.
I keep thinking what if I need some 84mm woodsaws later? or more Wenger style scissors?

-
Personally, I would prefer that Victorinox stick with the 91mm line as their main line. I don’t find my 91mm SAKs to be less pocketable than my 84mm SAKs. Also, remember that a longer blade can be shortened fairly easily to comply with local laws restricting blade length.
That being said, I don’t want to see so many models discontinued.
-
@MacGyver said:
I really completely disagree with them on that one. It would made way more sense to me to discontinue the Spartan and Tinker than the 84mm counterparts.
In these times, when it comes to knives, <u>smaller is better.</u> The same is true for EDC pocket carry, especially Urban/Suburban, 91mm is just too bloody big with no justification for it.
Why would i want a 91mm SAK when i can have a similar smaller 84mm version of it? If they give people no other option that to buy those models in 84mm, people will buy them.
They seam obsessed with the bloody 91mm line, when they should be cutting down some models from it, while adding more options to the 84mm line.That's just MY opinion anyhow...
Personally, I agree with you. I prefer 84mm for the 2-layer models and would rather they keep the Tourist/Tinker Small and stop making the 91mm models (shoot, rename the 84mm if it helps the general public...).
But for whatever reason, the 91mm line seems to sell better/more from what I can tell - the Hunstman, Spartan, Tinker, and Climber are often listed as the bestselling models after the Classic SD, though I won't claim to have seen any sales numbers to back that up. So when I said that I could understand that decision, I was trying to put my self in Victorinox's shoes to a degree.
If it's true that the 91mm models are the better sellers, I can see Victorinox moving to trim down the product line in favor of the 91mm SAKs, no matter how much I personally wish they were doing the opposite.
-
91mm line seems to have always been their focus. I too prefer 84mm and Wengers 85mm.
I'm still trying to wrap my head around the Manager not making the cut.
@z1913 said:
The end of 85mm sounds to me like the final stage of protracted Wenger bankruptcy. At the end it might be a good thing - remove what is not working anymore, focus on new stuff.Its also interesting 85mm is likely a goner. Is there anything left of the buyout? Wondering what the purpose was?
-
@Aloha said:
Its also interesting 85mm is likely a goner. Is there anything left of the buyout? Wondering what the purpose was?I think with the buyout, Vic was hoping to:
-
Keep the old Wenger factory going, albeit with a reduced lineup, Vic branding, and with some Vic components. However, I suspect they weren’t able to make this profitable, and this economic reality is catching up.
-
Prevent Wenger’s IP from being sold off to the highest bidder, and subsequently “Wenger” knives being cheaply manufactured in China, which would have probably had a negative impact on the reputation of SAKs in general. In this, at least, Vic was successful.
-
-
@Aloha - It sounds like the 130mm line will be staying - And rightly so - Awesome models
Really did not make much sense to have the 85 and 84mm lines - But why not (shock horror) discontinue the 84mm models and keep (maybe with some revision) the 95mm family.
EDIT: PS I meant the 85mm family
-
@Huntsman said:
Good point on the size - From a legal carry perspective- Although the legal carry length in the UK (for example) does seem to be set at the 91mm blade length.
Also, even though it is only another 7mm - It is surprising how much more pocketable the 84s are compared to the 91s
UK "legal" carry is 7.62cm so the 93mm is do-able without needing a reasonable excuse etc ::)
That said, I love my Cadet (Alox) and my ideal EDC would be a Cadet X (or FX :ahhh)
But I am poor :( -
Money Clip is no longer available through the Webshop in the EU (maybe worldwide,too).
2 weeks before there was a waiting list.
-
I’m surprised of some of the models they chose to discontinue.
-
regarding the money clip, just on the European amazon sites: https://www.hagglezon.com/en/s/victorinox money clip
-
Please does anyone have the full (confirmed, indisputable) list of discontinued models? ???
I am sure I saw it somewhere - It might have been on Facebook :o
Thinking of what updates we need to make to the Wiki !! -
Haven’t been around for a while
Typical, I log in a see Victorinox may be pulling the 85mm models.
As someone who specifically collected the original Wenger 85’s and 130’s
I own none of the Vic clones. Just checked prices on Amazon….EEK !! cheap they ain’t !!Not sure whether to dive in and begin again (groans) or just let them slip quietly away knowing I have the originals already :D
Decisions Decisions

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login