Multi-Tool Oil question
-
Greetings, gents.
Some of you may remember that when the war started in Ukraine we moved to the western part. At some point I realized that I don’t have any tool oil with me despite having to rely on my trusty Work Champ on a daily basis. One day I got it clogged with dust or whatever and had to look for a Victorinox Multi-Tool Oli to make it right. Found and ordered it here - seemed normal, but at some point I realized that after oiling my Work Champ and especially my Spirit that specific oil made the friction way worse than it was and than it should be.
Here’s what it looks like:
Spoiler:





Seems perfect fine and legit - looks just like my other oils in a same large bottle I have at home.
Later I had a few chances to go back home and brought an old small bottle of Victorinox Multi-Tool Oil that looks more yellowish than the more of a whiteish looking large one.

I decided to wash my tools with soap to remove that new oil and then lubed the tools with old one - pure magic 🪄 Works as it should - nice and smooth.
So I’m wondering whether I have a some kind of a counterfeit oil or there is something wrong with a newer lighter oil in large bottles? Has anyone noticed anything similar?
-
I don't use Vic's oil. Never have, one any of the knives I've own. I found "3 in 1" oil or any machine oil (like sewing machine, etc) works just fine. Use it as a lub and to protect in carbon bladed knives also. Fancy brand name oils are just making money for the seller.
-
I have a victorinox oil (the "new one") but I don't like it because I find it too dense.
For me olive oil (extra virgin) works perfect. I apply it with a toothpick in the friction parts and for me is the one that works.
Enviat des del meu Pixel 3a usant Tapatalk
-
Mineral oil is readily available, dirt cheap, food safe, tasteless/odorless, doesn't spoil, and works well. Been using it for years with great results. The Vic proprietary oil is probably mineral based.
Plant based oils (olive) run the risk of going rancid. Most 3 in 1 styles aren't food safe. Most oils are heavier, and more likely to turn into "gunk" over time. Even if it wasn't one of the cheapest options, it'd still be one of the best performers.
-

I find that the manufacturer's factory oils (Vic, LM, Gerber) seem thicker than the big cheap bottle of mineral oil from the drug store that should last me (and my heirs) for life. -
@BPRoberts said:
Mineral oil is readily available, dirt cheap, food safe, tasteless/odorless, doesn't spoil, and works well. Been using it for years with great results.My choice as well.

-
Great ideas, gents [emoji1317] though I’m mainly surprised by the difference between the two versions of what should have been exactly the same product [emoji38] is it just me or anyone else had totally different results with Vic oil at some point? Because again - those bottles should be the same, but they are totally different from the performance standpoint
-
@in_sympathy said:
Because again - those bottles should be the same, but they are totally different from the performance standpointIt depends what's happened to the bottle before it reaches you.
NSF H1 is a food-safe certified standard of mineral oil.
Mineral oil should be stored somewhere away from heat and out of sunlight, to avoid contamination or degredation. So if it's been sat on a sunny shop shelf, for example, that could affect it... even to the point where it goes rancid. -
@BPRoberts said:
Mineral oil is readily available, dirt cheap, food safe, tasteless/odorless, doesn't spoil, and works well. Been using it for years with great results. The Vic proprietary oil is probably mineral based.Plant based oils (olive) run the risk of going rancid. Most 3 in 1 styles aren't food safe. Most oils are heavier, and more likely to turn into "gunk" over time. Even if it wasn't one of the cheapest options, it'd still be one of the best performers.
I do the same thing. Mineral oil works great, it's cheap, and it's safe to use my SAK to cut one of my kids' sandwich into whatever shape they are currently demanding!
-
I use mineral oil for my SAKs as well. Sometimes it does seem to make the friction worse, but I think that’s because it loosens gunk that then gets stuck again when the tools are opened. That’s my working theory at the moment, anyway.
-
I tried applying that “bad” oil a few times on different SAKs - it’s surely not because of gunk, it really somehow made a friction worse. I applied, washed, tried again - same results.
And everything is perfectly fine with another bottle on the first try.
To give you a better idea of that friction level - scissors literally get stuck on my Spirit every time I oil them with this “bad” one
-
I am thinking you either got an adulterated oil (eg accidental contamination or counterfeit) or it turned rancid (either expired or subject to high heat). Though I don’t know if rancid oil will do that.
I would just try to return it or count your blessings you didn’t buy a pack. Really sorry to hear about this.
-
Like the previous post.
I am thinking you either got an adulterated oil (eg accidental contamination or counterfeit) or it turned rancid (either expired or subject to high heat). Though I don’t know if rancid oil will do that.I would just try to return it or count your blessings you didn’t buy a pack. Really sorry to hear about this.
[/quote] -
@Old Boy said:
Like the previous post.
I am thinking you either got an adulterated oil (eg accidental contamination or counterfeit) or it turned rancid (either expired or subject to high heat). Though I don’t know if rancid oil will do that.I would just try to return it or count your blessings you didn’t buy a pack. Really sorry to hear about this.
Yep, I guess that’s the case. Luckily I only bought one, so no big deal, yet still it’s a pretty unexpected discovery [emoji23]
-
@Old Boy said:
I am thinking you either got an adulterated oil (eg accidental contamination or counterfeit) or it turned rancid (either expired or subject to high heat). Though I don’t know if rancid oil will do that.I would just try to return it or count your blessings you didn’t buy a pack. Really sorry to hear about this.
+1
Maybe it's passed the expiration date?
I use japanese camellia oil. Not cheap, but it works extremely well and is food safe.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login