*** The Dean 51 Traditional Challenge 2023 ***
-
- SteveC
- Barry Rowland
- LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
- NutSAK (Case badge)
- nate j - GEC badge
- Adam5 - Case badge
- Sos24 - Case badge
- MTSAK - Case Badge
- comis - Case Badge
- David
-
- SteveC
- Barry Rowland
- LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
- NutSAK (Case badge)
- nate j - GEC badge
- Adam5 - Case badge
- Sos24 - Case badge
- MTSAK - Case Badge
- comis - Case Badge
- David
- GA1dad - Case Badge
-
- SteveC
- Barry Rowland
- LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
- NutSAK (Case badge)
- nate j - GEC badge
- Adam5 - Case badge
- Sos24 - Case badge
- MTSAK - Case Badge
- comis - Case Badge
- David
- GA1dad - Case Badge
- Alan K. - Case Badge
-
Now we're cooking with gas

-
I thought about joining in for the Case badge, but I've decided against it. Challenges work best for me when I have a decent assortment of the challenge gear (ability to do 30 in 30 is ideal), especially when that gear is a knife. I don't think I'm quite there with Case, and it's been a long while since I've added a new trad. So while I won't be joining in this time around, I'll most assuredly check in.
-
- SteveC
- Barry Rowland
- LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
- NutSAK (Case badge)
- nate j - GEC badge
- Adam5 - Case badge
- Sos24 - Case badge
- MTSAK - Case Badge
- comis - Case Badge
- David
- GA1dad - Case Badge
- Alan K. - Case Badge
- Gareth - Case Badge
Lucky number 13 for me. :D
-
@Farmer X said:
I thought about joining in for the Case badge, but I've decided against it. Challenges work best for me when I have a decent assortment of the challenge gear (ability to do 30 in 30 is ideal), especially when that gear is a knife. I don't think I'm quite there with Case, and it's been a long while since I've added a new trad. So while I won't be joining in this time around, I'll most assuredly check in.Sorry to hear that Dan but there is plenty of time for you to change your mind

-
Sorry to learn your decision Dan🥲
Last year GA1dad did the MEMORIAL with the GEC Bull nose(?), a sod buster style. Found a use for it every day. I thought that was so cool.
Remember it is not about the tool, it is LUV of the knife, sharing your respect to your SHARP finger extension and remembering a member that shared his knowledge and his respect by sharing everyday…
We awl have a story, 1 or 100, we still have are favorites, some pretty, some not, BUT awl are sharp🤪
-
@Farmer X said:
I thought about joining in for the Case badge, but I've decided against it. Challenges work best for me when I have a decent assortment of the challenge gear (ability to do 30 in 30 is ideal), especially when that gear is a knife. I don't think I'm quite there with Case, and it's been a long while since I've added a new trad. So while I won't be joining in this time around, I'll most assuredly check in.I totally get it, and that's why I've not done the GEC one, as I only have about 5 to choose from. They are 5 really good ones though!
It is nice to keep it fresh and interesting. I have about 10 Cases, so I'm gonna give 'er a go. -
Looks like we have nine going for the Case badge. Ten participants are needed for a badge.
I'll count up the Cases and see if I might maybe have enough to make a run at it. -
@Farmer X said:
Looks like we have nine going for the Case badge. Ten participants are needed for a badge.
I'll count up the Cases and see if I might maybe have enough to make a run at it.
My original plan for the Tween Challenge was to use four tools,,,, one for each week of the challenge. It didn't work out that way though. Other than a couple of cameo appearances, I have stayed with the same Cadet. -
There is no rule saying you can't carry more than one traditional during the challenge. A few of us carry two or more daily :D
You can carry a Case and a GEC, for instance. Or any other brand, but you only get one badge
-
While there is certainly an exciting element about having enough knives that meet challenge criteria to do “30 knives in 30 days” or something close to that, some of my most memorable challenges have been those in which I used a single knife or just a few knives for the entire 30 days.
Sometimes this was because I only owned one or a few knives that met the challenge criteria. Other times, it was because I would be traveling for a significant portion of the challenge timeframe, and bringing more than a couple of knives along wasn’t practical.
Carrying just one knife for a longer period of time gives the opportunity for developing a much more in-depth feel for the knife, its capabilities, strengths, and weaknesses. It’s simultaneously limiting and freeing, in the same way as having to wear a uniform to work. You don’t have a lot of options, but you surely don’t spend much time or energy deciding what to wear/carry each day.
For this upcoming challenge, I own a handful of GEC models but am only seriously considering two of them. The Pony Jack is a sweet knife, I appreciate having two knife blades, and I prefer the main clip to a main spear. It also gets into my pocket pretty regularly on WHW. I don’t carry the Johnny on the Spot regularly, but feel the additional non-knife tools might come in handy for the challenge, and would give the edge in durability to its delrin scales vs. the PJ’s wood scales.

-
For that matter, there are one or two traditional knives I've carried for consecutive months outside of any challenge, simply because they're useful knives, so I could certainly just do one in particular for 30 days.
But where's the fun in that? :D
-
- SteveC
- Barry Rowland
- LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
- NutSAK (Case badge)
- nate j - GEC badge
- Adam5 - Case badge
- Sos24 - Case badge
- MTSAK - Case Badge
- comis - Case Badge
- David
- GA1dad - Case Badge
- Alan K. - Case Badge
- Gareth - Case Badge
- BPRoberts - Case Badge
And that's 10 for the Case badge!
-
- SteveC
- Barry Rowland
- LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
- NutSAK (Case badge)
- nate j - GEC badge
- Adam5 - Case badge
- Sos24 - Case badge
- MTSAK - Case Badge
- comis - Case Badge
- David
- GA1dad - Case Badge
- Alan K. - Case Badge
- Gareth - Case Badge
- BPRoberts - Case Badge
- HarleyXJGuy - Case Badge
Super excited for this one.
Been carrying a Tinker Small all month for the Tween Challenge but furiously preparing for this one.

-
A couple of things have been weighing on me pretty heavy lately.
1- I sure have been to the doctor a lot lately. Seems like I could benefit a lot from just getting outdoors and moving more.
2- For somebody that loves fishing as much as I do,,,, I sure don't do it much.
So,,, for this challenge I am vowing to make at least 10 of my Dean51 posts centered around fishing,,,, or just getting outdoors. If anyone would like to join me, you are most certainly welcomed.
-
I don't know how much fishing I'll do, but I'll try to join you in some more outdoor shots. It is camping season! I hope you feel better.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login