Australian Knife Laws
-
Its a shame any SAK could be seen as a weapon. I am truly at a loss when it comes to such views. We are as much enthusiast as we are users of these tools. I cannot begin to think if such laws were enacted in my area what I'd feel tho I'm sure I'd be pretty upset.
Before joining MTO I was unaware of anyones restrictions when it came to sharps. I only focused on the legality of what I carried in my city. A decade later and now knowing a little more about what many of y'all have to contend with I feel for you. I am frustrated for you. I don't pack my pockets and think "oh well".
Before we begin to stray into areas of conversations that are better suited elsewhere lets please keep it as general as possible. Trust me, I am dumbfounded when such laws are passed anywhere. The laws and lawmakers are topics too highly charged that can lead to chat that is best elsewhere.
Thank you to those who have posted thus far for be the amazing MTO members you are. I just wanted to set a reminder for anyone who might want to post.
-
@Valkie said:
And it's even illegal to fight back.
My old boss was attacked, silly two attackers.
He beat one insensible in two punches, the second, he broke his leg.
When the cops arrived,he was arrested and the muggers taken to hospital.In court, even the video footage from the shop front showed he was attacked.
But he was charged with "using undue force to protect himself"An old guy ( in his 80s) and his wife were attacked, in their own home, by a couple of criminals.
He shot and killed one.
He was arrested and charged with murder.
Only the public outcry stopped it from going through and he got off on a manslaughter charge.In Australia, it's tge criminals 2ho are protected and the victims ignored.
I b3lieve it's because all of our politicians are criminals and they don't want to set a precedent.Here in the US, this seems to be highly dependent upon locality/jurisdiction. Some areas have strong laws designed to protect the right to self-defense. Other areas are every bit as backwards as you describe, and anyone who dares stand up for themselves faces a costly legal battle, at best.
-
@Aloha said:
Its a shame any SAK could be seen as a weapon. I am truly at a loss when it comes to such views.On one hand, I agree. Perhaps I simply lack the covert ninja black ops training to appreciate how lethal a Vic Spartan or Case Stockman can be, but I find non-locking folders in particular ill-suited for use as weapons, to the point that in most scenarios I would probably try to defend myself bare-handed before I would attempt to get a non-locking folder into action. I think a big part of the problem is that the people who write these laws have precious little knowledge of knives, and even less understanding of the dynamics of contact distance violence.
On the other hand, I find it delightfully ironic that much of the legal progress that has been made against some of the most draconian knife laws in the US recently has occurred precisely because attorneys have argued that knives are “Arms” under the meaning of the 2nd Amendment.
-
As a final note on this topic, Frome me anyway.
I am a law abiding person (for the most part)
never been arrested, never been charged with anything other than a speeding fine or two.
The only people I have hurt have either been in the ring with me or simply deserved it for starting it and not giving me an out.
I prefer to back off and apologize rather than fight, simply because I know how much damage I can do, and I have fought in the ring, so its not fear.I would not consider ANY multitool as a possible weapon, other than as a but of weight in my hand (like a roll of coins)
And the shape of a multitool does not lend itself to that sort of eventuality as it not nice and round.
Additionally, the knives themselves are not designed for weaponry, yes its sharp and pointy, but as a weapon not real good.I practiced knife and hand to hand fighting in my martial arts training.
The knives we used for fighting were karambits (not sure of the spelling, lets just say hook knives).
These are well designed to do maximum damage with the least effort, not a stabbing weapon as much as a slicing and dicing weapon designed to open up the attacker.
PS they were rubber training knives.
I was never any good with swords, Nunchucks or SAI, I was more a danger to myself.I try to avoid trouble, and willingly back down rather than fight.
I'm too old to run away, but I can walk, but refuse to tire myself just in case I need my energy for other actions.
But and I say this with all sincerity.
There is no way on Gods earth would I even consider pulling out a flimsy and less than ergonomically designed multitool to fight someone (anyone).
If the situation required me to defend myself from someone in earnest, it would be my cane or, time permitting, grabbing one of my Kerambits from my display cabinet.
Which is highly unlikely.This fixation that grubberments around the world have about pocketknives is truly disturbing.
Guns, I understand.
Machete and swords, likewise.
But a tool used in 99.9 out of 100 cases as nothing more than a tool, is asinine rubbish, perpetrated by a witless knumbskull seat polishing public servant with a fear of everything normal..
I would hazard that more people have been deliberately killed with a car, a screwdriver or even a hammer than have been killed with a pocketknife.Are they going to ban cars? what about hammers?.
I will continue to carry my tools at work or when volunteering.
I will continue to carry my tools when bush walking, camping or boating.
But I will aquiesse to the draconian and pointless rules and mandates of the less than cerebrally gifted grubberment at other times.Its sad for an old boy scout to finally hang up his knife.
But such is life in this day and age.I guess the grubberment will continue to enforce knife rules just like they did to the 95 year old retiree in Australia recently.
They tazered her to death because she was carrying a butter knife and the cops decided that tazers were a better option than talking. (But she was holding a knife)
Perhaps tazers should be only given to competent people. -
@Valkie said:
This fixation that grubberments around the world have about pocketknives is truly disturbing.
Guns, I understand.
Machete and swords, likewise.
But a tool used in 99.9 out of 100 cases as nothing more than a tool, is asinine rubbish, perpetrated by a witless knumbskull seat polishing public servant with a fear of everything normal..
I would hazard that more people have been deliberately killed with a car, a screwdriver or even a hammer than have been killed with a pocketknife.I mostly agree with your overall sentiment, but with this section you lose me. It's what ends up being the problem....you like pocket knives and multitools but nothing else so you're ok with applying the government rationale you decry to those things that you don't care about, such as guns and other "weapons". The vast majority of people with legal guns don't abuse them either. Punish and regulate behavior, not the objects themselves or harmless legal behavior with said objects.
-
This topic has been going very well, guys

Let's keep it steered in the right direction

-
@Valkie said:
Its even illegal to carry a replica gun and wearing a bullet proof vest is a huge NO NO.Realistic replica guns can still be used effectively to carry out an armed robbery, which is why the UK banned such things... but why on Earth is wearing a bullet-proof vest illegal??!!
Aside from making you look like a bell-end, it doesn't impact anyone in the slightest.... -
We can go round and round trying to figure our such things. We don't care to discuss such matters here tho. Such topics can be and usually are divisive.
-
@ThisAlarm7 said:
Punish and regulate behavior, not the objects themselves or harmless legal behavior with said objects.Well said!
-
@Tasky said:
why on Earth is wearing a bullet-proof vest illegal??!!While I personally believe civilians should be free to purchase and wear body armor if desired, I think the argument in favor of these laws boils down to the fact that bad guys wearing body armor are harder for good guys to kill than bad guys not wearing body armor.
-
@ThisAlarm7 said:
I mostly agree with your overall sentiment, but with this section you lose me. It's what ends up being the problem....you like pocket knives and multitools but nothing else so you're ok with applying the government rationale you decry to those things that you don't care about, such as guns and other "weapons". The vast majority of people with legal guns don't abuse them either. Punish and regulate behavior, not the objects themselves or harmless legal behavior with said objects.It's probably the continual and ongoing indoctrination and grubberment propaganda that makes my uncomfortable with guns.
But as you say, "It ain't the tool, it's the fool weikding it"Sorry if I have offended, it's unintentional.
-
@nate j said:
While I personally believe civilians should be free to purchase and wear body armor if desired, I think the argument in favor of these laws boils down to the fact that bad guys wearing body armor are harder for good guys to kill than bad guys not wearing body armor.The way it was explained to me is.
You only wear body armorial if you intend to commit a crime.
That's why John Howard the coward wore it when addressing the gun lobby.
He was a corrupt, horrid little lying politician.
It was howard the cowards policy the drove the last nail into the coffin of gun ownership in Australia. -
@Valkie said:
The way it was explained to me is.You only wear body armorial if you intend to commit a crime.
That's why John Howard the coward wore it when addressing the gun lobby.
He was a corrupt, horrid little lying politician.
It was howard the cowards policy the drove the last nail into the coffin of gun ownership in Australia.We have allowed this discussion to go on so far as everyone has been pretty good about not getting too political. This comment could be the last nail in this thread if you continue to inject politics.
Last warning
-
@Valkie said:
It's probably the continual and ongoing indoctrination and grubberment propaganda that makes my uncomfortable with guns.
But as you say, "It ain't the tool, it's the fool weikding it"Sorry if I have offended, it's unintentional.
No offense, we're good here my friend. I'm firmly in your corner on the knife and multitool thing and can only hope the legal environment there improves.

-
I know we rarely have to moderate things but that last post (after being warned) by Valkie (and ThisAlarm7 because he had quoted part of that post) was passing the line to much and is now gone

This is a thread about knife laws not guns. (Plenty of people on both sides of that argument and we will leave it be at that) We need to keep it in a friendly tone, leaving our personal feelings and politics completely out of the thread or it will be locked.
Sorry to have to be harsh but we have had more than a couple of posts to keep this thread on topic

-
@Poncho65 said:
I know we rarely have to moderate things but that last post (after being warned) by Valkie (and ThisAlarm7 because he had quoted part of that post) was passing the line to much and is now gone
This is a thread about knife laws not guns. (Plenty of people on both sides of that argument and we will leave it be at that) We need to keep it in a friendly tone, leaving our personal feelings and politics completely out of the thread or it will be locked.
Sorry to have to be harsh but we have had more than a couple of posts to keep this thread on topic

I was wavering on this (based upon freedom of speech etc..) However, this is a non-political forum and MUST remain so, for the benefit of awl.
As much as I sympathise with others (from various parts of the globe) I don't want to be forced to close something down as my first act as a Mod (apart from removing spurious requests to join MTO) but I WILL!!!
A) Opinons; Yes (subject to "B" below)
B) Politics; NoPlease keep this on track & look out for each other.
We have enough enemies out there without falling out with each other :ahhh
Peace. Out

-
We have confusing layers of knife laws as well. My state allows carry of knives, including "common pocket knives." However, to carry one concealed (not including the common pocket knife) you need a concealed weapons permit. However, the knife part of the state CWP doesn't preempt county/city laws. Make sense?

If I carry a SAK in my pocket, good to go.
If I carry a knife clipped in my pocket, good to go.
If I carry a sheath knife openly, good to go.
If I have a CWP I can carry a knife (of nearly any kind) concealed on my person.
If I go to Miami, I cannot carry certain knives that are legal in my home city/county even though I have a CWP.Solution: don't go to Miami. 8)
-
As written that is true. I will say I used to live near the city and something small like an SAK never caused any issues. Got checked at a Phillies game once, forgot I had it, and I didn't even have to take it back to the car.
-
Well, it happened, I was approached by the police to check me out at a cafe the other day.
I had me Victornox pouch on my belt, but I took out the knife and left it in my car, I am still edgy about wearing it in public.
The cops saw the bulge in my shirt at the belt and approached me as If I was an axe murderer.
One with his hand on his tazer and the other standing behind me.
At first, I wondered what they wanted, and then one demanded I stan against a car so he could undertake a concealed weapons check.
He asked if I was carrying a knife or weapon, I said no.
He then got all official and stated that he could see the knife (not pouch) on my belt.
I said he could have a look, it was empty.He checked it, then did a body search and asked why I had the pouch on my belt.
I said I usually carry a tool at work, but as I was in public and now that we have draconian laws and SS enforcement, I thought it prudent to remove the tool while I was getting my lunch.
He wasn't happy, took my name and said that I shouldn't wear a "sheath" if I didn't want to be arrested.I thought of several comebacks, but sensibly just let it be.
No point in giving him a reason to get nasty.Sadly, this wasn't in a major city, or even a big town, just a little town on the outskirts of Newcastle.
I don't think anything will come of it, But the fact that he took down my name was concerning.So be warned,
A 65 year old, limping, old fart, with a walking cane, is considered a danger to the public in Australia.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login