*** The Dean 51 Traditional Challenge 2023 ***
-
@nate j said:
It is certainly subjective, but assuming you’re referring to the 75 pattern, then I think the 47 pattern has it beat for EDC/general utility.The 47 is 3/8” shorter closed, but still long enough for most folks to get a full four-finger grip on.
If you compare the two side by side, you’ll note that the blades on the 75 are wider than the 47’s blades, but not really much longer.
Being narrower, shorter, lighter, and having rounded bolsters (vs. square bolsters on the 75), the 47 carries much smaller in pocket than the 75 but gives up very little in terms of cutting capability.
Excellent effort Sir but 75 makes me smile.
-
@BPRoberts said:
I don't particularly see the appeal of sod busters, but, at the price, I'm tempted to pick one up just to try.Interesting,,, I always assumed all fans of traditional knives had tried a Sodbuster at least once,,, whether they liked it afterward or not.
@LoopCutter said:
From my perspective, I understand.I at first ignored the Sod Buster pattern, relating it prairie farmers, slicing SOD to make dwellings.
But, when I took stock of my preferred blade types, my choices start at; Spear Point, Drop point, Clip point, Wharncliff, Sheepfoot (lamb), and then TANTO.
So for me a Sod Buster it is a nice general purpose WORK KNIIFE.
Being from a family of tobacco sharecroppers,,, I can appreciate the association of the knife and simple country folks
Growing up in western Virginia, we were always taking game or slaughtering livestock of some sort. One particular uncle was considered a "great white hunter" and he kept a skinning knife with him at all times. He and I were very close and he taught me a lot,,, both good and bad. As such, I always had a propensity for skinning knives. I guess that's why I like the Sodbuster style knives so much. In fact, I have skinned one whitetail deer with my yellow Sodbuster. It did the skinning well,,, but boy was it hard to hold on to during the process. It also developed a micro crack in the blade edge while splitting the pelvis. No the perfect tool for the job,,, but it got the job done.
Also for me is the simplicity of a single blade. As you said,,, just a good old, reliable, everyday work knife.
-
@GA1dad said:
Interesting,,, I always assumed all fans of traditional knives had tried a Sodbuster at least once,,, whether they liked it afterward or not.Being from a family of tobacco sharecroppers,,, I can appreciate the association of the knife and simple country folks
Growing up in western Virginia, we were always taking game or slaughtering livestock of some sort. One particular uncle was considered a "great white hunter" and he kept a skinning knife with him at all times. He and I were very close and he taught me a lot,,, both good and bad. As such, I always had a propensity for skinning knives. I guess that's why I like the Sodbuster style knives so much. In fact, I have skinned one whitetail deer with my yellow Sodbuster. It did the skinning well,,, but boy was it hard to hold on to during the process. It also developed a micro crack in the blade edge while splitting the pelvis. No the perfect tool for the job,,, but it got the job done.
Also for me is the simplicity of a single blade. As you said,,, just a good old, reliable, everyday work knife.
I'll start by admitting that I'm pretty new to traditionals. I carried a 58mm SAK or a keychain Gerber or Leatherman for most of my life (and I'm pretty sure I'm on the young side for the forum). Only started getting into other multitools (aside from a Hiker for camping and a no-name PBMT under the sink) a few years ago, and only started with traditional folders last fall (thanks to a trade with FarmerX). I'm enjoying learning about and trying new (to me) patterns, but there's a lot I haven't seen yet.
I think the single blade is a big part of the issue for me. I've spent most of my life in the suburbs, and (mostly) work a desk job. My dad carried a SAK, because he was more likely to need a pair of scissors than a serious blade at his (awlso mostly desk) job. The odds that I'll need anything heavier than a 2.5" stockman or SAK blade are pretty slim. I do like having 2 or 3 blades (and a screw driver or whatever is always nice) though, so that the one that's covered in tape crud isn't slicing my apple (and I don't have to worry about cleaning it in between).
I have a couple of single blades at home that get some carry time on rougher fix-it projects, camping, etc. but soddys "feel" like they want to be EDC to me, not bushcraft or whatever. Buying one feels a little like going out and buying a Carolla to drive on weekends when you've already got a daily driver, something sporty, and a pickup. It'll get the job done, but I'm not sure it's the right tool for the job, and, even cheap, it's still money that might be better spent elsewhere.
I'm sure I'll wind up with one someday (probably this month, thanks to all of you), and I'll sound off. Maybe it'll click.
-
@BPRoberts said:
I'll start by admitting that I'm pretty new to traditionals. I carried a 58mm SAK or a keychain Gerber or Leatherman for most of my life (and I'm pretty sure I'm on the young side for the forum). Only started getting into other multitools (aside from a Hiker for camping and a no-name PBMT under the sink) a few years ago, and only started with traditional folders last fall (thanks to a trade with FarmerX). I'm enjoying learning about and trying new (to me) patterns, but there's a lot I haven't seen yet.I think the single blade is a big part of the issue for me. I've spent most of my life in the suburbs, and (mostly) work a desk job. My dad carried a SAK, because he was more likely to need a pair of scissors than a serious blade at his (awlso mostly desk) job. The odds that I'll need anything heavier than a 2.5" stockman or SAK blade are pretty slim. I do like having 2 or 3 blades (and a screw driver or whatever is always nice) though, so that the one that's covered in tape crud isn't slicing my apple (and I don't have to worry about cleaning it in between).
I have a couple of single blades at home that get some carry time on rougher fix-it projects, camping, etc. but soddys "feel" like they want to be EDC to me, not bushcraft or whatever. Buying one feels a little like going out and buying a Carolla to drive on weekends when you've already got a daily driver, something sporty, and a pickup. It'll get the job done, but I'm not sure it's the right tool for the job, and, even cheap, it's still money that might be better spent elsewhere.
I'm sure I'll wind up with one someday (probably this month, thanks to all of you), and I'll sound off. Maybe it'll click.
Sounds like a Camillus Office Knife might be right up your alley. :tu: :D
-
Day 1
Starting with what is probably my most used Case knife - Navy Sodbuster Jr

-
@BPRoberts said:
I'll start by admitting that I'm pretty new to traditionals. I carried a 58mm SAK or a keychain Gerber or Leatherman for most of my life (and I'm pretty sure I'm on the young side for the forum). Only started getting into other multitools (aside from a Hiker for camping and a no-name PBMT under the sink) a few years ago, and only started with traditional folders last fall (thanks to a trade with FarmerX). I'm enjoying learning about and trying new (to me) patterns, but there's a lot I haven't seen yet.I think the single blade is a big part of the issue for me. I've spent most of my life in the suburbs, and (mostly) work a desk job. My dad carried a SAK, because he was more likely to need a pair of scissors than a serious blade at his (awlso mostly desk) job. The odds that I'll need anything heavier than a 2.5" stockman or SAK blade are pretty slim. I do like having 2 or 3 blades (and a screw driver or whatever is always nice) though, so that the one that's covered in tape crud isn't slicing my apple (and I don't have to worry about cleaning it in between).
I have a couple of single blades at home that get some carry time on rougher fix-it projects, camping, etc. but soddys "feel" like they want to be EDC to me, not bushcraft or whatever. Buying one feels a little like going out and buying a Carolla to drive on weekends when you've already got a daily driver, something sporty, and a pickup. It'll get the job done, but I'm not sure it's the right tool for the job, and, even cheap, it's still money that might be better spent elsewhere.
I'm sure I'll wind up with one someday (probably this month, thanks to all of you), and I'll sound off. Maybe it'll click.
Feel what you are saying about only a single blade.
In this case just the single blade helps keeps the Sodbuster thin. Also being a relatively wide blade give the handle some with so keeping the blade on the correct plane or angle becomes very easy.
If that make sense.
-
Day 1
Been getting ready for this the last few months so have a nice selection of Traditional knives to choose from finally.
Of course the Mini Copperlock that my baby girl got me for Fathers Day with here own money and selected by herself was a slam dunk choice.
Second knife was going to be something not Case because Steve said I could and still be doing Case Badge.
Earlier today there was some talk about Trappers so that being my favorite pattern and having a new horizontal sheath to try out made the decision.
Overcast day walking by the lake.

-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Day 1Been getting ready for this the last few months so have a nice selection of Traditional knives to choose from finally.
Of course the Mini Copperlock that my baby girl got me for Fathers Day with here own money and selected by herself was a slam dunk choice.
Second knife was going to be something not Case because Steve said I could and still be doing Case Badge.
Earlier today there was some talk about Trappers so that being my favorite pattern and having a new horizontal sheath to try out made the decision.
Overcast day walking by the lake.

Fine pair to get started and of course the Mini Copper lock is priceless !

-
-
@SteveC said:
Nice opening shot in the enabling part of the challenge !
Added to my watchlist. Wasn't GA1dad saying he needed to do some more fishing? And Harley loves trappers? Clearly one of you needs this Fish Trapper!
-
Day 1
I've owned this shirt for over a decade, but for some reason the tag was really bugging me today. Easily remedied by the spey blade.

-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Excellent effort Sir but 75 makes me smile.
-
Day 1
Batting lead off is my EDC Chestnut bone CV Peanut. It's been used for innumerable tasks, and I even used it to gut a whitetail buck I shot a few years ago! It is one of my most prized possessions given to me by my wife the first Christmas we were married. It will make many appearances here despite the many other Case knives I own.
-
Day 1
As I’m currently traveling and didn’t bring any other GEC knives, I’m likely stuck (for better or worse) with this Johnny on the Spot (way too long a name; I shall refer to it as JOTS for the duration of the challenge) for most of the challenge.
The good (so far):
- At 3 3/4” closed, I can just barely get four fingers on it, and it fills the hand nicely.
- I’m a sucker for these equal-end patterns; something about the symmetry appeals to me.
- F&F and W&T are as expected from GEC.
- While delrin isn’t my favorite handle material, GEC did a nice job with the texturing/jigging, and I have no concerns about the delrin standing up to pretty much whatever I can dish out.
- I’m excited to have some other tools in addition to a knife blade.
Concerns (at this point):
- This is a 1095 carbon steel knife. I will be spending significant time outdoors in the sticky July heat. Oiling it all the time just isn’t practical for me. I’m concerned that it may rust, but we shall see.
- I would really like to have more than one knife blade, though I’ve certainly survived challenges with only a single blade before. The point on the one knife blade also isn’t as acute as I would prefer. However, I’m hoping to be able use the claw-style can opener as a bit of a beater blade for things like opening packages, as an awl if the need arises, etc.
With regard to actual use today, the JOTS trimmed a couple of cigars. I’m also pleased to report that I got to test the bottle opener. It passed with flying colors, removing the cap in a single smooth motion.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


I could make a lot of folks at work jealous with that knife.