*** The Dean 51 Traditional Challenge 2023 ***
-
I always wondered about the Congress grip shape. It's been years since I held one though. Yours is a good looking knife mind you and I like your reasons for getting it.
-
@BPRoberts said:
The Congress ends with multiple bumps of different sizes, and the back bows the "wrong" direction away from your palm, instead of into it. I assume it's simply the only way to fit 4 decent sized blades into a handle this size, but it seems questionable. I can't think of anything else where the handle bends this way. Other knives, axes, hammers, pistols...All that said, I love the blade combo (sheep, sheep, coping, pen) for whittling, so I'm hoping I can get used to it.
Congress patterns are designed primarily for whittling, and the combination of multiple small blade types and "swayback" frame excel at that. The swayback is designed to fit the middle of your fingers in a whittling, paring, peeling, pruning sort of overhand hold, not in a slicing hold with the spine against your palm. The types of jobs that a stockman is patterned for are not really the same as those of a congress or swayback. I frequently carry a swayback because it fits many of the jobs that I use a pocketknife for (pruning or coring/slicing fruit and cutting cord or rope) but usually carry one in addition to another knife. Well, any knife I carry is in addition to another knife! :D
Below is an example of other swayback knives that are not congress patterns, and the grip I'm trying to explain. In this type of grip, protruding blades folded into the frame don't interfere, and the sway of the spine conforms comfortably to your fingers.


-
@BPRoberts said:
Day 10Got a Böker Congress in today. This checks two boxes in my collection:
- A German knife, to represent my gradma's (mom's side) heritage.
- A nicer Congress. I have a small Old Timer one that I saw as kind of a toss up. I liked the blade assortment (clip, spey, sheep, and "pen" that's halfway between a coping blade and a reamer), but I never liked how it felt.
Having only had it for all of 6 hours, I have a theory. The conventional thought on the "issue" with Congresses is that they have a bad handle:blade ratio. However, the 47 is well respected as a great size...
~Anyone else with thoughts on the "smurf Stockman?"
I have several stockmans that is what maybe considered the large size that match the 47.
Buck 301, Camillus 66, 67?, Old Timer. And a case 18.
Last fall I scored a 47 Amber bone. It is nice. Then a CASE 75. Both are great in the hand. In the last few weeks anothe 47 arrived, another on the way. And then a 75 arrived last Friday.
I like the tall Clip point on a Stockman, not the Muskrat blade they now call a California Clip.
A Stockman should be easy on the hand, able to whittle and with the secondary blades do some detail work.
A Whittler patter with its Wharncliffe and Coping blade is designed for more detail.
The Congress with 4 blades is to be a detail cutter only, each blade with a purpose. In my eyes not necessarily the all around knife a Stockman is designed for.
But, I do now have respect for Case’s Stockman patterns 47 and 75😉
-
@NutSAK said:
Congress patterns are designed primarily for whittling, and the combination of multiple small blade types and "swayback" frame excel at that. The swayback is designed to fit the middle of your fingers in a whittling, paring, peeling, pruning sort of overhand hold, not in a slicing hold with the spine against your palm. The types of jobs that a stockman is patterned for are not really the same as those of a congress or swayback. I frequently carry a swayback because it fits many of the jobs that I use a pocketknife for (pruning or coring/slicing fruit and cutting cord or rope) but usually carry one in addition to another knife. Well, any knife I carry is in addition to another knife! :DBelow is an example of other swayback knives that are not congress patterns, and the grip I'm trying to explain. In this type of grip, protruding blades folded into the frame don't interfere, and the sway of the spine conforms comfortably to your fingers.


Excellent information, learned something new today.
-
@MTSAK said:
Took little man fishing for pike today, and we finally got into some.Little Man did good!

@RF52 said:
Opened a new bag of dog food for this little guy
I bet he's grateful that you carry a knife!

I used to have a 42131 with "as-ground" blades. I found them preferable to the heavy-handed polishing one typically gets with Case stainless.
@comis said:
Open a box exactly the way it's not supposed to...They must expect you to open it with your teeth!
@LoopCutter said:
A no.08 in olive wood, and a no.06 in walnut…

Another great day, y'awl!

Day 10
It's fitting that I'd use a 3137 to cut the tape used to seal this box...it's going to the world's biggest Sod Buster fan.

[attach id=0 msg=2427514]

-
@Farmer X said:
Little Man did good!
I bet he's grateful that you carry a knife!
I used to have a 42131 with "as-ground" blades. I found them preferable to the heavy-handed polishing one typically gets with Case stainless.
They must expect you to open it with your teeth!

Another great day, y'awl!

Day 10
It's fitting that I'd use a 3137 to cut the tape used to seal this box...it's going to the world's biggest Sod Buster fan.

[attach id=0 msg=2427514]
Yellow Soddy is so good.
-
Day 10
Long crazy day so all you get is a bad photo of one of my favorite traditional knives.

Forgot that I am taking part in the Case challenge. Very tired.
Anyhow bragging earlier about the twelve years olds great taste. Here is another example.

-
Day 10
The Soddie helped to peel some mandarins. After eating a few pieces, I thought they might taste good with some coconut rum. I used the Soddie to get the pieces of fruit out after letting them soak in the rum.

-
Spent the day packing, loading the Suburban, and driving home after 10 days with family for the 4th of July and my cousin's wedding. Now I am getting myself organized again and filling out my little planner/schedule book for the next couple of weeks to get back in a routine. Packed the Peanut like every other day. No uses other than opening a snack on the road for my daughter. No action shot since I was driving.

-
@BPRoberts said:
Day 10Got a Böker Congress in today. This checks two boxes in my collection:
- A German knife, to represent my gradma's (mom's side) heritage.
- A nicer Congress. I have a small Old Timer one that I saw as kind of a toss up. I liked the blade assortment (clip, spey, sheep, and "pen" that's halfway between a coping blade and a reamer), but I never liked how it felt.
Having only had it for all of 6 hours, I have a theory. The conventional thought on the "issue" with Congresses is that they have a bad handle:blade ratio. However, the 47 is well respected as a great size...
[attach id=0 msg=2427484]
And the Congress is nearly the same size. Officially 3.625" vs 3.875". It's less than an 8% difference, and comparable to the much loved Case 22.
[attach id=1 msg=2427484]
While the clip point on the 47 is obviously larger, the sheep's foots (sheeps' feet?) are comparable. This gives a higher blade:handle ratio on the "main" blade, the opposite of the hypothetical problem.
I think the real issue is the grip.
[attach id=2 msg=2427484]
With a Stockman, once you open one blade, the back of the knife fits snug to your palrm, and the front comes fairly flat. Depending on which blade you pull, you might get one bump around the middle, but it fits nicely between the fingers (almost like finger grooves).
The Congress ends with multiple bumps of different sizes, and the back bows the "wrong" direction away from your palm, instead of into it. I assume it's simply the only way to fit 4 decent sized blades into a handle this size, but it seems questionable. I can't think of anything else where the handle bends this way. Other knives, axes, hammers, pistols...
All that said, I love the blade combo (sheep, sheep, coping, pen) for whittling, so I'm hoping I can get used to it.
Anyone else with thoughts on the "smurf Stockman?"
With regard to comfort in hand, I think NutSAK pretty much nailed it. Before reading his response, I was simply going to say that the Congress is designed to be used in a forward (or tip-up), edge-in grip. Most other pocket knives are designed to be used tip-up, edge-out; or to be comfortable in either of those orientations.
When it comes to handle:blade ratio, my personal preference is that at least one blade comes close to the maximum achievable blade length given the length of the handle. This maximizes the utility of the knife in situations (e.g. food prep) where a longer blade is generally better. The Congress doesn’t have this, which is perhaps where the criticism you’re referring to comes from. Although, as previous posters have noted, the Congress isn’t necessarily intended as a general utility knife.
-
-
@LoopCutter said:
And, today number 10, continues.A Case Wharncliff opens a package,
[attach id=0 msg=2427471]And frees two specimens that are new to this oldster! A no.08 in olive wood, and a no.06 in walnut…
[attach id=1 msg=2427471]Barry R is responsible for tempting and sometime in the future is to be a challenge🙄
Congrats on your new Opi LC

How's the sheath?
-
-
Day 10
Sorry for being silent over the last 2 days - I am in my busiest time of the year... annual reviews :ahhh :ahhh
Todays pic is one of my largest Case knives. Case calls it a 6.5 BoneStag Trapper, but a lot of sellers call it a Wharncliffe Trapper, and it's a hefty beast


-
@McStitchy said:
Congrats on your new Opi LC
How's the sheath?
It comes in this lovely box, wooden with a plexiglass slide cover☺️ I have not broke the seal, yet!
Became side track last evening, maybe later this morning. -
Sorry for being silent over the last 2 days - I am in my busiest time of the year... annual reviews :ahhh :ahhh
Todays pic is one of my largest Case knives. Case calls it a 6.5 BoneStag Trapper, but a lot of sellers call it a Wharncliffe Trapper, and it's a hefty beast


That very pretty Bone/Stag!
And I do like the blade set on your Trapper.
I have a single blade Wharncliffe Trapper, the other r 3 Trappers are Clip point and Spey blade sets. -
@LoopCutter said:
Very nice use, Nate!
How many cigars can be prepped before a blade touch up!
I must admit that I have no idea.
It’s very rare that I smoke more than 2-3 cigars per day, and some days it is one or none. I don’t find daily or even weekly touch ups necessary.
Assuming a blade made of good steel, properly heat treated, well-sharpened initially, and with appropriate geometry to do the job in the first place, I think the answer would have to be “a lot”.
Analyzing a bit more, taking 60 ring gauge as the largest common size, remembering that with cigars ring gauge is 64ths of an inch diameter, and recalling C = pi*D, the length of cut to cap a cigar is less than 3 inches. If you have to cut through filler and binders, the cross sectional area is less than 0.7 square inches.
-
Day 10
Cigar duty, fingernail whittling, and cut the tags off a new shirt for one of my daughters.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

