*** The Dean 51 Traditional Challenge 2023 ***
-
Day 13: A couple more 2021 TdF's

-
@Barry - luv the TdF theme! But do tell me about the lower model! Please!!!
Is it still available?
I love watching the event, now more for the scenery of the country side. I have ridden several century rides, not Metric and US mile types back as late as 15 years ago.Now enjoy from my couch☺️
-
Day 13
A Crimsom Red type of day.
Wanted to show two new knives that were ordered and arrived mid June with this challenge in mind.
[attach id=0 msg=2428129]
[attach id=1 msg=2428129]My first 75, a big’im!


-
**Day 13
**



I got a shipment of 4 new Case knives and it was a real lottery draw with the lot.

Only 1 out of 4 was somewhat ok with minor uneven grind, but the rest are plagued by serious burr (see the silver line on the edge), really uneven grind (20 deg vs almost no bevel on the other side) or flat spot where some part of the blade not fully sharpened.
Having said that, luckily all the scales are alright, no crack or too much gap anywhere. So a full on re-sharpening session awaits.
-
@Barry Rowland said:
Day 13: A couple more 2021 TdF'sThe bottom one is pretty cool looking!

@LoopCutter said:
Day 13A Crimsom Red type of day.
Wanted to show two new knives that were ordered and arrived mid June with this challenge in mind.
[attach id=0 msg=2428129]
[attach id=1 msg=2428129]My first 75, a big’im!
Beautiful covers!

-
I got a shipment of 4 new Case knives and it was a real lottery draw with the lot.

Only 1 out of 4 was somewhat ok with minor uneven grind, but the rest are plagued by serious burr (see the silver line on the edge), really uneven grind (20 deg vs almost no bevel on the other side) or flat spot where some part of the blade not fully sharpened.
Having said that, luckily all the scales are alright, no crack or too much gap anywhere. So a full on re-sharpening session awaits.
Sorry to hear that. I'm to the point where I expect that I'll have to put some sharpening time into most Case knives. However, I'll take that over the two most recent Cases I've bought, one with rounded-off tips and the other with serious gap issues between the layers. In hindsight I should have returned the latter one with the gaps.
Due to theses issues it's unlikely I will buy another current-production Case unless I can lay hands on it before purchasing, which would be a rare event.
-
Day 12
Busy day for the JOTS. Opened these new toenail clippers, unlocked the privacy lock on the bathroom when one of my kids locked himself in, opened a package of cigars, trimmed cigars, and made an extra hole in a belt for one of my sons.
As hoped, the can opener makes a great box opener. It is OK as an awl, though not nearly as good as, say, a Victorinox awl.

-
-
@comis said:
I got a shipment of 4 new Case knives and it was a real lottery draw with the lot.
Only 1 out of 4 was somewhat ok with minor uneven grind, but the rest are plagued by serious burr (see the silver line on the edge), really uneven grind (20 deg vs almost no bevel on the other side) or flat spot where some part of the blade not fully sharpened.
Having said that, luckily all the scales are alright, no crack or too much gap anywhere. So a full on re-sharpening session awaits.
@NutSAK said:
However, I'll take that over the two most recent Cases I've bought, one with rounded-off tips and the other with serious gap issues between the layers. In hindsight I should have returned the latter one with the gaps.Due to theses issues it's unlikely I will buy another current-production Case unless I can lay hands on it before purchasing, which would be a rare event.
Curious what the date stamps are on these bad Cases? From the ones that I’ve bought, it seems like the older ones are really good, then there was a period of time where QC went into the toilet, and then a recovery back to reasonable standards. Not exactly sure of the timing though.
As a general observation, even with good QC some problems can slip through, so if you are unhappy it is usually worth a shot to contact the manufacturer and see what they will do for you.
-
@nate j said:
Curious what the date stamps are on these bad Cases? From the ones that I’ve bought, it seems like the older ones are really good, then there was a period of time where QC went into the toilet, and then a recovery back to reasonable standards. Not exactly sure of the timing though.As a general observation, even with good QC some problems can slip through, so if you are unhappy it is usually worth a shot to contact the manufacturer and see what they will do for you.
The best ones I have are from the 70's, and the 2002-2010 timeframe, but I don't have much in-between. The most recent ones with problems I mentioned were from 2014 and 2021. Both of those were pretty terrible. I fixed the issues with the 2014, but there's nothing I can do with the 2021 to improve it.
I somewhat disagree with your QC comment as it applies here as I've not had this issue with other manufacturers, and a significant percentage of Cases that I've purchased required some adjustment. It is very clear when you compare the older ones side-by-side with the same patterns from current times that the same level of care is not being taken in the fit and finish department, and QC is clearly lacking or the standards have slipped. I can go into detail with supporting photos if need be.
-
Day 13
'76 Canoe

-
@NutSAK said:
The best ones I have are from the 70's, and the 2002-2010 timeframe, but I don't have much in-between. The most recent ones with problems I mentioned were from 2014 and 2021.I somewhat disagree with your QC comment as it applies here as I've not had this issue with other manufacturers, and a significant percentage of Cases that I've purchased required some adjustment. It is very clear when you compare the older ones side-by-side with the same patterns from current times that the same level of care is not being taken in the fit and finish department, and QC is clearly lacking or the standards have slipped. I can go into detail with supporting photos if need be.
Before these 4 I just purchased, I have 13 purchased through out 2013-2021. To be brutally honest, most majority would have some issues with sharpening and rubbing issues (which I can somewhat tolerate due to the design), but luckily no issue so serve that I have to immediately return.
I have heard of those better years as mentioned by NutSak; however, since I have never get to experience them, I wouldn't know what to compare to.
Another major brand that often gives me heartache is Buck, which most 110/112 would have some sharpening issues. Some even have spring protruding from chassis (either when the blade is out or retracted).
What I can never understand is the Buck 301 stockman pattern, one of the blade tips has always been proud from the chassis(from all the reviews online and my own too) and even after all these years, they still haven't fixed it. Having said that, if they could fix that and make the spring stiffer (at least a 5 pull like SAK), I would have buy one again in a heartbeat, the rosewood scale surely is pretty to my eyes.
-
Day 13
Some old bone today
I*XL Lamb and a Keen Kutter Cattle knife both from I believe ca. 1930's

-
Day 13
Package opening again today, and this time it was the package I was expecting from Dan. :ahhhWe traded for the orange scaled 4137 and then, just for fun, Dan threw in the Camillus Yello-Jaket trapper and four 58mm saks. A true gentleman that one. He happens to be next in line behind me to receive the Sos Surprise box, and has agreed to wait for that to get his trade items so I don't have to pay for shipping twice. I have curated some special items to add to the box that I know he will like. If anyone else wants to sign up for the surprise box there's a thread in the Breakroom about it. The way it works is you get the box, pick out some stuff and add stuff if you want and then send it to the next person. It's fun because you don't know what is going to be in the box.



-
Day 13
Notebook time.

-
@AlanK - very interesting assortment you received along with the Orange Sod Buster.
That Yello-Jaket is neat. Camillus did those nice.
-
Day 13:
Sharpened a pencil for the kid


-
@Sos24 said:
It actually came with the stove for storage (stove fits in it when folded) and as ash pan.I know the smaller size is sold separately on the Firebox website. The size in my picture (Freestyle case) isn’t listed separately on their website, but if the x-case is too small and you contacted them they might sell you one.
Cool! Thanks

-
@comis said:
What I can never understand is the Buck 301 stockman pattern, one of the blade tips has always been proud from the chassis(from all the reviews online and my own too) and even after all these years, they still haven't fixed it. Having said that, if they could fix that and make the spring stiffer (at least a 5 pull like SAK), I would have buy one again in a heartbeat, the rosewood scale surely is pretty to my eyes.This is one area that has changed for Case. They never adjust the kicks on the blades anymore like they used to. They just assemble them as they're punched out and polished and don't adjust the blade height out of the frame at all. This was one of the many issues with my 2014 Sowbelly--the tip of the sheepsfoot blade was proud of the chassis, so I adjusted the kick with a diamond file to my desired height. Of course, that in turn will make the backspring not quite even with the liners on that end, but that's much less of an issue than the proud blade.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
