Cellidor damage information
-
Good info there. I strongly suspect a lot of organic solvents would cause problems. I have had problems with other items and insect repellent. Wood finishes are vulnerable to bug dope. If something causes cosmetic damage only, to me that seems important. A big melted thumbprint is ugly but even cloudy surface finish isn't good. I have seen different sorts of damage through the years on used knives, but never knew what actually caused the damage of course. Thanks for the input, BT. Best wishes G
-
To elaborate a bit about what I intended to test, I thought about things that your SAK might be exposed to on a daily basis. Mostly from what might be on your hands.
Accidental damage from things. Gasoline, diesel fuel, WD40, alcohol, Hoppe's 9, vinegar, dish soap, clothes detergent, tape, rubber bands, spray paint, house paint, transmission fluid, ammonia, toilet cleaner, motor oil, hand sanitizer, bug dope, etc. All these sorts of things might be on your hands. Some regularly. That is the sort of thing I would test if I can find a discard cellidor scale. I realize not everybody who reads this notice has one. DON'T take something good off a knife. Somebody has a discard in their junk box that could be put to use.
It seems interesting to me, but it might not be interesting to anybody else. Perhaps I will drop a knife and create my own test sample. Accidentally of course. I dropped an old black Tinker just this morning. No damage luckily. The test criteria would be to put a small sample of the liquid on a limited area with a Q-tip. Leave it for 24 hours and then determine what if any damage is done. Might be lots of things would cause damage of some sort. Maybe not many. I can't test everything of course. We will see what turns up. Best wishes G -
One thing that happens as the knife is used is the scale surface finish becomes less glossy, duller. It gets micro-scratches and the surface gloss diminishes. My guess is eroded Celidor surfaces pick up stains better than a shiny new one. Scratches, pores, places for dirt to lodge.
Oil and oily solutions probably are ok if you wash them off with soap and water fairly quickly. The oil dissolves. If the surface is rough, used engine oil might stain it, I suspect. Similarly with most foodstuffs. If it is something you can eat it most likely will dissolve in water or can be brushed out.
You've got a good start on a list of possible substances to investigate. I wonder if Victorinox has some sort of fact sheet on this? Or possibly we could write to them?
-
This should be pretty close…
-
@nate j said:
This should be pretty close…
-
Bravo Nate, just what was ordered. To do a very brief summary of the material, watch out for various stronger concentration alcohols. Denatured ethyl alcohol (methylated spirits ) are not good for cellidor. I would call attention to page 11 of the manuscript for concerns over various household items and their effects. Blood and Budweiser seem to be okay. Somehow those two often come together? Many of the chemicals in this exhaustive list are not something that most of us would come in contact with outside of an industrial environment or a lab. I would like to buy Nate a coffee and a doughnut for finding this. And saving me the trouble of messing around with a busted knife handle and whatever chemicals I could find. Best wishes Gary
-
I remember reading that Vic had changed the scales somehow to make them more resistant to alcohol recently. Anyone know if there's any truth to that?
-
@BPRoberts said:
I remember reading that Vic had changed the scales somehow to make them more resistant to alcohol recently. Anyone know if there's any truth to that?I had not heard that, but of course that doesn’t make it not true.
Thinking about it logically, though, Cellidor is a brand name for a family of cellulose acetate butyrates and cellulose acetate propionates manufactured by MOCOM. Because the chemistries are so similar, I have some difficulty believing there would be a significant increase in alcohol resistance unless Vic changed the scales to something that wasn’t Cellidor.

-
You can dissolve cellidor in acetone, just like the scales on vintage knives with celluloid. UHU Hart glue used when building plastic models is basically cellidor/celluloid with acetone that vaporizes when exposing it to air. You can make your own mixture to repair scales with shavings from old scales that one dissolves in acetone to a paste. If it´s also sensitive to alcohol or gasoline in the same way as with acetone is not something I can testify to, but I would not recommend to have it on any scales.
But as for repair goes, or removing the shield from a damaged scale, acetone is the answer. -
Great info and thanks for the input, BB. The idea of using acetone to soften a cellidor scale enough to reset a Vic cross is going to be something to note. If you haven't looked at the rather exhaustive Eastman link posted by Nate, you might be interested in their lab tests. It is rather dry reading, so be sure to have something liquid on hand when you start reading. Maybe our friend Nate or somebody could find something about the jelly ABS scales? Best wishes Gary
-
@IMR4198 said:
Great info and thanks for the input, BB. The idea of using acetone to soften a cellidor scale enough to reset a Vic cross is going to be something to note. If you haven't looked at the rather exhaustive Eastman link posted by Nate, you might be interested in their lab tests. It is rather dry reading, so be sure to have something liquid on hand when you start reading. Maybe our friend Nate or somebody could find something about the jelly ABS scales? Best wishes GaryThanx Bro, will read the post when the beer stash is topped ;)
-
It was a lot of "dissolved" in that list from nate ;)
The upside with acetone is that it vaporizes quickly (if you want to do some sort of repair). -
One word of caution in using acetone. This stuff is harmful if you breathe it, and it can be absorbed through your skin as well. I remember that from my college chemistry days. Use EXTREME caution with this stuff. Well ventilated areas and gloves. Best wishes. Gary
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

