*** The Dean 51 Traditional Challenge 2023 ***
-
@comis said:
Passing down from a grandparent really does make that knife that much special. Those clip points on GEC are sweet!
Agreed, but the GEC is not ideal for the same purposes as the Case and Schrade, and vice-versa. The GEC definitely isn't as comfortable in the hand when doing precise cuts with the clip or sheepsfoot either, due to the clip point blade extending so far out past the frame of the knife.
-
@NutSAK said:
I would agree that the california clip is probably a more modern take, but I can only think of a few patterns even today that have them. The number #18 Stockman is really the only pattern I can think of that has them. The #32, 47, 74 stockmans all have what I would consider a full clip blade.I've always preferred the look of a full clip blade and was really somewhat turned off by the narrower ones, but once I bought my #18 stockman with the California clip, I realized how great it is in use. Plunge cuts such as those used with coring half an apple are the types of jobs where the narrower blade really shines. I find that style is better for my EDC, but not something I carry for hard work around the shop and property. For that type of work I prefer the fuller blades with stronger spines.
Good point on the narrow blade profile. Aesthetic aside, given the blade stock and sharpening angle are somewhat similar, I often feel the taller full clip point blade height would also have a more acute geometry than the shorter Cali clip blade height, in other words thinner behind the edge. But the narrower clip point surely wins in the tighter turn. So it really boils down to personal preference and usage.

-
Day 22
My trusty Sod Buster cutting vegetation on the homestead and another tool handling the woodsy branches as need. Awl post Thursday night’s fast moving storm cell. Dropped 3” rain in 40 minutes it did!
[attach id=0 msg=2430186]

-
@LoopCutter said:
Beautiful pictures and the threesome STAGS WOW!

Thank you

-
Day 22
KA-BAR-LO and a Lamb

-
@comis said:
Good point on the narrow blade profile. Aesthetic aside, given the blade stock and sharpening angle are somewhat similar, I often feel the taller full clip point blade height would also have a more acute geometry than the shorter Cali clip blade height, in other words thinner behind the edge. But the narrower clip point surely wins in the tighter turn. So it really boils down to personal preference and usage.
You make a good point about the geometry, but to stock and sharpening angle, you would want to add the grind of the stock to the equation. The Case is slightly hollow ground and the GEC is flat ground, so that must also be considered in the slice-ability of the two blades.
It does definitely boil down to usage, and it's great that we have so many choices.

-
@LoopCutter said:
Day 22My trusty Sod Buster cutting vegetation on the homestead and another tool handling the woodsy branches as need. Awl post Thursday night’s fast moving storm cell. Dropped 3” rain in 40 minutes it did!
[attach id=0 msg=2430186]
So much awesome in that pic! Happy ST Saturday.

-
-
@LoopCutter said:
Day 22My trusty Sod Buster cutting vegetation on the homestead and another tool handling the woodsy branches as need. Awl post Thursday night’s fast moving storm cell. Dropped 3” rain in 40 minutes it did!
[attach id=0 msg=2430186]
Locks up !

-
-
Day 22.
Spent quite a bit of today driving so I can't think I've done much with this little Peanut.

-
Olive scales?

-
Day 22
Carried my new addition today

A Forge de Laguiole 1211INEB with ebony scales and stainless steel liners/bolsters with satin finish.
It is 11cm/4.33in closed with a 9.5cm/3.74in blade, and I can just about carry it comfortably enough in my jeans 5th pocket. Its form and shape seems to carry slimmer than the numbers would suggest.

Here it is lying next to a Buck 110...

I had it out for a walk this afternoon. It was a rainy day at Irelands west coast...


-
I'm having some issues posting, so I'm running late again.
Here's day 21. The Copperhead has been a fave lately.
-
Nice! I like the pouch too

-
@Gareth said:
Trangia make an excellent product.
Do you just have the spirit burner, or do you have the whole aluminium stand, wind shield and pots as well?I only have the burner. I've been looking at windshields and stuff on Amazon. I'm trying to keep it small and light, so I'm not sure yet. I already have a Stanley pot and cup set I use with my MSR Pocket Rocket stove, so I'll use that for now
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



and locks up too!