*** The Dean 51 Traditional Challenge 2023 ***
-
Day 25
Large Lamb and a Trapper Jack
-
Day 24
My two knives for this challenge

-
@NutSAK said:
I absolutely agree when it comes to the Seahorse for my use cases. Which others fit that description for you? "Optimal" varies greatly by user.I can't think of a single traditional knife pattern that is optimal for my EDC, and for that reason, my EDC never consists solely of one traditional knife.
But yeah, if whittling was on the agenda, this one would surely be one of the best ones to carry.
The other one I was referring to that was discussed earlier in this thread was the Congress.
I would tend to agree that there isn’t a single trad that checks all the EDC boxes for me either. I really like having a SAK or two (mostly for the non-knife tools) plus my PWII, and a OHO/OHC folder for convenience and emergencies.
While it may be unlikely to be encountered as a real-world scenario (outside of a MT.o challenge perhaps), as a thought experiment I would have to say that the Large Stockman is a pretty good all ‘rounder. It’s big enough to get four fingers on and solid enough to handle virtually any task that might reasonably be demanded of a folding knife. Choice of three different blades that are typically also different shapes gives it versatility. The best of these knives have handles that are comfortable in just about any configuration. The main blade is long enough to handle most food chores (though not ideal for things like carving a turkey or cutting up a watermelon), including cleaning fish or field-dressing game in a pinch. Below are a few of mine.
Honorable mention to the Scout pattern. While the typical single spear point knife blade may not be ideal, it is functional, and the other tools would be most welcome if one were sans SAKs.

-
Thanks for the additional info Nate. That's a nice collection of stockmans you have there. I tend to agree that pattern is the best all 'rounder as far as traditional knives go. Having a combination of three or more different types of blades/tools of good size is definitely a plus.
I've always been pretty satisfied by a pen and spear on a 91mm Victorinox, and then choose whatever tools I need beyond that. As mentioned, if I'm carrying a traditional knife it's always in addition to other tools, so that particular knife being an all 'rounder really isn't that important to me. In fact, I frequently choose a traditional knife for specific chores that I may encounter, just as I'll select from a variety of MTs or SAKs.
-
@nate j said:
The other one I was referring to that was discussed earlier in this thread was the Congress.I would tend to agree that there isn’t a single trad that checks all the EDC boxes for me either. I really like having a SAK or two (mostly for the non-knife tools) plus my PWII, and a OHO/OHC folder for convenience and emergencies.
While it may be unlikely to be encountered as a real-world scenario (outside of a MT.o challenge perhaps), as a thought experiment I would have to say that the Large Stockman is a pretty good all ‘rounder. It’s big enough to get four fingers on and solid enough to handle virtually any task that might reasonably be demanded of a folding knife. Choice of three different blades that are typically also different shapes gives it versatility. The best of these knives have handles that are comfortable in just about any configuration. The main blade is long enough to handle most food chores (though not ideal for things like carving a turkey or cutting up a watermelon), including cleaning fish or field-dressing game in a pinch. Below are a few of mine.
Honorable mention to the Scout pattern. While the typical single spear point knife blade may not be ideal, it is functional, and the other tools would be most welcome if one were sans SAKs.
Awesome collection :o ... you need one more for that blank spot

-
Day 25:
Cut some threads holding patches that I needed to fix some holes in my daughters pants/trousers

And yes the holes where all on the knees.
-
Day 25

-
-
Day 25
Another "I've been out all day and forgot to take a Case with me" last minute before bed shot.


-
@BPRoberts said:
Thanks for the continued congrats, everybody.
The turtles thank you.

Day 24
Couple more other Cases I want to cameo before the challenge is over. I know the Russlock is controversial pattern, but I like it. Not a lot of traditional-style folders with OHO, and I like the pivot lever over a stud, hole, etc. No particular function difference, just an aesthetic thing.
The blade on the Russlock seems like it would be a very good slicer.
Need one of them.
-
@LoopCutter said:
That is beauty!‘44 is a practical design😉 I went from ZERO to 4 in as many months.
Then there is the ‘75 model, now have two!
And I do have a lonely Yellow 18🫣
Stockmans can define a man!
I have Buck 301s, several Camillus 67s, a 66, a Uncle Henry and a few other.
I do hope I was only a minor influence 🫣
I only own one Medium Stockman but not a fan of the pattern. Too many blades for me.
-
Day 25
Still kicking it with some Yellow Trapper because as you may know Yellow Case is the best Case.
Discovered an added bonus of carrying your Case in a leather slip. Excellent fidget factor squeezing the slip and dropping the knife into your hand over and over is relaxing.

-
Day 25
Continuing with the Case cameos as we move towards the end of the month. Today, a Mini Copperlock. Honestly, not a big fan. A small single blade lockback isn't really something I have a lot of use for. I'd rather have the multiple blades of Stockman, Trapper, etc. or, if single bladed, OHO with a liner lock like the Russlock. I won't argue that that bolster doesn't look sweet, though.

-
Day 25
Cut up some extra treats for Fisher

-
@BPRoberts said:
I won't argue that that bolster doesn't look sweet, though.
and the brass pins look really good against the wood scales.I'm with you on the lock on the small knife though. I've used slipjoints since a young age so I treat every knife like one, but they are a nice safety feature when doing jobs that require a larger knife.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Day 25Still kicking it with some Yellow Trapper because as you may know Yellow Case is the best Case.
Discovered an added bonus of carrying your Case in a leather slip. Excellent fidget factor squeezing the slip and dropping the knife into your hand over and over is relaxing.


Dammit! I'm going shopping.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
