*** The Dean 51 Traditional Challenge 2023 ***
-
Badges are being awarded as they are requested.
Congrats everyone on a great Challenge. I hope you all will join us in the Traditional thread after the challenge is over

-
Day 30
Waynorth Lamb and a Voos Arrow

-
Day 30
Ending the challenge with the Pink, Digital Camouflaged, Zytel trapper 18318. Same color as these flowers. Thanks to everyone who participated, and for the generous GAWs. I think I got off cheap this year. Only spent about $60 between purchases and trades.

-
-
**Day 30
**
-
If you recall, we were doing family tattoos for my daughters birthday,,, per her request. That all went down yesterday. As a bonus, her brother from my first wife road up from Georgia and joined us. The arrows are one segment of the Monacan Indian Nation tribal insignia. It means "Came from the West and ventured North and South." I had it tattooed on my arm some 30 years ago I guess, as I was born in California and have lived or travelled all over since. Fast forward a few years and I married my second wife who was also born in California and my daughter was born in Arizona. The arrows have now become our family crest and that's what they got for their tattoos. My son was born in Georgia,,,, and is a big Transformers fan.
In order,,, daughter, son, wife and me.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
-
Very nice GA1dad. Family bonds are forever🥹
Shucks I ‘ve got dust in my eye… excuse me
-
@LoopCutter said:
Very nice GA1dad. Family bonds are forever🥹Shucks I ‘ve got dust in my eye… excuse me

-
Clearly the GA1 in GA1dad stands for Great and Awesome One!
**Day 30/Reflection
**Giving a cleaning and a touchup before putting it back in storage. For now. Definitely a knife I look forward to carrying again. I'm debating swapping it with the RR Stockman I currently use for whittling just to get to handle it more often.
This is the second or third time I’ve carried a Stockman for a challenge, and I always enjoy myself more than I expect. Having three different blades (as opposed to two similar ones as you often find on pen knives, multitools, SAKs, etc.) means you always have what you need on hand.
This month, I made myself a little sub challenge to use the spey as my primary blade. I read a post about someone who tried the same a couple months ago and thought I’d give it a shot. All in all, it performed pretty well. It’s pointy enough to get most pointy job done (although I did fall back on the clip a few times for stubborn packages) and blunt enough for minimum “stab through” risk. All in all, I think it’s a blade type that a lot of people ignore/take for granted, but I’d rather have it than a lot of the other semi-pointy shapes like sheepsfoot (which saw only a few uses this month) as an EDC. My only regret is choosing it as the “dirty” blade and using the clip as my “clean”/food blade. The butter-knife-esque shape would’ve been a much better spreader for jelly, cream cheese, etc. and would’ve handled most slicing as well as the clip.
More specifically, I’m absolutely in love with the 6347. I don’t think I’ve ever gotten so many compliments on a knife. I know they’ve had some stumbles lately, but Case, overall, still makes a great knife. Also, best website of any knife/multitool company out there. No one else lists all the exact blade sizes, handle materials, etc. as nicely. A little harder to browse/search on, but I don’t think anybody really has that down (Victorinox is closest. Leatherman’s filters are painful to use). The jigging gives it a nice grip, looks great, and handles the little dings that come with EDC better than a lot of the plastics companies use (nylon plus scales when, Victorinox?!). I want to reiterate my desire for Case to expand the “47” size line for Trappers and other patterns. The conventional wisdom that a 3ish inch blade on a 4ish inch handle is ideal for a pocket knife is correct. Small/light enough to disappear in the pocket, handle easily, and be nonthreatening (and not count as a “knife” for a lot of legal purposes) and large enough to get the job done. I don’t think Case has anything else in their lineup at this size, and it’s a shame.
Thanks to Steve for hosting, FarmerX and NutSAK for the give aways, everybody else who joined in, and Dean for inspiring the whole thing. He passed before I joined the forum, but we should all be so lucky to have the legacy he has.
I’ll probably see some of you for August Alox over on the SAK board next month. Congrats and good carry everyone!

-
@BPRoberts said:
Clearly the GA1 in GA1dad stands for Great and Awesome One!I do believe I'm stealing that!

-
@BPRoberts said:
I want to reiterate my desire for Case to expand the “47” size line for Trappers and other patterns. The conventional wisdom that a 3ish inch blade on a 4ish inch handle is ideal for a pocket knife is correct. Small/light enough to disappear in the pocket, handle easily, and be nonthreatening (and not count as a “knife” for a lot of legal purposes) and large enough to get the job done. I don’t think Case has anything else in their lineup at this size, and it’s a shame.I don't recall if you own a Copperhead, but the frame is the same length as the 47, with a slightly longer main blade.
-
I think this is my 5th Challenge-inspired purchase. This time there isn't an individual to "blame"... this one goes out to all of you that posted yellow Cases. The yellow handles have such a classic look, you awl made me want one in my collection
Thanks a lot
and thanks a lot 

Yellow Trapper, good combo there.
-
Day 30
Really enjoyed this challenge.
Plan to add a Traditional to all my carry set ups. A joy to use and just have on hand.
Here is a picture of the other side of my stag GEC.

-
GECs are something else, aren't they? -
-
@Barry Rowland said:
Just a fun pic. My No. 12 and No. 8.That No. 12 is massive!

@NutSAK said:
It seems that many of us have these and respect them, the #18.
I sure am glad I decided not to get rid of mine!@Rich_SD said:
[The yellow handles have such a classic look, you awl made me want one in my collection
Thanks a lot
and thanks a lot 
You are most welcome!

An astonishing collection!

@GA1dad said:
The Dean51 Traditional Challenge ( Case Badge )
I'm gonna close out this challenge with one of my favorites,, a cigar jack. So light and easy in the pocket today.
@BPRoberts said:
I want to reiterate my desire for Case to expand the “47” size line for Trappers and other patterns.They seem to have locked the Muskrat, which was on the 47 frame, in the vault. If so, that was (in my opinion) a bad move.
An update for the giveaway is again in order. If your username is in bold, I have seen your Day 30 post. Most everyone got theirs in before I did!
1. SteveCOpted out
2. Barry RowlandOpted out
3. LoopCutter - CASE 30 day
4. NutSAK (Case badge)Opted out
5. nate j - GEC badge
6. Adam5 - Case badge
7. Sos24 - Case badge
8. MTSAK - Case Badge
9. comis - Case Badge
10. David
11. GA1dad - Case Badge
12. Alan K. - Case Badge
13. Gareth - Case Badge
14. BPRoberts - Case Badge
15. HarleyXJGuy - Case Badge
16. SAK Guynot participating in challenge (?)
17. Farmer X - Case badgeIneligible / Eligible for Canoe
18. Rich_SD - Case BadgeOpted out
19. MichaelGT83 - Case Badge
20. McStitchy
21. RF52Day 30
Since yellow synthetic seemed rather popular in this challenge, here's a double shot of it. More thoughts (and a little bonus) coming tomorrow.
[attach id=0 msg=2432011]

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login