Reshaping Broken Tip
-
Rounded tip is an interesting idea. It I assume it'd be an easier job/less removal (blunt is a very loose shape), I already have a the small clip for pointy blade duty, and I was considering a flatter end like a spey or sheepsfoot (I've got stockmans on the mind...) anyway.
-
How about a photo of the blade closed. How much of the break is visible now above the scale? If the break is visible you would have to recontour to bring the top down or do a clip point, right? The new point would have to be below the scale closed. Think you might mess it up with a clip? Draw around the blade as it is now on a piece of white thin cardboard, then cut it out and try making a clip point on the cardboard replica. See what you think about the looks. Slide it down into the scales just like a blade and see if it looks funky to you. Do several days of thinking before you start grinding. Best wishes. Gary
-
Looks like the nail nick is slightly further back than on the current blades so you could reshape (clip looks cool) quite easily without losing that. I personally would go that way but understand why there would be trepidation and, as in the previous answer, it’s maybe not so much damage that leaving it is such a bad thing. I definitely wouldn’t get the blade replaced. :o
I ‘short’ clipped a modern one (to keep the original nail nick) and think it looks pretty good. With the nick on this one further back you’ve got more room to get a nice transition in.
Whatever way you go it’s a great knife


-
Main blade closed and clip blade deployed. You basically have to run your finger right over the blade to get it to catch, and it looks fine closed.

-
I'm not a collector of valuable knives and I'm not sure where this one falls.
That being said, if you're going to carry it and use it, I'd reshape it and not look back. But that's just me. I like using things I carry.
-
You know I like the looks of HB's clip point. With that said, I am assuming you won't carry this one even if you alter it. No doubt you have 47 dozen other knives. It doesn't attract attention the way it is now. It would look fine like this in a display.
If it were me, I would leave it like it is until I just couldn't stand it anymore. What's the rush? Best wishes Gary -
@BPRoberts said:
The tang stamp was my biggest concern as well. I'm not super up on files, is there a particular design, brand, etc. you recommend? I assume you file off the rough shape, and then finish on a stone as you would on a "normal" resharpening job.I used a Leatherman diamond file in those cases, and the process is exactly as you state. You actually can use the file directly against the spine, and for the blade edge, you can basically grind back using the same dual angles as you would a sharpening stone--you'd just be removing more material at a time with the diamond. If you have a course diamond stone, you could do the same thing really. I didn't have one at the time. Today I would use the file on the spine, and coarse stone on the edge. Then, once it's shaped the way you want, finish it off with finer and finer stones.
I like the look of HB's short clip--this is exactly what I was thinking in my previous comment.
-
I'm leaning towards carrying it at least occasionally. I'm considering downsizing some of my uncarried knives as it is, I don't really want to add another. I agree that if it's going to be a shelf queen, I'll just do the minimum to clean up the proud edge. If it's going to be carried, I'd like the blade to be fully usable.
Regardless, giving myself a day or two to think it over, and I appreciate the input.
-
I just found a pic/post of one of the leatherman blades I re-profiled. This one didn't have quite as much broken off the tip as your SAK:
/post/850595
-
You could stick some black electrical tape on there and cut the various blade shapes out of that just to see how they might look and how you like them before making any decision.
-
Oh boy, I'd leave that one alone. It's in incredible condition other than the broken tip of the main blade. This knife would be a museum piece in my collection, with those sexy tang stamps, the awl, etc.....
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login