Reviving old threads
-
It seemed to me like a lot of online stuff got a bump during COVID, when many in-person activities were shut down or curtailed. As things opened back up, the pendulum swung the other direction as people leaned in to RL activities and spent less time online.
-
nate
I spent a lot more time online during covid

-
@Simon_Templar said:
Or anyone raised the philosophical question if modding is unethical because the meaning of SAKs is to receive in humility what Victorinox giveth us and make the best out of it (I belong to this school of thinking, btw). Oh well, I miss the old action.When did this one happen?
-
@IMR4198 said:
The other forums I followed are completely moribund. Dead. Throw on the dirt. Put up a tombstone. One or two dyspeptic grumps make posts complaining about their neighbors or the weather."Moribund" and "dyspeptic;" two words you don't hear every day!

I'm awl for reviving old threads. Some of them contain useful information, and some of them are just plain fun (or funny). I will be reviving one of the latter pretty soon.
-
Simon, I think you hit very deep, almost existential topic here.
What is the cause of rise and fall of empires? Why almost every human endeavour goes through the stages of humble beginnings, growth, heydays, stagnation and inevitable decline?
For the forum - is it age related? Maybe the old members already told everything and there is not enough of a new ones to rejuvenate? Of course I do not have exact data, but I guess there are not many members below 40 or 45...
I am still very grateful that this forum exists, I remember my early lurking only days and the excitement reading discussions about the best combos, hours spent contemplating pro and cons of Rambler vs. Classic vs. MC, discusions between users and collectors, stories what sparked interest in SAKs and what SAKs means to people..
But it seems to me that SAKs and pocket knives in general are thing of the past. Beautiful, useful and great, but with limited future...
-
[Deleted for redundancy]
-
@z1913 said:
Simon, I think you hit very deep, almost existential topic here.What causes rise and fall of emipires? Why almost every human endeavour goes through the stages of humble beginnings, growth, heydays, stagnation and inevitable decline?
For the forum - is it age related? Maybe the old members already told everything and there is not enough of a new ones to rejuvenate? Of course I do not have exact data, but I guess there are not many members below 40 or 45...
I am still very grateful that this forum exists, I remember my early lurking only days and the excitement reading discussions about the best combos, hours spent contemplating pro and cons of Rambler vs. Classic vs. MC, discusions between users and collectors, stories what sparked interest in SAKs and what SAKs means to people..
But it seems to me that SAKs and pocket knives in general are thing of the past. Beautiful, useful and great, but with limited future...
Interesting points to think about.
I don't think it's age related as I don't believe many youngsters are collecting multitools. They are more likely to just use them, namely the one they were given by a family member or friend. Collecting multitools comes with older age, when you have both more ennui and more disposable income. When you are so far gone that you join this forum, you usually reached the stage where you need like-minded (=mildly disturbed) people with whom you can discuss all aspects of your affliction. This need can subside when your SAK fever dies down for whatever reason, but in most cases SAK fever turns out to be a chronic disease, so you stay at least passively interested and might become active on the forum again when there is a flare-up. I therefore don't think the growing older of members of this forum is of major importance for the slow-down.
Concerning new members, I also don't have the impression (from my admittedly rather short experience on this forum) that there is a lack of them or that they are any less enthusiastic when they enter here. I keep enjoying their introductory posts where they explain the path that led them here, and more often than not I feel reminded of my own story.
However, I do observe that after the initial "welcome to the forum posts", older members (myself included) seem to interact less with the new members than before. There is not a lot of resonance to the newer members' posts and opinions, not much to fuel their frenzy or drive them to ever crazier ideas, acquisitions or mods, which in turn inspires the older members to muse again about SAKs, life, the universe and everything.
So after a short while the new members seem to just get in line and the forum goes back to the few active evergreen topics ("what's your latest sak", "[xyz] monday/tuesday/wednesday", "pics of your sak outside" and the challenges) where the actual community seems to reside nowadays and just keeps each other up to date on their current status.
I believe that's what is different, for whatever reason, than when I joined the forum. Back then, one of the first things I did in my naive enthusiasm was spontaneously setting up a Ranger challenge, with just a few days prior notice, and there wasn't even any badge to earn for this. Despite my gauche approach, two long standing members just joined me in the endeavour and helped me, together with many members who consistenly encouraged us from the sidelines, to a really good start into the forum. I don't want to single any of them out here, but many of them are still active and if any of you guys reads this, many thanks for doing the challenge with me back then or rather for cheering us up from the sidelines. This is what really got me committed to this forum.
What's also missing in my opinion is all that friendly banter of old, the de-railed posts which just went completely off topic (if it does not have a cork, can it be a good wine?), the goofing around with, well, goofy but sympathetic people. After all, one doesn't visit this forum just for business, does one? But nowadays there seems to be little resonance. It feels a bit life-less at times. In these moments, there just isn't much else to do during the daily visit then to contemplate beautiful SAKs in the Alox challenge (which isn't a bad thing either, except that it flared-up some Alox fever in me and drove me into buying even more SAKs
).So that's my five cents on the topic (uh, more like a million bucks - sorry for the long read).
Cheers,
Simon
-
What seems like a sure fire discussion topic is whenever Victorinox introduces a new LE, especially controversial ones. The silly Paper White thing, or whatever it was, really got the group going. And before that the Model 1897 Sportsman's knife re-issue was probably the most controversial topic I've seen on the forum in years.
I wish Victorinox would re-issue a Swiss Rail Soldier. I'd buy one in a heartbeat, and then we could all discuss the merits (high) and value (poor)!
-
I think reviving old threads is a good idea. I'm sort of guilty of that already on this and other forums.
Also, I enjoy starting a new thread so that there is more room for discussion instead of messing up the flow of day-of-the-week threads, which I am guilty of as well, but probably won't stop. ;)
-
@Myron said:
What seems like a sure fire discussion topic is whenever Victorinox introduces a new LE, especially controversial ones. The silly Paper White thing, or whatever it was, really got the group going. And before that the Model 1897 Sportsman's knife re-issue was probably the most controversial topic I've seen on the forum in years.
Same thing happens when they discontinue yet another model. Although more often than not, in those cases a very large majority is opposed to a very small minority, so it quickly gets stale (how many posts in the 1897 discussions where about the price? 95%?) -
The only topic of mine that I would revive is this one, and it's still going strong after 15 years. It's SAK-specific content, so please participate if you can:
/topic/7543
-
I think this is a great idea - As there have been some fabulous threads in days of yore
What I loved about this forum was the detailed discussions on the various tool merits; threads on tool and SAK dating; the fabulous comparison threads; - Lynne Le Fey - where are you now? and of course the modding threads - The designs that people came up with never ceased to amaze me - Although this last one I think applies more to pliers based tools than SAKs.
Anyway "yes please": Let's revive all those great older threads
And as you say these topics seem to have declined :( and there are some very interesting points and discussions above
For me I do find posting photos a bit of a pain - It's a five step process: Take the photo; upload to PC; resize on PC; write post; upload piccie to MTo - There's probably an easier way - If so please enlighten me.
I certainly had the SAK fever in my early days on the forum: Diving all over the forum; constantly digging around ebay to find SAKs.
Certainly the ebay thing, and buying SAKs, has pretty much stopped for me.
Two reasons: I kinda hit my collection target for SAKs which was the major versions of all tools - say after 1945 as per this spready.
I still love the old SAKs - Pre 1960 - But the prices are just too steep for me. I guess this also applies to the Vic limited editions (eg 1897, Damascus, White Stuff) etc. They are just so expensive / overpriced - and I can't afford them. I guess for the older SAKs it is the market rates - And that is due to crazy people like us pushing up the prices >:(Note: I just like to make it clear I never even considered buying the White Stuff SAK - And, as several people pointed out - even if it had cost $50 would not have done so ;) :o
That's just made me think of another point.
With Victorinox constantly decreasing their range - There is a lot fewer SAKs to discuss and talk about - Apart from the topic of Victorinox constantly decreasing their range >:( >:( >:( -
@Huntsman said:
For me I do find posting photos a bit of a pain - It's a five step process: Take the photo; upload to PC; resize on PC; write post; upload piccie to MTo - There's probably an easier way - If so please enlighten me.One word - Tapatalk
Take the photo on your phone, open the Tapatalk app (with MTo the only forum followed of course
) find the thread you’re interested in, (you can individually follow threads or whole topics), hit reply and upload your pic. No resizing requiredThe only thing that doesn’t work as well as are the forum specific emojis….I’m sure I’m not the only one very used to typing
: like : (without the gaps)
:DIt’s free too, although better if you pay which is very cheap, less than A$20 a year
-
@z1913 said:
For the forum - is it age related? Maybe the old members already told everything and there is not enough of a new ones to rejuvenate? Of course I do not have exact data, but I guess there are not many members below 40 or 45...I’m 28.
I joined the forum during my accursed Covid unemployment; I can’t even remember how I found MTO or what prompted me to join (aside from a shared interest in SAKs and MTs).
My participation dropped off after I became reemployed. I mostly work in an office, so there are many days when I never use a SAK or MT. If anything, a daily challenge would be a constant reminder of the uncomfortable fact that I don’t really need a SAK in daily life.
-
Welcome youngster :D :o
@hsherzfeld said:
If anything, a daily challenge would be a constant reminder of the uncomfortable fact that I don’t really need a SAK in daily life.
But I bet you're glad you have one in your pocket !!
... Just in case -
@hsherzfeld said:
If anything, a daily challenge would be a constant reminder of the uncomfortable fact that I don’t really need a SAK in daily life.If you follow any of the daily challenge threads, you’ll see that there are plenty of posts with captions like “No uses today, so here’s a glamour shot.” Nothing wrong with that, and some very cool pictures have been shared that didn’t involve actual use.
-
@hsherzfeld said:
I mostly work in an office, so there are many days when I never use a SAK or MT. If anything, a daily challenge would be a constant reminder of the uncomfortable fact that I don’t really need a SAK in daily life.Alas, that's probably true for most office dwellers, myself included. But this isn't really the point of carrying a SAK, is it? It simply feels good to touch it in your pocket and know it will be there if life offers one of its little challenges. That's what it's all about. Getting to actually use your SAK is just a bonus.
To sum it up: Life without a SAK is conceivable, but it would be meaningless.
Cheers
Simon
-
@Simon_Templar said:
To sum it up: Life without a SAK is conceivable, but it would be meaningless.
- But -
-

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login