August Alox Addict Challenge 2023
-
@BPRoberts said:
That's a fun one! Thanks Explorer and comisDay 30
Opened this unnecessarily large box from SMKW.
Reflection
At the end of each challenge, I like to take a little time to reflect on the knife I carried for the month. What did I like about it, what did I learn, how did it do? In the case of the Farmer X the overall answer was a resounding… fine. There’s certainly nothing wrong with it, but it feels like (despite only being introduced three odd years ago) it’s a knife that doesn’t really have a place in the modern multitool ecosystem.
To me, the 93mm line as a whole occupies kind of a weird middle ground in Victorinox’s lineup. The 58s are tiny keychain knives that you forget about until you need them. The 91s are the flagship line, with a million and one tools and configurations. The 84s and 85s offer almost as many, in a slightly smaller/lighter package (one which really does benefit from Alox’s thinness). The 111s and 130s are heavier and sturdier for more demanding tasks. The 93s are… slightly longer and heavier but thinner than the 91s? They’re tougher (though still not as tough as the 111s) in exchange for having fewer tools. When the “Sturdy Boy” Alox line was introduced in the 50s(?) that made sense. There was a market for knives that were more rugged than the traditional officer’s/gentleman’s models, and that still makes some amount of sense today. If you’re out in the woods, you might not need an inline phillips and magnifying glass, but you do need your blade not to break.
The Farmer X still does that. It’s only blemishes are some (lovely) pocket wear on the coloring, and it took care of everything I needed with flying colors. I didn’t torture test it this month, but I think I put it through some fair paces. If I was stuck with it as my only knife/multitool for the rest of my life, it’d be fine. At the same time, I did miss the extra tools that a Huntsman, Explorer, etc. offer, and I wonder if the there’s really a worthwhile niche for the FX to fill anymore. Maybe less so for the slimmer
How often does someone really need a pocket knife/mulitool that’s tougher than the 91s today? I have a few ~20 year old beater 91s that I occasionally pull out for “stupid” uses. They’re all fine. I’ve used a Hiker as a chisel and beat it with a hammer. It’s got a little ding on the liner and a wobbly scale. The only use I had this month where I was even slightly concerned about durability was a concern was prying out some staples from an old pallet. I’m pretty sure that Hiker would’ve held up fine. The Hiker would’ve also given me a toothpick to get popcorn kernels out of my teeth at the movies.
And that’s the issue I have with the 93s. In my day to day life, the 91s are durable *enough *and more versatile, and about equally carryable, but with (by Victorinox’s count) 15 functions instead of 10. Multitools are all about tradeoffs, and I think the 93s are trading away functionality that I (and most people) value, in exchange for toughness that just isn’t needed in most people’s EDC.
And when I do want something tougher than the Huntsman, Vic has that covered too (to say nothing of the option of stepping up to a PBMT), with the Outrider. Again, the same core toolset as the Farmer X and Huntsman, and even more durable, with a locking blade and flathead, and a “real” inline Phillips. The 93mm line was something like 30 years old when the 111s debuted, so we can hardly fault it, but it still feels like it’s been sandwiched into a really small use space. The Outrider is a good bit heavier than either, but the niche of “tougher than the Huntsman, lighter than the Outrider, and with fewer tools than either” is fairly slim.
Again, I don’t want to malign the Farmer X as a bad knife. It’s great! I was perfectly happy to have it in my pocket, used it a lot, and I prefer it to tons of multitools out there. I was really looking forward to giving a 93mm a try, since I haven’t carried then much. I just think that most of the time, one of the similar models on either side of the size ladder would suit me better.
Pleasure doing the challenge with all of you. I hope to see a bunch of you over for Country of Origin next month, that looks like a fun one.
A really nice writeup! Sometimes I do wonder 93mm exist because of certain market sentiment, for example, there was a time in US where durability and ruggedness were advertised, and so these may appeal to that segment of market? A little tougher spring and pivots, bigger blade, more durable scales, it may has it appeal to the outdoor enthusiast. But for everyday use, I too agree that 91mm is plenty tough, and all the extra features of 93mm are nice to have.
See you in Country of Origin challenge!
-
Superb and beautiful collection comis

-
Excellent colours, Comis!

-
@BPRoberts said:
I haven't tortured tested either one, but the 111mm tools are visibly thicker/wider at the tang than the 93s, at least for the commonly abused tools like the cap lifter and blade. Obviously that's not the only possible failure point (the liners could bend, for example) but I wouldn't personally be concerned about the 111s surviving anything I'd be willing to throw at a 93. At least in terms of raw force. Obviously alox scales have some advantages in terms of temperature, chemicals, etc.Here are some tang measurements from my digital calipers:
<u>Tool - Farmer / Trekker (in mm). Larger measurement highlighted in red</u>
Blade - 2.74 / 2.45
Can Opener - 2.25 / 2.17
Cap Lifter - 2.23 / 2.45
Saw - 1.75 / 2.44
Awl - 1.76 / 2.43Wider tang 93mm: blade, can opener
Wider tang 111mm: saw, cap lifterI'm not willing to give an advantage on the awl just based on tang width, because even though the tang on the 111mm tool is thicker, the L-shaped cross section of the 93mm awl is better at resisting torque than the flat cross-section awl on the 111mm, and the tang is supported better at the end of the 93mm frame than at the center of the layer of the 111mm. I also would not necessarily give an advantage to the 111mm saw, because a longer tool requires a thicker cross-section to be as "sturdy" as a shorter one, due to the increased leverage forces affecting that longer tool.
In my opinion, based on tang width, the cap lifter is the only tool that is meaningfully sturdier in the 111mm line, and the blade is the only tool that is meaningfully sturdier in the 93mm line. I also believe that the frame of the tools play a crucial role in the overall determination of which is "heavier/sturdier", and the 93mm line has a distinct advantage here and not just from a temperature/chemical standpoint, as you mentioned. The outer members of the 93mm frame (scales) are nearly 3 times thicker than the outer plates of the 111mm one. Granted, the 111mm line has larger diameter pins than the 93mm line to counteract this, but strength at the tang of a folding tool can only be as good as the structure supporting it.
In conclusion, I can only say that it is not clear to me that the 93mm is "not as tough as the 111mm", but it makes for good discussion.
-
Day 31( for OCD completion of the month points 😁)
Absolutely astounding array of alox abilities
and awesomeness awl around
Cheers explorer for setting up this challenge and comis for the badge, and awl of you along for the ride .
Final photo of the team lined up, Cadet Pioneer, 86 Soldat , and Farmer .
It's been emotional .

-
Day 30
The Voyageur helped with setting up a new TV (opening box and screwing on feet). First task was seeing what video games look like on it.

-
-
DAY 31
My new favorite Alox, and I finally completed a Challenge.
I do miss toothpick and tweezers in the Alox line but always have an Executive on the keychain for such emergencies.
The tools I really like on the Harvester are the Pruner blade, Saw, & Awl. So for Jean days it might be this or one of my 111's.
Congrats to Awl who participated.

Launched from the Southwest
-
<u>DAY 30</u> (Catch Up)
Brilliant challenge and hats off to Explorer
So much Alox goodness on display here. You've awl done yourselves proud

Here's the one that really started it off for me

I was in a poor state yesterday
so didn'tcouldn't post
I present the O/G Px with my mates ankle biter "the Reg" (who clearly couldn't give a flying one ::)

-


Finally get a chance to assemble these colors together for a shot, I always have a slight hesitation for a bigger shot like this, fearing I may get some of them mixed up since a few of them are quite close in color. Hope you like them. What interesting is some colors are so dark(such as the deep deep green), one have to literally shine a bright light onto the chassis to bring the green out of the darkness. The 'mint' and 'sunset orange' colors are always confusing to me, they look more blue and copper to me than green and orange.
What a beautiful array of colors comis! :ahhh

-
Stunning, with some real rarities too!Day 31 bonus
Thanks mods for the badge! Time to celebrate by opening up another dunkel with a Vic M62 vintage ‘63 with amazingly good condition scales - clearly one kept for inspections!

-
Thirty days has September,
April, June, and November,
All the rest have thirty-one,
But February's twenty-eight,
The leap year, which comes once in four,
Gives February one day more.Why stop at a 30 day challenge when the month has 31? I don't believe I'll ever stop carrying my MiniChamp and Cadet, so, for me, I'm in for life.
[attach id=0 msg=2437850]
My monochromatic collection suits me well, I guess, as it now matches my hair.
Classic SD, MiniChamp, Director, Bantam, Cadet, Alpine Jack and Pioneer X.Once again, great challenge and many awesome pics.

-
<u>DAY 31</u> (because I'm sure I missed one, somewhere
)
Bow'lox to you awl (see what I did there
I'll get me coat 
Once again, a big thank you to Explorer and congrats to awl who helped make it happen (your awlmazing)

No real uses as such but just a shot of my meagre collection (compared to most of you :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh)
After this I've come to realise that;
-
I still prefer Alox to the other scales but there's no surprise there, I guess

-
I need more coloured Alox in my life ;)
-
We are screwed for this stuff in the UK

Stay safe people and see you on another challenge



-
-
The reason the box is so large is because of a sjambok, which is sort of a cross between a whip and crop. It doesn't coil like a whip so a 4 foot sjambok requires a 4 foot box. A folding shovel to replace the one that used to be in the back of my car, and a small stone and couple of knives (MIL K and GAK repros) to get it up to the free shipping amount.
@comis said:
A really nice writeup! Sometimes I do wonder 93mm exist because of certain market sentiment, for example, there was a time in US where durability and ruggedness were advertised, and so these may appeal to that segment of market? A little tougher spring and pivots, bigger blade, more durable scales, it may has it appeal to the outdoor enthusiast. But for everyday use, I too agree that 91mm is plenty tough, and all the extra features of 93mm are nice to have.See you in Country of Origin challenge!
And, as much as I don't know that they still "make sense" I don't want the 93s to go away. If nothing else, the Pioneer has a strong claim to the title of best modern Scout/Camper pattern. I guess Vic would still be making the Recruit, but it's not the same.
@NutSAK said:
Here are some tang measurements from my digital calipers:<u>Tool - Farmer / Trekker (in mm). Larger measurement highlighted in red</u>
Blade - 2.74 / 2.45
Can Opener - 2.25 / 2.17
Cap Lifter - 2.23 / 2.45
Saw - 1.75 / 2.44
Awl - 1.76 / 2.43In conclusion, I can only say that it is not clear to me that the 93mm is "not as tough as the 111mm", but it makes for good discussion.
Interesting the see the measurements. I'm away from home/the knives at the moment, but I wonder if the "wider" tang that I think most of the 111mm tools also contributes somewhat?
-
Powernoodle Day 30


*I opened a bag of collard greens with the Cadet, and sauteed the greens with onion and garlic. Collards are my favorite, because they retain their firm texture when cooked.Thanks Colonel Explorer and everyone for a great Challenge. That was fun.*

-
@Sos24 said:
Day 30
The Voyageur helped with setting up a new TV (opening box and screwing on feet). First task was seeing what video games look like on it.

Uh, I hate to point to this out, but the game you showed is for the Nintendo Wii, which is rather outdated and does not even support full HD (it's a great console though). If that is what you used to test your new TV, I imagine you might have ended up disappointed. ;)
-

@SurgeUk said:
<u>DAY 31</u> (because I'm sure I missed one, somewhere
)
Bow'lox to you awl (see what I did there
I'll get me coat 
Once again, a big thank you to Explorer and congrats to awl who helped make it happen (your awlmazing)

No real uses as such but just a shot of my meagre collection (compared to most of you :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh)
After this I've come to realise that;
-
I still prefer Alox to the other scales but there's no surprise there, I guess

-
I need more coloured Alox in my life ;)
-
We are screwed for this stuff in the UK

Stay safe people and see you on another challenge

Great shot Surge!

A glass half full of Alox :ahhh
-
-
DAY 31
Bonus Day

Thank you to awl for the kind words it was an absolute pleasure to host this challenge with awl of you great people in this wonderful community.

Some unexpected work and family stuff that arose during this challenge lead to me being not as attentive and responsive as id like to have been but sometimes that’s how it goes.

Well there’s awlways next yearrrr!

Ok here we go…
Challenge Confessions: This challenge has really confirmed that I’m indeed addicted to alox and if my addiction has enabled anyone else then I’m genuinely sorry about this

but… at the same time >:D
>:D

**Continued **

Upon joining this forum my go to for many years was mainly cellidor models particularly the Explorer model. While I’m still a big fan of the Explorer the more I’m exposed to this forum Im finding myself being inexplicably drawn to silver (and other color) shiny things instead

Admittedly I’ve been looking at some alox 91mm scales on the bay destined for an Explorer but that’s for another day…
Most Carried Knife This Month: Harvester
Lessons Learned: This challenge has really showed me that I’m quite fond of the 93mm three layer options. Particularly the Harvester and Farmer and after 30 days the Harvester has taken the top spot by a nose. It’s that darn pruner blade it’s just so useful as an actual pruner for gardening but awlso it’s just plain bada$$. :ahhh
After diligently carrying these 3 layer models I’ve awlso learned that I’m in need of scissors quite often. So in steps the classic sd Alox as the wingman completing my perfect EDC (for the moment :ahhh)

** SAK Nerd Particulars: ** Adding the classic sd alox gives me more tools for less weight and a backup small blade as opposed to just carrying the Farmer X so the FX has been benched for the moment.

Thank you again to all who participated and helped make this challenge happen. It’s been great fun!
Take care and Happy Trails
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
