August Alox Addict Challenge 2023
-
looks like a great trip -
with all of the foregoing.

-

Amazing view awlso great shots and uses Buzz!
Make sure to request the badge if you’ve not already.
Thanks for all your great posts
Cheers, mate
-
I wouldn'tn have wanted to leave that spot, either!

-
My newbies arrived today


-
Thanks chaps

-
Those are some real beauties John
especially that Elinox


-
Been away for a bit, but figured I'd stick my nose in to the 93 vs 111mm question.
The outer pin size for the liner lock 111mm is the same as the 93mm = 3mm.
The two inner pins are smaller @ 2.5mm.The side lock 111mm share pin sizes with the 91mm line.
The back springs on the 111mm are generally longer from the center pins to the outer, which means they could have more force applied at the end and lead to failure toward the fixed center pin. I believe (but cannot recall for certain) that they are also thinner front to back in the middle span of the spring between pins.
It also depends on which tool you are using. The liners on the 111mm are objectively weaker (with the notable exception of the stainless locking liner), and this means that tools like the backside Philips are prone to failure (see here for example: /topic/22526).
Also, on 93mm, more of the scale surface is in contact with the blade tang. On the 111mm, the aluminum liner has an indentation similar to the 91mm and the steel liners have little bumps. These are for two reasons, to allow a thinner main blade steel stock and to allow the blade to open more smoothly one handed (less surface area in contact = less friction). The larger contact area on the 93mm should offer greater strength when twisting.
All these little things lead me to believe that for most tools, the 93mm line will be stronger/more robust. But I also agree with other comments that in the real-world it likely doesn't matter. Anything I've encountered that would make me worry about using a 91mm would be grounds for a fixed blade ore dedicated tool, not a slightly beefier SAK.
My love for the 93mm, specifically the pioneer, is more esoteric (and some usage considerations too):
- I don't generally need or want to carry a toolbox. My life doesn't require it, and I have dedicated tools close enough to hand almost anywhere I'm at.
- the equal end 93mm pattern is more comfortable in hand to me. I also find it more aesthetically pleasing.
- I despise with a passion the recessed back springs on the 91mm line. They are uncomfortable and collect dirt. The delemont knives and 111mm knives have back tools with flush back springs, why can't the 91mm?
- I strongly prefer materials other than plastic in most of my EDC things. If it is to be plastic, I prefer something much more robust than cellidor. Even Nylon isn't great. Micarta or G10 would be preferred.
- I don't like all the fiddly bits that usually accompany a 91/111mm knife like tweezers and toothpicks, etc. Just more stuff to lose.
-
All great points, and nice to hear from someone who clearly knows the inside of a 111mm better than I do.I prefer the 93mm line because they're stronger than the 91mm line, are more pocket-able than the 111mm, and for the same number of layers are thinner than a 91mm, by about one layer.
-

Also, glad to see you're still enjoying the elinox pioneer! Some nice photos of it in this challenge

-
Also, glad to see you're still enjoying the elinox pioneer! Some nice photos of it in this challenge

You bet I am, and thanks. It remains solidly in the top 3-4 of my favorite users!!
-
@gustophersmob said:
3) I despise with a passion the recessed back springs on the 91mm line. They are uncomfortable and collect dirt. The delemont knives and 111mm knives have back tools with flush back springs, why can't the 91mm?Are you sure about the Delemonts having back tools with flush back springs? All my 85mm are recessed. Maybe you mean the 130mm line?
-
@Bunk Tuppins said:
Are you sure about the Delemonts having back tools with flush back springs? All my 85mm are recessed. Maybe you mean the 130mm line?If you have Evo scales, the outer two liners that the scales mount to are larger, and thus not flush to the backsprings but the rest are. With older Delemonts that have "regular" scales, all liners and springs are flush, because the outer two liners are the same size as the others. This is in contrast to Victorinox that have many layers that have recessed springs, not just at the outer liners.
-
I used to have a wenger evo 18 and its springs were flush with the liners. I just assumed the current iteration being the Vic delemont line would be the same.
I made a pic of what I mean. The left is a wenger evo s557 pic from the web. See how all the backsprings are flush? The right is my own Vic troubleshooter. As you can see only the plier layer has a spring flush with the liner. Any layer with a backside tool has recessed springs.

-
@gustophersmob said:
I have dedicated tools close enough to hand almost anywhere I'm at.I'm much the same way, especially with screwdrivers. Dedicated screwdrivers are highly desirable or outright necessary for most of the screws I turn, anyway.
I despise with a passion the recessed back springs on the 91mm line. They are uncomfortable and collect dirt. The delemont knives and 111mm knives have back tools with flush back springs, why can't the 91mm?
I'll take a look at my Wengers...I never thought to pay attention to their back springs. But I've pretty well gone to Team No Back Tools.
-

The only back layer tool that I’ll find myself missing is the multi-purpose hook :ahhh
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login